Matthew Cutolo: Gargiulo’s & The Last Cannoli Recipe

Matthew Cutolo is the Executive Pastry Chef and third-generation chef at Gargiulo's Restaurant, a Coney Island institution since 1907. He helps oversee both front and back of house, preserving rare Italian-American dishes seldom found elsewhere. A sought-after culinary voice, Cutolo has been featured on the Today Show, CBS's The Dish, The New York Times, NBC New York, PIX11, and Fox's Good Day NY. Beyond the kitchen, he creates content championing classic Italian traditions and is now building his own digital platform dedicated to his culinary philosophy, signature recipes, and entrepreneurial ventures, establishing himself as a culinary entrepreneur for the next generation of food lovers.

Chef Matthew Cutolo was halfway through an accounting degree when his uncle called and asked one question — you coming to work when you're done? That was it. No speech, no pitch. He's been in the kitchen at Gargiulo's ever since, third generation now, running a Coney Island restaurant his family's had since 1965 in a building that's been slinging Italian food since 1907. A hundred and nineteen years in one spot.

I've had guys work under me for years before I'd actually show them anything real — call it selfish, call it survival, but you learn fast who wants to be great and who just wants the paycheck. Matthew's version of that is a guy named Mike the Bake, forty years as Gargiulo's pastry chef, the only man alive who ever had the cannoli recipe. He didn't just hand it to Matthew. Months of watching, no bowl, no measuring, nothing written down — and there's a theory on why Mike kept walking away mid-recipe for years that's got nothing to do with baking. It's about figuring out who's serious and who's just talking.

Socials

• Website
• Instagram @Matthewcutolo

Listen to the full episode and more! It would mean the world to me if you could leave a 5 star review on your listening platform to help grow and expand the Podcast.

Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/55qBuFe9dQh5jLLdg0KLoL?si=08455ef88e554b91

Apple Podcast - https://apple.co/41RoTm4

YouTube: https://youtube.com/@FellIntoFood

Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/fell-into-food/

Instagram: http://instagram.com/fell_into_food

Facebook: https://facebook.com/fellintofood

FellintoFood.com

CHAPTERS / TIMESTAMPS

Timestamps pulled from raw transcript paragraph-start markers — confirm exact in/out points against the edited cut before publishing.

00:00 — Cold open: a family business, a phone call, and the third generation who said yes

01:25 — Mike the Bake — the pastry chef who trained Matthew for over 40 years

06:28 — Was disappearing mid-recipe actually a test of whether Matthew really wanted it

08:57 — The pressure of running solo, and why no two written versions of the same recipe matched

12:16 — The phone call from Uncle Louie that pulled him out of an accounting degree

16:23 — Working with family — who wins the argument when the food's on the line

17:50 — Staying true to tradition while everyone else chases what's viral

20:28 — From an internship on The Chew to his first solo TV hit

27:22 — Jarring the sauce, shipping nationwide, and the real math on freight cost

29:17 — The Gargiulo wine on the way, and why he keeps building past the restaurant

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy