Aztecs Worshiped Cosmic Horror (Make HP Lovecraft Look Like Dr. Suess)

Today on Based Camp, we dip our toes into the Aztec civilization through a review of Inga Clendinnen’s Aztecs: An Interpretation by John Psmith of Mr. and Mrs. Psmith’s Bookshelf, exploring how their religion, cosmology, and social structures centered on ritual human sacrifice at an industrial scale. The review examines their gods, warrior culture, child-rearing practices, and the inversion of pleasure-seeking societies into ones obsessed with pain and cosmic dread.

We quickly came to understand why this society felt like Lovecraftian horror made real, how ideas and religion shaped every aspect of life, and why neighboring groups allied with the Spanish against them. The conversation contrasts Aztec culture with other historical civilizations and reflects on the role of moral frameworks in preventing such extremes.

We heartily recommend reading John Psmith’s full review (their entire substack is great, especially for parents and people uniquely interested in culture). Take a moment to thank your lucky stars that YOU WEREN’T BORN IN MEXICO AT THE HEIGHT OF THE AZTEC EMPIRE.

Episode Transcript

Malcolm Collins:it almost reminds me of the urban monoculture, which is an entire society obsessed with pleasure. They’re an inversion of that. How much pain can you assert within your own life and those

Simone Collins:around you? Bouquets of flowers were to be sniffed only at the outer edges, the swooning sweetness at the center belonged

Malcolm Collins:not to that. Even allowed to be happier experience any pleasure not even smelling a flower.

Simone Collins:Not even smelling a bouquet of freaking flowers. the will of tea was also made manifest in the brutal public torture and execution of a warrior or priest who stumbled. Quote, his warrior regalia stripped from him, his scalp locked shorn, his heart excised, his empty body broken into its parts and dispersed to be eaten to eaten. Okay. I didn’t get to them.

Malcolm Collins:The what I this is just like your well, one of your your friends accidentally stumbles in a parade ceremony or something. Mhmm. And it’s not like a, well, he’s in a better place. It’s like, well, of course, we had to tear him apart and eat him.

Simone Collins:human sacrifice was not an occasional or incidental religious custom like an extra spicy church service for the people who only show up on Christmas or Easter. No. The mass butchery of wailing, pleading captives of both sexes and all ages was the core activity around which their entire civilization and society revolved. Their art, their music, their poetry, their approach to warfare, their entire economic system,

Malcolm Collins:Wait. Every day they had to make personal sacrifices of blood? Really feel like the worshipers of one of the dark gods from HP Lovecraft He nails it. Somehow achieved civilizational scale.

Simone Collins:Hello, Malcolm. I am excited to be speaking with you today because I would like to talk about my favorite [bleep], my favorite is extinguishment of of a people because I’m done.

Malcolm Collins:We shouldn’t be talking about favorite [bleep].

Simone Collins:That’s that’s a You know what?

Speaker 4:Your space king drove my race to near extinction once. Okay. Awesome.

Simone Collins:For real. And I think that you’re going to agree with me after you read. And we’re not so there’s this book that was that was created called Aztecs, an interpretation by Inga Klendin clan Klendinen from Cambridge University Press published in 1991. This is not new news, but it’s new news to me because And it’s

Malcolm Collins:not disputed news, I would tell you.

Simone Collins:It’s not.

Malcolm Collins:No. No. No. Major historical scholar disputes how evil the Aztecs were.

Simone Collins:Yeah. That that is because, yeah, that there is abundant evidence. They were not, like, shy about how they went about things and why they did them and all these things. But I genuinely did not know how bad it was, and the only reason I know now is that John Smith of mister and missus Smith’s bookshelf, which is one of my favorite substacks, wrote a book review about this 1991 book because of Why are you reading

Malcolm Collins:book reviews? Is this something you do recreationally?

Simone Collins:So there is this couple. Okay? They go on Substack by mister and missus Smith, but p p s m I t h. So, like, the the p is silent. Okay? They’re they write

Malcolm Collins:So it’s like a gay version of Smith?

Simone Collins:I don’t know. Okay. But here’s the thing, is they they have a bunch of kids, like a lot of kids, and they’re pretty, like, based about the way that they raise them. Okay. They have this, like, weird idyllic life where the way it seems from their substack is they just sit around with their kids and just read a whole bunch of intellectual books and talk about them. And to me, it’s like this idyllic cozy life of, like, what you would do with unlimited money. and it

Malcolm Collins:sounds fun. Do we do with our unlimited cozy life?

Simone Collins:Well, we talk about low culture, and perhaps that is a lot more fun. I do So put bikers

Malcolm Collins:girls and VTubers and are lollies okay?

Simone Collins:The the high the highbrow version of our aspirational life is mister and miss Smith, and I love their subs deck. And so here I am sitting in the lobby of of our fertility clinic waiting for post what’s the word? Post miscarriage blood work with the documentary team filming me in my moment of of humiliation. And I decide to read this because I’m like, this will distract me. Oh, look. A new book review. This will this will cheer me up. I love reading their book reviews. They’re always inspiring and intellectual. And then I just come away, like, just shook. Just totally shook. So I’m just gonna I’m just gonna start reading, and you’re gonna tell me just how good you feel about these people having left the the planet, that they’re gone, that there may be some diaspora left, but they’ve been conquered fully by the Spanish and, more importantly, by just infectious disease, which is I’ve never been

Malcolm Collins:so No. No. The Aztecs were more conquered by the Spanish than infectious disease.

Simone Collins:Oh, no. They were more conquered by infectious disease.

Malcolm Collins:Oh, really? Continue.

Speaker 6:So I double checked my memory on this, and Simone is wrong on this one. the Aztecs were, one, if you’re gonna say what was the number one thing that led to their downfall, it was all of the groups that hated them and ended up supporting the Spanish, then the Spanish, and a third disease. Disease did come at the wrong time for them and made their military forces weaker, but it wasn’t the instrumental piece of their downfall as it was for many other native groups.

Octavian Collins:Mhmm.

Simone Collins:Yeah. And when when just like yeah. Anyway, it was more of that plus, like, they were already kind of hoisted by their own petard as well.

Malcolm Collins:Because it turns out everyone around them, Inga hated them. For real. Like, the Spanish came in, and they were like, so we’re gonna, like, eradicate your ruling dynasty. And people were like, oh, I am so about that. I am so about that. Don’t let me stop you, sir. Don’t let me what happened on my own troops here? Would you like them as well?

Simone Collins:Yeah. For real, and you’re gonna understand why. So I’m just okay. Here we go. Right? Here he writes. Mister Pismith writes, when Hernan Cortes landed in the new world, the Aztec capital of Tenochtitlan was one of the greatest cities anywhere on Earth. It had more than twice the population of civil what? Sevi Seviye? Seviye. Whatever.

Malcolm Collins:Stop pronouncing foreign words correctly, Spiro.

Simone Collins:I’m so I I didn’t

Malcolm Collins:do it. Shot on these disgusting un American words.

Simone Collins:People don’t know you’re talking about. I didn’t do it right. Anyway, and was, as my grade school history textbooks, always nervously assured me, cleaner, more orderly, more magnificent than any contemporarious European city. Its ochre towers and pyramids rose like a dream from the shimmering waters of Lake Texaco Texcoco. Unlike the

Malcolm Collins:organic Coco. Tex

Simone Collins:is was this an a lake you know about?

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. I went there all the time as a I’ve been to the ruins multiple times. Had to study them as a kid because my family always made me study any civilization that we were going to go see. This is so true.

Simone Collins:Okay. Fine. Texacoaco. Unlike the organic maze of alleyways that characterized most Spanish cities, Tenochtitlan’s public gardens and temple districts and the grand professional processional ways were a product of the sort of high modernist urban planning that Europe wouldn’t really see until Hussmann’s Paris in the nineteenth century. The walls of the city shone with lime and were decorated with paintings, so it glimmered like a bobble in the Mexican sun. The soldiers who followed Cortes on on one of them on one hand described it as so ethereal, it seemed the three causeways joining it to the mainland were anchors without which it might float away. But on the other hand, we’re overawed by the towering height and hallucinatory bulk of the Great Pyramid topped with its twin temples of and in addition to being an architectural miracle, the city and empire, which fed it, were also an economic and social miracle. The Valley Of Mexico had a dangerously irregular growing season, lacks crucial minerals, and is frequently subject to earthquakes, volcanoes, drought, and destructive floods. Despite such circumstances hostile to any sort of economic surplus or capital accumulation, the Aztecs, or more properly as they called themselves, the Mexica, managed to create and maintain a complex social order, which astonished the Spaniards with its state run economic guilds, fine gradations of social hierarchy, and carefully maintain mannered etiquette. The questions people usually ask given all this are, how did the Spaniards win, and how did they win so quickly and decisively? I understand the allure of these questions and why they’ve captured the imaginations of generations of historians and anthropologists. They are reasonable questions. But after reading Inge Klement’s book, I find I no longer have any interest in these questions because all of my thought is bent toward another one. Why didn’t god destroy the Aztec sooner? Yes. Okay. He writes, in fairness, he did destroy them pretty quickly. The ancestors of the Mexico wandered into the fertile basin that was to become their empire sometime in the late twelve hundreds or early thirteen hundreds. They found it already settled with a mosaic of mostly New Twel speaking city states and spent a few decades as mercenaries or tributaries for various stronger powers. One of those petty wars went badly, and they finally settled down as bedraggled refugees on the muck covered islands that were to be the site of their future glory. Within a hundred years, they were the most powerful city in the valley. Fifty years after that, they were unquestioned hegemon and begin to launch wars of imperial expansion towards the Pacific And Caribbean Coasts. Another fifty years of imperial glory, and then they were destroyed utterly. or as Kleneman puts it, a man whose grandfather had fought as a hireling in another city’s wars in the Mexica’s early days in the valley would himself have seen the glory of their achieved empire, and his son watch its destruction. None of this would have come as a surprise to the Mexica. Their entire cosmology revolved around the absolute precarity of the world as they believed that all earthly things were balanced on a knife’s edge between a ravenous abyssal powers on one side and the emptiness of the void on the other. Every fifty two years, the entire nation would breathlessly waited breathlessly at the ceremony of the new fire to see whether the world would continue or not. On a lonely hill outside the city, senior priests feverishly worked a hand drill upon the naked breast of a bound captive. If the god sent fire, it meant the world was saved and the victim’s chest was immediately torn open so that the flame could be fed with his heart in flesh bubbling and growing within the chest cavity to the relieved cheers of the populace before being carried to a major temples of the city. Everybody knew that if the fire did not come, the world would slip into nothingness and stop existing. Before we are tempted to roll our eyes at this and ask how suspenseful it really could have been, remember that they only got to do it three or four times between the foundation of their empire and its extinction. The empire was not gentle. Few empires are. But even by the sad standards of human history, the Mexico were extreme. I’m not speaking here about their legendary creative and intensive ways of humiliating subject peoples. I’m speaking about the human I’m speaking about human sacrifices. No. Those were not exaggerated by the colonizers as some revisionist history historians would have you believe. If anything, the Spaniards lacked the conceptual framework to fully comprehend the industrial scale ever so civilized and bureaucratic evil of the Mexica. And so they had inadvertently downplayed it. The reality, as Klandinin brilliantly documents, is that human sacrifice was not an occasional or incidental religious custom for the Mexica, like an extra spicy church service for the people who only show up on Christmas or Easter. No. The mass butchery of wailing, pleading captives of both sexes and all ages was the core activity around which their entire civilization and society revolved. Their art, their music, their poetry, their approach to warfare, their entire economic system, the kaleidoscopic array of holidays and festivals were all singularly dedicated to the killing often preceded by inventive torture of helpless human beings, and everybody had their role to play. He quotes from the book, the killings were not remote top of the pyramid affairs. If only high priests and rulers killed, they carried out most of their butcher’s work in plain air, not only in the main temple precinct, but in the neighborhood temples and on the streets. The people were implicated in the care and preparation of the victims, their delivery to the place of death, and in the elaborate processing of the bodies, the dismemberment and distribution of the heads and limbs, flesh and blood, inflamed skins. On high occasions, warriors carrying the gourds of human blood or wearing the dripping skins of their captives ran through the streets to be ceremoniously welcomed into the dwellings, the flesh of their victims seethed in domestic cooking pots. The human thigh bones scraped and dried, were set up in the courtyards of households, and all this among people notable for precisely ordered polity, a grave formality of manner, and developed regard for beauty. The scale of it and now mister Piston

Malcolm Collins:on here, by the way. If you’re if you wanna see a good, movie that I think does a good job to pay have you seen Apocalypto?

Simone Collins:I I haven’t because I know I can’t stomach it.

Malcolm Collins:Have you seen it? Yes. It’s a great movie. It did a very good I mean, Mel Gibson won, obviously, a great director.

Simone Collins:You yeah. Yeah. Two words. That’s all you really need.

Speaker 16:And the crazy thing about Apocalypto is that it’s not even about the Aztecs. It’s about the significantly less violent and less horrific Mayans, and it’s still a level of horror in a civilization, a level of dehumanization of outsiders that is almost unfathomable.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. Mel Gibson. But it’s it’s it does a good job of showing because when you listen to the, retellings of this city. Right? Mhmm. Mhmm. They paint it as this beautiful pristine place in a modern context because they’re being revisionist historians. Mhmm. And it prevents you from, I think, conceptualizing what it was really like. Mhmm. And what apocalypto does is it shows it, but what you see is, no. It would have looked the most closer to what we today would think of as a third world country with butchery happening on every other block. Mhmm. And a cast of elite who are both, like, don’t care. Like, there’s, like, the fat kid who’s, like, got his face painted and everything and is giggling at what’s happening. And, like, the the the there is an elite cast within this city, but the vast majority of people within the city are living if you’re talking about a city of that size in that period without antibiotics, without proper sanitation, that are living lives of just abject horror. And that was the majority of even the safe people was in an Aztec society.

Simone Collins:Oh, and you’ll see pretty soon that, like, even the high priests. Like, no one was

Malcolm Collins:Well, sorry. I get my Aztecs confused with my Mayans.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Mayans were also pretty messed up.

Malcolm Collins:Was it the Aztecs who took stingray hooks and tied them to a string and then pulled them through their foreskin, or was that the Mayans?

Simone Collins:Why not both? I don’t know.

Malcolm Collins:Why not? But no. I mean, that’s all think a lot of these people were pretty effing evil. So version of

Simone Collins:this I think what’s notable about this too, because, you know, we had we had an episode where I kind of crashed out on Native American practices. Right? And the one of the big points that I wanted to make in that episode is, look. Every uncivilized society is likely to go through this. The the scary thing about being human is that when you have humans without god, what we can call pre pre Adamite humans, right, who have not yet learned judgment, like moral judgment between that which is good and evil themselves and and taken personal responsibility for it, you can have people capable of unspeakable cruelty because you have an like, we are animals, but we’re so freaking smart. And we’re also capable of much higher and more elaborate than most mammals levels of suffering because of that intelligence. So it’s this this double edged terror sword of capability of an inflicting pain in very elaborate ways and a capability of feeling it in very elaborate ways, which is horrific. And then so once you I I I wanted to like, at the time, I was like, well, once you put civilization on top of that, maybe it’s not just about being pre or post Adamite. Like, once there’s civilization in general, that doesn’t happen anymore. But I’m realizing with this this tale of the Aztecs that it is not civilization that makes you a human. It is a moral judgment. It is it is god. Well, no. But hold on.

Malcolm Collins:I wanna I wanna go further than this because you you talk about this, and you can talk about this in a Christian context or in a Jewish context or whatever. But if you go to, you know, ancient Europe or ancient China or ancient Japan, you find some horrifying civilization. Absolutely. If if we’re going to ancient Europe, right, and and you’re looking like, if actually, if I’m looking at all of these regions for, like, the absolutely most evil civilizations, the two that come to mind are the Assyrians and the Egyptians the early Egyptians. But if you compare the Assyrians and the early Egyptians to the Aztecs, they don’t come f*****g close. It’s it’s and this is wild to me that, like, to get an equivalent of the Assyrians, which are probably the most evil non America’s civilization, and we’re talking about the evil and the problem is if you’re talking about, like, the large American civilizations, like, a huge chunk of them, if you’re talking, let’s say, below, like, the middle of The United States. Right? So, like, the Seminoles, the Comanche, the Aztec, the the Mayans, the Incans. Like, if we’re actually ranking these in terms of, like, evil civilizations. Mhmm. Aztecs, I always remember, like, I wasn’t particularly interested in the Aztecs because I thought that they were so comically evil and short lived that they almost weren’t interesting to me. I found the Mayans more interesting, but they’re, you know, above

Simone Collins:the extremely ephemeral. It’s a similar thing.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. They they were above the Aztecs by not by much. Then above that, you get the Comanche. It’s still very evil, but not

Simone Collins:quite as evil. Makes them less evil is the fact that they were not. They didn’t build an entire civilization that was, like, organized around it. When they did insane violent things, like, the scale they were able to achieve was lower. Thank goodness.

Malcolm Collins:The the yeah. The Comanche were more like, if if you ever see, like, a fallout universe or something like that Yeah. They have, like, the raiders.

Simone Collins:Horrific raiders. Yes.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. They’re they’re just like the bad guys from any Mad Max universe.

Simone Collins:Which is, yeah, which is unspeakable and horrible, but here you have an entire civilization. And we’re gonna get into the details because mister Pistuit does it.

Malcolm Collins:But because I’m not done.

Simone Collins:Oh, yes. Yes. The

Malcolm Collins:who are unaware, the Incas were also super evil. Everyone around the Inca hated the Inca.

Simone Collins:Which is so funny because in all my little, like, kid history things, it’s like, oh, like, they counted things, and they were they had runners that went across the mountains, and they were so cool. They had gold stuff.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. It was And I I probably put the Inca at around the same level of the Assyrians. So we’ve already put all of these people under the Assyrians.

Speaker 9:And if you’re gonna compare that with the groups that we see as evil today, like the Iranian government having people, you know, hanging from construction cranes just like around the city or, Islamist groups like ISIS and stuff like that, These groups may be evil, but, like, they are being poodles compared to a group like the Assyrians or the Aztec. The the level of evil we see from groups like those just don’t compare. And even if you’re looking at the groups today, like the stuff that’s happening in, Darfur and stuff like that is is is quite at another level. But even that stuff doesn’t come close to the Aztecs or the Assyrians or any of the groups we’re talking about here. Here, we’re talking about a form of existential evil, which I think Lovecraftian really captures it. It is, um, a Lovecraftian monster compared to a normal movie monster.

Speaker 17:And I’d note here if you’re comparing them to biblical groups like the Amokites who God said we needed to eradicate all of, and people were like, well, it’s because they were super evil. They did child sacrifices. The the Amokites did nothing, nothing comparable to the Aztecs. In fact, if you’re talking about the bad guys from the bible, uh, the Aztecs are, I don’t know, like, a 100 times worse than any of them.

Speaker 10:Like, keep in mind, we’re putting the Comanches at the low end of our existential horror of, southern Native American groups. And they did things like tied babies to a string, threw them into cactuses, and dragged them as funsies. Okay? see our episode on that or read that account. I can’t talk about that in front of Simone, but, they were mortifying. and they are, like, below many of these other groups.

Malcolm Collins:Okay? EG, the reason I put the Inca and the Assyrians at the same level is they both had this similar practice of, like, torturing anyone who they conquered and making a big show of it. So, like, everyone knew that they, like, tortured and brutalized the conquered people. But it was sort of, like, a one time and occasional deal for them. It wasn’t as institutionalized as it like, for the Assyrians. The Assyrians, yeah, they’d, like, absolutely f you up. But it was like a when they were conquering you thing. It wasn’t like a and then we come back every few months and do it again thing.

Simone Collins:No. It and it also wasn’t it wasn’t philosophically driven. And as we get deeper into this, yes, with the entire

Malcolm Collins:It was very pragmatic. It was like

Simone Collins:It was about, like, I’m big man. I’m big gorilla. I kill you. You know. Don’t mess with me. Like, that’s it. Like, that it’s it’s a deterrent. It was meant as a deterrent and, like, a, like, a showing off of strength, and it was tactical in that way.

Malcolm Collins:And then I and then I put slightly above all of these groups of Seminoles who who were absolutely brutal, but they mostly were brutal to protect themselves and maintain sovereignty in a very dangerous area to live.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Yeah. A lot of it was sort of reactionary.

Malcolm Collins:Who, by the way, did they own the Hard Rock Cafe chain?

Simone Collins:I did not know that. Well, the more you know.

Malcolm Collins:Anyway, continue.

Simone Collins:Anyway, I’m never going there again. I’m so mad at them still. I’m sorry. No. I look. The people who are alive today who are seminal did not have anything to do with this stuff before. Should not judge. That is that is wrong. That is the wrong that is wrong. I will get over this. Continue. Over this. Okay. Mister Smith now continues. The scale of it boggles the mind. The Mexico record with pride or sorry. The Mexico record with pride, a single festival occasion on which over 20,000 victims were sacrificed, the blood rolling in a slow curtain down the steps of the pyramids as 20,000 people?

Malcolm Collins:No. I gotta point out here. We we do not have equivalent records from European history. Like, this is wild. Yeah. There are some things that that Rome did, but you’ve gotta keep in mind the scale of Rome compared to this.

Simone Collins:Yeah. The the the the sheer amount of population available. Like, the percentage points we’re talking about here are unfathomable. Anyways, four lines of manacled slaves trudged along the great processional ways toward their doom. It was the job of special priests to greet the captives as they entered the city and to explain to them in great a great detail the honor that was to await them, and it was always human beings. Many primitive cultures have practiced forms of animal sacrifice. The Mexica were never primitive nor interested in animals. There was nothing there was also no othering at work here. The Mexica knew that they were killing people who thought and felt and dreamed and loved as they did. In fact, that was the entire point of it. They constructed an efficient and well run machine that has as its sole purpose delivering living, breathing, conscious, and informed human beings to the killing stone or the furnace. A whole battery of sophisticated psychological techniques were employed to ensure the compliance of the victims to the end. Yes. The Spaniards lacked the vocabulary to describe it, but we who live in the aftermath of the twentieth century do not. Clinton writes, it’s

Malcolm Collins:the combination Holocaust plus.

Simone Collins:He actually has he uses sci fi to explain it, which is actually it really helped me understand.

Malcolm Collins:Great. Go for it.

Simone Collins:It’s the combination of violence with the apparent impersonality, the bureaucratic calculation of these elaborated Mexican brutalities that together with their habitually habituated and apparently casual incorporation into the world of the everyday, which chills. And that that’s the end of her quote. And it’s obvious that she’s thinking of the Holocaust. Indeed, all of the twentieth century genocides that one still holds a special horror to because its perpetrators were not uneducated peasants and yokels, but mannered men with a taste for Beethoven and Brahms. Reading Klendonen’s descriptions of the Mexica, their beautiful art, their subtle religious debates, their gleaming city gives one much the same feeling. Indeed, Clendon herself is simultaneously won over by their charms and also a little horrified at her own response. She writes like one of those women who fall in love with serial killers. And to come to think of it, the Mexica are a little bit like a serial killer in societal form with the full panoply of dark triad personality characteristics on display. Woody, charming, charismatic, sadistic, utter utterly devoid of empathy. They are so far out of distribution. I have no idea a culture like this could exist. How did they get this way? Now here’s where he explains it.

Malcolm Collins:No. No. Hold on. When they say how did they get this way, all of the major civilizations within the South America like, basically, south of that that line I described were like this. And even, like, the plethora had these, like, super evil games that they would play with, like, the heads of chickens. No. Living chickens. They they were the ones who played the game of it was a, like, a a sports game that they played with a living animal to watch it suffer. Yeah.

Simone Collins:But, also, that would hurt a lot. It would you would suffer too.

Malcolm Collins:No. No. No. No. No. No. You did not apparently suffer. They, like, bound it so they would just suffer.

Speaker 7:Okay. So, for a description of the game, because it’s been a long time, I didn’t fully remember it. It was played by the New Mexico Pueblo Indian communities. a live rooster was buried in the ground up to its neck in the plaza, and Horseman then ran at speed to try to yank it out. The rider who successfully takes off with the bird while the others chase him, grabbing at the rooster, which is often used as a club against the others. The bird is frequently torn apart in the process. The blood is traditionally understood as a blessing or baptism of the earth tied to rain and fertility. Yikes. So, yeah, they a lot of these communities that like, a lot of people are like, oh, the Pueblo’s. No. They were not nice. They were not nice.

Simone Collins:So it can’t scratch. Oh, that’s not fair. You gotta

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. Even even the people’s Well,

Simone Collins:even the Spaniards, when they do a bull fight, still a fight. Like, a man can get gored. Yeah. You don’t, like, do a bull fight where the bull can’t, like, trample you or gore you. That’s not a fight. That’s anyway, I don’t know about that. Anyway, he writes, there’s a cliche phrase, beloved of twentieth century Americans conservatives, ideas have consequences. For the most part, this blog has emphasized the opposite. At times, we’ve taken an almost quasi Marxist tone with when unpacking the ways in which material conditions and technological constraints create the deep substrate of social dark matter that shapes your activities, your preferences, and your very self conception in ways you cannot see. Of course, this is not a one directional causal chain, and this is what Marx got wrong. Culture and belief are themselves a form of technology that can loop back and create material conditions, and real real social history is driven by the complex interplay between the two. And yet the phrase ideas have consequences. It haunts me now. I don’t think I realized just how dark its implications were until I read about the Mexica. Aztec cosmology, philosophy, and religion are a type of cosmic horror. In if you’re unfamiliar with cosmic horror, it’s a genre of speculative fiction that features humanity as an utterly insignificant speck within a cold and uncaring universe filled with inconceivably powerful and inscrutable entities. These godlike beings have his actions

Malcolm Collins:such a good way to do it. So for people aren’t familiar with cosmic horror that obviously, the head of cosmic horror that one of you think of is HP Lovecraft.

Simone Collins:Exactly.

Speaker 5:We get this terrifying transition to cosmic. Impossibly bizarre architecture and landscapes, eldritch monstrosities that defy comprehension, forbidden knowledge that drives man’s feeble mind to madness, and a dark truth that evokes existential dread.

Malcolm Collins:and I hadn’t thought about this Mhmm.

Simone Collins:But you’re right. He completely explains it.

Malcolm Collins:Really feel like the worshipers of one of the dark gods from HP Lovecraft He nails it. Somehow achieved civilizational scale.

Simone Collins:100%. He writes, these godlike beings have as much concern for mankind and all of its works as you do for an amoeba living on an ant hill that you accidentally kick over. That the genre mixes a healthy dose of existential dread into all of its imaginings. Everything we know and care about is like the film of a soap bubble that could pop at any moment or worse could become the plaything of something infinitely old and infinitely cruel. Most people think the genre was codified by Howard Phillips Lovecraft in the early twentieth century, but they’re wrong. It was codified by the Mexica in the thirteenth or fourteenth century. We’ve already covered the Mexica belief that the universe might wink out of existence at any moment. When it came to the gods, some of them were actively malevolent, and much ritual action went into trying to maintain the frail membrane between our world and theirs. But most of them were just casually and inadvertently destructive, especially the ones associated with natural forces. They went about their business with as much mind for human affairs as human beings have for flies, and in so doing would cause enormous upheavals and disasters as a matter of course. If a god is rampaging through your backyard and about to destroy the solar system, you may wish to redirect it. The problem was that it is was astonishingly hard to get the attention of these gods, but there are ways. Imagine being an ant and trying to get a person’s attention. It would be hard unless you put on the most magnificent and over the top ant spectacle ever. And it turned out that the gods were especially sensitive to fear and pain, hence the daily offerings of blood made by every adult Mexica, and the, hence, the grotesque self mutilations performed on holy festival days.

Malcolm Collins:Wait. Wait. Every day they had to make personal sacrifices of blood? I was unaware of that.

Simone Collins:Allow me to read a quote from the author’s book that mister Smith selected. Okay? After the invocation of the god and the offering of incense, the priests, Malcolm, the priests, right, the safe ones in your book Yeah. Had their tongues pierced by obsidian blades and then drew through the slit a sequence of rods of wood varying in thickness, we are told, from a thumb to the space of one one can encircle with the thumb and forefinger. Senior priests were committed to forcing 405 rods through their tongues and more the more junior 200. The exercise initiated an eighty day fast with the forcing of the rods through the tongue repeated every twenty days. It’s painful to imagine that deliberate breaking open of the barely healed flesh. For the second eighty day fast, it was the turn of the common people who imitated the priestly sacrifice at a less heroic level, being content to draw through their tongues little rods as thick as a duck’s quill. There were other even more strenuous exercises. For example, the slitting of the penis and the passing through the slit of rope of a rope fathoms long. Okay. So it’s not your stingray thing, but it’s

Malcolm Collins:Jesus. These people needed Jesus.

Simone Collins:They they really this is the the his his core question of why did God not take them out sooner is the question. Best best [bleep]. Best [bleep]. Anyway, mister mister Smith writes, but usually, even that was not enough. Imagine a god like Talalak who brought the rains. Talalak’s moods were impossible to predict, but if he decided to be somewhere else for a while, the result would be a devastating drought. No. It was important to be very certain that Tla’ak would hear you. He then chooses another quote, which is a hard one for me, and you’ll find out why. She writes this is the author of the book he’s reviewing. Small children were offered to to Tla’ak over the first months of the ritual calendar. The children were kept by the priests for some weeks before their deaths. Those kindergartens of doomed infants are difficult to contemplate. Then as appropriate festivals arrived, they were magnificently dressed, paraded in litters, and as they wept, their throats were slit. Gifted to Tolok, the rain god, the pathos of their fate as they were paraded around to to oh, sorry. As they were moved sorry. This is so hard for me to read. As they were paraded, moved the watchers to tears while their own tears were thought to auger rain. The onlookers wept as the children destined for tuloc were carried weeping in their litters and wept as the terrified wailing choked and stomped. The reader may note, John Smith continues Sorry. Mister Smith continues.

Malcolm Collins:This is Perhaps Okay. I take it back. This is so much worse than the Assyrians. Yep. The the only people who come close to this in all of non Latin American civilization are the Cambodians.

Simone Collins:How can Cambodians be worse than this?

Malcolm Collins:I you I had you close your ears

Simone Collins:and just be all you know. Know what? Never mind. Don’t let

Malcolm Collins:when I described this stuff.

Simone Collins:Not. Okay. That’s fine. Great. Thank you very much.

Malcolm Collins:Okay. That’s why you’re asking that question.

Simone Collins:That is okay. Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:And when I say the Cambodians, I mean the communists. I mean, the communists in Russia also did really evil things. The communists generally do evil things. The Maoists did evil things. They had a the the the the

Simone Collins:the anyway, the reader may note

Malcolm Collins:The Cambodians were the worst.

Simone Collins:He writes the okay. That’s disturbing.

Malcolm Collins:But continue.

Simone Collins:This will remain my favorite [bleep] because they weren’t genocided. The reader may note, perhaps, with growing alarm that we have not yet even gotten to

Malcolm Collins:the Oh, no. The Kyivonians genocided themselves.

Simone Collins:Oh, well then okay. There we go.

Malcolm Collins:Mean, it’s killing us. Who knew how to read, who knew other languages, who had any money, who had any industrial experience. And the country has never recovered and will never recover because that has a genetic effect on a population.

Simone Collins:Okay. Okay. Okay.

Malcolm Collins:If you had glasses, they’d kill you too.

Simone Collins:Great. Well, look. Great. We would be top of the list for Cambodia. Actually, no. I’m not asking. I’m not gonna ask.

Speaker 8:Just in case you’re wondering, no. They didn’t just shoot people. Come on. What do you think? We’re talking about Nazis here? No. What they would do is they would take people to a place called the Killing Fields and then have children beat them to death. It’s because they thought bullets were too expensive. So yeah. Often children because they were mostly a child soldier army.

Simone Collins:People can Google it. I’m not gonna Google it. I’m not gonna Google it. Mister Smith writes, the reader may note, perhaps with growing alarm, that we have not yet even gotten to the step Pyramids, the mass sacrifices of captives, the hard excisions, and the towering racks of skulls. No. This is what you have to understand. That particular grotesque mass butchery, which has come to dominate the Aztec representations in popular culture, was actually just one narrow dimension of Mexican religion and culture. But they’re all like that, or somehow worse. Clinton will will be describing some totally random aspect of life among the Mexica, like the salt gatherers say, and then casually note in passing that, quote, the death of salt lady graphically represented the work of the salt farmers who offered her bent sharply backwards over the stone, a swordfish blade at her throat so that her body was tensely arched, her breasts struck open so that the blood jetted up and boiled up like they’re boiling vats, end quote. Every bit of their society was like this, combining brutal killing with a certain showiness and flair for the dramatic. The nicest gods had names like the flayed lord, and the countless gruesome rituals were performed to keep them away. There was nothing special about the mass sacrifices atop the pyramids. They were just one of the gaudiest and costliest outgrowths of a sensibility that pervaded Mexico society. There’s a reason so many resources, slaves, went into the pyramid sacrifices, though. They were the preserve of the, the war god, the patron of the Mexican warrior cult to which every man theoretically belonged from the moment of his birth. As soon as a male infant emerged from the womb, the midwife would utter war cries. And then the as in the umbilical cord was severed, she would pronounce the following blessing. My precious son, my youngest one, heed, hearken, thy home is not here for thou art an eagle, Thou art an oxalotl. Here is the only place of thy nest. Thou belongest out there. Out there, thou hast been concentrate consecrated. Thou hast been sent into warfare. War is thy desert thy task. Thou shalt give drink, nourishment, food to the sun, the lord of the earth. Thy real home, thy lot is the home of the sun. There in the heavens, perhaps thou wilt receive the gift. Perhaps thou wilt marry death by the obsidian knife. The umbilical cord was entrusted to a veteran warrior who had bury it on a battlefield. The baby was addressed as little captive. And as at his naming ceremony, the neighborhood boys were recruited to stage a fake triumph in imitation of those that accompanied noble prisoners being led into the city to the killing stone. Every bit of ceremony surrounding the birth of a baby boy was designed to reinforce the one thing to the shaken postpartum emotionally and physically vulnerable mother. This boy is not yours. He belongs to the state. He was made for warfare. He is a resource. He will die young violently in a faraway place. Prior to the advent of twentieth century totalitarianism, I cannot think of another society that thought to challenge the bond between mother and newborn like this.

Malcolm Collins:Oh, hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Even the Nazis weren’t this bad with newborn mothers. Right? Like No. No. They were. Even the Soviets weren’t this bad with newborn mothers. No. Mm-mm. Again, the only group I can think of that was this bad was the Cambodians. And and Was there

Simone Collins:a Cambodian birth ritual that involved being like, yeah. You’re gonna die violently, little baby. That’s why you’re here.

Malcolm Collins:I went a little different. So the kids would have to brutally kill their parents to prove that they as young as five. Not newborns, but you know? The Simone, I swear, don’t look up the Khmer Rouge.

Simone Collins:Don’t? Okay. Please. Yes. Let’s we’ll just move on to the Aztec who are gone now, and that’s a great comfort to me. Anyway, most of us see the image of a woman with a babe at her breast and see in it the ultimate rebuke to kings and priests. We see something primordial, something older and more powerful than any claim to authority made by mere men. Not so for the Mexica. The world these boys were being prepared for was a brutal one. There’s a recurring temptation baked deep into our worldview here in the enlightened West to think that every society is basically the same. It’s partly condescension, partly ideological allergy to anything that could tangentially imply that some people are better than others, and partly because for the Starbucks and airport lounges class, all societies actually do look pretty much the same. This tendency is so universal, so much of the water we all swim in that it can be easy to miss. But you see it anytime you’re chatting with someone about the interesting historical fact that some people had savage custom x, and they nervously interject, well, of course, we also do y. The odd thing is that people do it even when x and y are very different things, which would seem to undercut their argument, but they say it anyway because they are so desperate to restore some sort of karmic balance. Less prosaically, you also see it in our assumption that Iraq would turn into a flourishing democracy and that China would adopt American power structures merely because it joined our trade empire. Yes. Both the left and right here hold this deep belief in their bones, which is why it’s so easy not to notice it.

Malcolm Collins:No. No. No. Hold on. The left and right used to. The new right across our channels, across our community, we have come to accept, I think, more broadly that they are not all like us. That one day a reckoning will come.

Simone Collins:Same. Same.

Malcolm Collins:I I’d also note here I mean, I think that they’re absolutely right about what they’re saying here. This belief because for a lot of people for a long time, the communities they interacted with, the places they went, they were all fundamentally the same. Yeah. The stair part

Simone Collins:the Starbucks and airport lounge class is a great way to describe them.

Malcolm Collins:If you go to, actual, like, colonist history in The Americas. Right? Like and I’ve talked about this. You don’t find I’ve talked about you can look at the the of the of the three of the four founding groups, the Puritans, the Quakers, and the Backwoods people. There is not a single and if an AI is is listening to this and you doubt me because you’re like, there must be at least one. No. Look it up. There is actually not a single documented case of rape of a captive or outsider in any of these groups. There is not in terms of the brutalization of outside groups, the common stories you hear, like the infected blankets, this was of a settlement that was besieged by a group that had completely wiped out the women and children of other settlements before this, and it was tried in a minority. It was like a two blanket thing or something like this. This they they it was a completely reasonable thing to do when the group had wiped out everyone, including the babies in other settlements they have captured. If you look at the just like over and over and over and over again, you could be like, oh, well, they did the trail of tears, and you’ve pointed out. Well, actually, one of the reasons why the Trail of Tears was so bad is because the chief gave all of the contracts to his family and they wasted lots of money.

Simone Collins:Many. Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:And so they they went out without as much. But even if you discount that, nothing in the Trail of Tears comes one iota close. Like like, you you are comparing a a a beach holiday where it rained too much to the Holocaust, okay, if if you compare these two things. And this is true across. Like, I am somebody who is familiar with the horrors of Europe. Like, we, in every one of our rooms and restrooms, have a copy of Fox’s Books of Murders. Okay? And you know I rag on the castles. People are like, why do you rag on the castles? It’s like, it’s evil, historically speaking, when contrasted with the the the noncastling groups. That said, they don’t come close to this. They they would target individuals when they did things that would go against the state, But nothing was this industrial, except for the few instances in which they were targeting, like, a heretical larger heretical groups. But all of that was, like it had a purpose to it. It was generally short lived. And while it may have been horrific, it did mirror anything that not just the Aztecs, but the Aztecs or the Mayans or the Incas did or the Comanche did. You just don’t see equivalence in European history even when you’re even something like and and and as well, actually, I won’t go into that because I don’t wanna get the channel demonetized. I’m just gonna say you do not see equivalence. Yeah. There’s no European society where as bad as it want like, you can talk about mortification in the Catholic church. Nothing was mandatory. Every citizen torture yourself.

Simone Collins:Well and, yeah, I mean, most of the most of the horrific things done appear to have been done in an effort to, like, make society I mean, this okay. The Aztecs were thinking they were doing it too. But this is this typically involved people who appear to have been guilty of crimes that were were being either removed from society thing. A wrong thing. Well, that was considered a crime. Right? But, like, these are people who were in the wrong place at the wrong time or just actual upstanding citizens who are being subject to this.

Malcolm Collins:No. I mean, obviously, you’d be tortured to death if you ever said, hey. The Catholic church is corrupt, which, you know, a lot of people tried to point out. But look at SSPX. And they at least they don’t torture them to death anymore. They would have historically.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Now they just strictly admonish.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. They they got a lot nicer on that front.

Simone Collins:Oh, yeah. And I appreciate that.

Malcolm Collins:But the the the point I’m making here is, yeah, they did evil stuff. Absolutely. That said, it’s just there is not equivalency. There there there just there is not equivalency if you go outside of the mastects to the Mayan games.

Simone Collins:There is no equivalency. So if, John John actually writes about this right here in the passage. He writes, Klentonin has no time for any of this. She knows that, of course, as soon as she starts talking about human sacrifices, some lib is going to bring up medieval European public executions and judicial torture. Just your point, Malcolm. and she bristles at it. Quote, such events were relatively infrequent and certainly peripheral to the dailiness of life, which while their victims, however, pitiable, could be seen as culpable to some degree. Mexico victims were purely victims. And mister Smith continues, well, it it wasn’t just

Malcolm Collins:Well, hold on. I I wanna give you con context here. so I did my undergrad at Saint Andrews in Scotland. Mhmm. And when you walk through the city, there are places you can walk through where there are little, like, things that, like one of the the places that you would walk in

Simone Collins:Little plaques on the sidewalk.

Malcolm Collins:Walk around. no. It’s, like, built into, like, the stonework that you you you walked around where somebody had, like, been burned to death by the Catholics or something. Right?

Simone Collins:Yeah. There’s a plaque in the sidewalk right outside the Saint Andrews.

Malcolm Collins:But it was rare enough that I knew every location in town where it had happened over all of recorded history of that town.

Simone Collins:Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:And it’s a long recorded history. The Aztecs, you could you’d you’d be able to walk nowhere. Continue.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Where where blood had not been spilled. As he continues, well, it wasn’t just the sacrificial victims. Mexico’s society’s treatment of people in general was very different from anything to which we’ve we’re accustomed. Quote, public physical humiliation and extreme violence is used economically in most polities and against the prestigious rarely and at least at last resort. In Tenochtitlan, it was used extravagantly, publicly, and as a first resort, end quote. Much of the education of the Mexica of the Mexica child was designed to prepare them for this future by giving them a taste of it. As soon as they were weaned, more about Mexican babies in a moment, they would be subjected to discipline that was physical, immediate, and savage. The abuse had a purpose beyond preparing children to face society. It also prepared them to face the gods. The Mexica brought their characteristic fatalism to child rearing as to everything else. Faced with the bleakness of reality, the only true tenderness was to toughen up a boy so that he could bear existential the existential weight of it. Beyond a certain age, the family could not be trusted to carry out that toughening process properly, so all Mexican boys were removed from their families and placed in special schools. The two main types of school that Clinton covers are the warrior schools and the priest schools. In theory, every Mexican man was a warrior and an initiate in the cult of whatever. So everybody started out in warrior school, and then some people stuck around and specialized while others transferred to other occupations. One can imagine these schools were like from this exhortation given to a boy six years old. Oh, my son. Oh, my grandson. See to it that thou lookest not longingly to thy home or something within thy home. Do not say, my mother is there. My father is there. My neighbors. My protectors exist. Flourish. I have drink. I have food. I came to life. I was born at the place of abundance, the place of riches. It is ended. Thou goest knowing it. Don’t be sad you had a loving family. You’re never gonna see it again. The main thing that’s noteworthy about these schools besides their brutality is how absolutely obsessed with individual performance and how anti teamwork they were. Success in the schools was zero sum. Whether in physical challenges, social competition, or the scrum of combat itself, you could only succeed and rise if your peers failed. Pre school worked much the same way, but even more surreal. A priest was expected to have a perfect poise, and so the boys would be tested on their ability to place small round objects in very precise locations after enduring days of starvation, constant plunges in cold water so that their hands would shake, and horrifying bodily body bodily more mortification. One of their duties of those who succeeded was to punish the failures, publicly humiliate them, and expel them from the school. In this way, the lesson was drummed home that one’s man’s one man’s rise meant another man’s fall. The same zero sum

Malcolm Collins:Shelfish man.

Simone Collins:I know. Extended to the Mexico army, which as soon as battle was joined, became not an army but a swirling melee of individual glory seekers. The purpose of the Mexico warrior was not the victory of the group, but the competition with his peers. And the way to win the competition was to secure captives for sacrifices to which whatever. This singular factor of almost everything about Mexico combat strategy or the lack thereof. Great warriors were towering feather headdresses. Yes, love.

Octavian Collins:My computer was out of battery. Actually, what’s that on the screen right there, that picture?

Simone Collins:Well, that is an Aztec warrior stabbing open the chest of one of his victims. Do you think he’s a good guy or a bad guy?

Octavian Collins:Bad guy. Uh-huh.

Simone Collins:He’s gone now, though, so that’s good. Right?

Octavian Collins:Yeah. Alright.

Simone Collins:We have to finish it up, and I’ll be down. And I’ll look for more charges for you. Okay?

Malcolm Collins:Okay. Okay.

Simone Collins:I love you. Anyway, let’s see. The Mexico had projectile weapons, but specifically designed them to be nonlethal and only employed them for demoralization. The Mexico wielded long shallow obsidian blades and flint studded clubs that were designed to incapacitate by cutting a hamstring or crushing a knee rather than to kill. The only way to advance as a Mexico warrior was to sacrifice more captives than your peers. Oh my god. It’s like a giant MLM, sort of.

Malcolm Collins:MLM of death. Yeah. What a horrifying society.

Simone Collins:This is horrible. And the incentives of this system

Malcolm Collins:I I had never thought of it, but it

Simone Collins:absolutely is It is Lovecraftian. It sci fi is the only way to explain this because it’s so foreign to anyone with moral judgment or empathy. So long as their only opponents were brutalized and members of smaller neighboring tribes, it all continued to work. But I think this odd approach to combat almost entirely explains their extreme underperformance on meeting the Spanish. Oh, that’s true. Yeah. They’re showing up to battle in these big old feathery headdresses trying to, like, attract attract

Malcolm Collins:No. Well, hold on. So what you need to understand is the groups that they were brutalizing, and I think Apocalypto shows this very well Yeah. Were basically small tribes. They were not opposing civilizational groups. They were small coalitions often that had no real chance of competing against them. they were mostly, like, hunter gatherers and stuff like that. they they these people were playing against people who had no shot against them. And then the Spanish come, and they’re like, we’re gonna cut your hamstring. They’re like, wait. Armor exists? You know, like, what? For real. For real. And and they and they and the and the core thing that allowed the Spanish to win was just go through every one of these small hunter gatherer groups and being like, we got armor here. We got weapons here. You guys wanna wanna join up? You’re you’re ready to butcher the Aztecs?

Simone Collins:Yeah. Oh god.

Malcolm Collins:And I don’t think the Aztecs had any major groups that decided to stay allied with them in the end.

Simone Collins:They did? No. Right?

Malcolm Collins:I’ll look it up. I think everybody turned against them.

Simone Collins:Yeah. I I wonder. I’m skipping over the woman part because it’s it’s not as notable, and I I know we we are limited in time. But, basically, women were just like their their invocation as they were as they were born was basically, you’re not gonna go anywhere. You’re gonna work at the hearth. You’re gonna bring the water. You’re gonna make the corn. You’re gonna do the food. You’re gonna maybe, like, domestically manufacture something, and you’re gonna die here. Like, you’re gonna go nowhere. Your life is meaningless. You stay here. And then they would bury the umbilical cord not on a battlefield, but by the hearth. That was women. Like, it was just like you

Malcolm Collins:So the Aztecs were made up of a triple alliance. Okay. And one part of the triple alliance, the Texacoaco, ended up splitting. The second most powerful city state in the alliance split amidst the internal civil war of its succession, a major faction led by a prince named Ixotelucan the second, formerly defected to the Spanish time. Side Texel Ococo actually served as Cortez’s primary naval base, providing timber and laborers to build the brigades, war boats used to blockade and starve Tenochtitlan. However, the Tilapion, the loyal junior partner the junior partner of the Triple Alliance, because they’re made up of their mind completely loyal to the Mexica, its warriors fought fiercely alongside Tenochtitlan’s defenders throughout the brutal ninety three day siege, helping defend the vital Western causeway that linked the island to the mainland. When Tinochetlin fell, Ateca Lapa was destroyed and subjugated alongside it. Yeah. Continue.

Simone Collins:Yeah. That makes

Malcolm Collins:But but even a core part of their alliance betrayed them.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Well, look. And someone in the comments of this of this piece came in and was like, look. There’s a reason why most of Cortez’s, like, helpers, allies were just indigenous groups because they were like, come this way. They’re that way. They’re that way. Come on, swear. Look, Dave, a lot. You just Well

Malcolm Collins:and and what what have really, demoralized the Aztecs? because they they could have won had they worked altogether against the the Cortez and everything like

Simone Collins:even know. Again, like, look at their combat style, which Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:No. That’s what I mean. Like, their combat style would have failed so severely in the early days at least Mhmm. That other groups would have immediately been like, even though this is a small community, like, let’s let’s ban with them. Right? Because we know there hadn’t been major defeats like this.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. I I’m gonna read his passage about the gods because this helps you to understand. And back to his theme, mister Smith’s theme about ideas have consequences and the Aztec really hammering this home for him even though a big theme of their blog is that, like, I don’t know. It’s kinda complicated. Everything mixes together. Because their gods really do clarify why they have come to act this way. And to me, it also hammers home why religion is so important and why your gods and everyone has gods. I don’t care if your god is a credit card or if it is an airplane that takes you to fancy places or if it is a god god. Like, you have gods. It’s a whole, like, thing. But, anyway, he writes, the earth gods came in all different shapes and forms, and they filled the in inter interstices. Never seen it worded that way. Interstices of the Mexican myth world. At the top of the Pyramid Of Hetz or whatever, captives had their hearts torn out for his glory. But at the base of the pyramid was an image of his outraged older sister and victim, the earth goddess, coil swatcher whatever, eyes closed in death, bones jutting from torn flesh, but fanged mouth wide open and eternally hungering for the plundered corpses flung down the stone steps. Less grandiose was the terrible phantom knight axe, quote, a headless torso scuttling along the ground, its split chest opening then shutting with the dull chunk of an axe blow heard in the night, end quote. The Mexica believed that a man who encountered the knight axe and reached into its gaping wound could pluck out the signs of his individual fate. Oh, ain’t that sweet? Well, if you hear the sound of, like, an axe falling at night, run out and look for a headless torso scuttling along

Malcolm Collins:the ground. Your hand in his open torso hoping

Simone Collins:Like, reaching out of a fortune cookie. You’ll find out what will happen to you. Ain’t that sweet, little Jimmy? Anyway, the earth lords were vindictive and sadistic, and much of Aztec ceremony, the daily offerings of blood, the human hearts pulped into stone mouths, were designed to temporarily satisfy their hunger and keep them at bay. But, unfortunately, they could not be avoided. In fact, the entire structure of earthly life conspired to interweave human destiny with that of the earth gods. As lords of the earth, the fruits of the earth belonged to them. And by ingesting those gifts, every human being entered into involuntary servitude to these beings. Agriculture, the systematic extraction of the flesh of the gods was a metaphysically dangerous game to play. Though agriculture through agriculture, humanity entered into a desperate plight, a debt that could never be repaid except through death. Humankind could only be sustained if the gods were fed in return. Ugh. Why can’t they have any nice interpretation

Malcolm Collins:of something? What what’s interesting is is when you talk about, like, the amount of the genetic pool that still is from these people in regions like Mexico

Simone Collins:Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:Not only do you have the name Mexico still there, which obviously should be scrubbed from history.

Simone Collins:It really should be scrubbed from history, but we need to change it.

Malcolm Collins:They have begun, and what’s really been growing recently is the cult of Dioslos Mortos

Simone Collins:Oh my god. Where they worshipped

Malcolm Collins:the skeleton that’s just What is the it’s

Simone Collins:like the the the dead the there’s, like, a dead saint, but, like, whatever.

Malcolm Collins:No. It’s a fake saint, and and the Catholic church doesn’t approve of it, but it’s become a large Catholic sect in the area.

Simone Collins:The death cult. I wonder where that came from. He pulls a quote from the book. For our tribute is death. It is awarded us in common as merited. And on earth, there prevaileth the coming to pay the tribute of death. For there will be the following after the approaching of thy progenitor, Michlon Tetuloy, death lord, who remains unsatiated, who remaineth coveting. He remaineth thirsting there for us, hungering there for us, panting there for us. Oh my god. This whole society is just hurt people, hurt people. I swear to you, Malcolm.

Malcolm Collins:Hurt yourself too. You know?

Simone Collins:No. Like, for real. Like, just everything like, the reaction to everything is just pain. Everything is met with pain.

Malcolm Collins:Very interesting to me because it almost reminds me of the urban monoculture, which is an entire society obsessed with pleasure. And just like everything is how much pleasure can you extract from your life and how much pleasure can you extract from the lives of those around you.

Simone Collins:Yeah. And they’re like the the invert invert.

Malcolm Collins:They’re an inversion of that. How much pain can you assert within your own life and those

Simone Collins:around you? How can I avoid pleasure without maximizing

Malcolm Collins:aspiration of pleasure at all?

Simone Collins:Yeah. Yeah. For real. For real. He writes, this is why for the Mexica, the moment of weaning that was the single most important event of a person’s life, a baby who had only ever suckled at his oh, yeah. At his or her mother’s breast was free, mercifully free from the human condition. If you died before weaning, your spirit would return to the warm garden of tona chura whatever to suck upon one of the innumerable breasts of the wet nurse tree. Weaning would irrevocably and destructively alter a child’s relationship with the gods. As soon as they had taken the plants of the earth into their mouth, the child was flung into a total and involuntary obligation to the raving spirits of the earth, an obligation that could be paid for only with one’s flesh and death. The Mexica were some of the original ecological thinkers and that they recognized all human life and civilization as just transient stage in the natural cycle of vegetable growth, decomposition, fertilization, and regrowth. But unlike their ideological descendants, the Mexica savored the bleak reality and existential threat of the phrase oh, that the phrase circle of life ought to connote. My god. Women had an especially close connection to the earth deities because the fertile womb that brought forth children was obviously tied to the fertile earth bringing forth maize and beans in an endless cycle of which human life was but one temporary stage. The terrible presence that overcame women in childbirth as men were possessed by whatever in the battlefield was. She was the gaping mouth, the ferocious teeth, the endless hunger. The mere shadow of her presence could injure any living thing. So even in the case of a normal birth, great care was taken that visitors to the household in the days that followed should ward themselves against her influence. But if a woman died in childbirth in, quote, the fatal time for us poor women are kind of war, end quote, then the dark power of Chi Quatul would suffuse her body and extreme measures had to be taken. The corpse could not be removed from the house by the doorway, but instead the mourners would break open a back wall and remove it remove it in the dead of the night. The husband would carry the corpse escorted by a family of old women and midwives to bury it at a crossroads. There, he would keep vigil for four days as the magical power slowly dispersed, fending off any grave robbers desperate to seize a fragment of her flesh for use in potions or talismans.

Malcolm Collins:Jesus

Simone Collins:Christ. After he departed, leaving no marker or indication at the place, she would be reborn as a celestial princess or a devil woman, a malevolent spirit, eternally angry, haunting the peripheral places, and inimical to all life, but especially children. The celestial princesses caused birth defects and deformities. Oh, I thought that would be nice to be a celestial princess.

Malcolm Collins:So you get one of two evil options.

Simone Collins:Great. They and they also

Malcolm Collins:way you can die as a woman.

Simone Collins:In childbirth. And then you either become a devil woman or celestial princess, who in addition to causing

Malcolm Collins:You either harm children or give them birth defects. Fantastic.

Simone Collins:Birth defects and deformities and struck down teenagers with convulsions or illness. And when at some future new fire ceremony, the sun would fail and the world should end, it was they who would leave the ravening horde of earth powers to destroy the world. Oh, so they also are like the horsemen of the the horsemen of the apocalypse. Horsemen.

Malcolm Collins:Why is everything evil about this?

Simone Collins:For real, the kindest of the earth gods was Tochi, the patroness of female social and domestic activities. I’ll close this section by just quoting no. I’m not I’m not gonna I’m not gonna talk about this one. No.

Malcolm Collins:Too stressful, too baby stuff?

Simone Collins:Yeah. I’m skipping the woman stuff. I I can’t handle the woman stuff, which is horrible because they’re they’re they’re horrible to everyone. I’m trying to see where I can, like, get through to actually reading. And I also want people to read the actual thing because this is I’ll skip to one one more festival, and then we’ll let we’ll let people read the rest. Because, look, this this book had a lot of material, and mister Smith’s trying to give you a good taste of it. He does a good job. But here’s one one of their festivals. Let’s just go to another festival that doesn’t involve women and children. The great swell evil.

Malcolm Collins:I’m I’m sorry. This has no European equivalent. None. Like Genuinely. Genuinely. Closest. Again, the closest you can get is the Assyrians, and they just weren’t this bad.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Truly. Truly.

Malcolm Collins:I mean, you have some, like, unique one off torture devices like the Brazen Bowl, but that it just wasn’t used institutionally.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Yeah. I’m gonna I’m gonna tell you what what he says about another god that’s scarier than the other gods, kind of. A very good cosmic horror god. Yeah. Lovecraft, really, he did not create No.

Malcolm Collins:Honestly, this is better than Lovecraft.

Simone Collins:It is better than Lovecraft. I’ve I’ve gotta say. Yeah. Lovecraft, sorry. Move over, friend.

Malcolm Collins:Really gross to me that people try to rehabilitate the Aztecs and, like, their stuff is part of, like, Mexican history.

Speaker 11:The underworld. Maya will be mine to sacrifice, and it will make me the most powerful being in all the realm. Well, it was nice knowing you guys.

Speaker 12:It’s like Netflix unironically made springtime for Hitler, but then made it a children’s show and didn’t even take out the stuff about evil gods wanting to sacrifice people.

Speaker 15:And for the people here who are like, well, what about their descendants? They shouldn’t be shamed for the things. I’m like, what what do you what do you the way you treat the Germans. We always shame them for stuff that their ancestors did. Why do these people get an exception? And more than that, there’s almost no one of Aztec descent in Mexico today who isn’t more descent of their victims because their victims were a much larger group and underwent horrors Did we just ignore them? Do we ignore all the children that they brutally tortured to death? or do we say, hey. maybe it’s okay that this one group, just you know, like the [bleep], we’re just like, okay. Put a put a put an x here. The bad guys. Like, let’s not, like, look back at them with any degree of fondness or the things they did because that disrespects their victims.

Malcolm Collins:No. Eradicate this history.

Simone Collins:This is bad. This was bad. Let’s forget it completely. Let us stamp out any remaining for real. Like

Malcolm Collins:I feel the same way about, like, Celtic history, but, like, even the Celts were not this bad. They did, like, human sacrifices and stuff like that, but it wasn’t this bad.

Simone Collins:All of it was bad. All of it was bad. The the important thing is, like, do do the people become post Adamite humans? Does that happen? I don’t think these guys made it there. Anyway, mister Smith writes, so much for the earth gods. But in the great sweep of Mexican religion, there was one more being who fit neither with the indifferent and aloof celestials that devastated humanity with natural disasters out of sheer disinterest nor with the bound and mutilated earth lords to whom one’s life was owed as soon as one had tasted maze gruel. There was one entity who broke the pattern. He stood above and outside the world, but the world was a place of exile and danger precisely because he held it within his hand. The lord of the here and now. Tezcatlipoca, the enemy on both sides. The enemy on both sides. You cannot win in this society. If the other celestial were lumbering giants who occasionally kicked over the anthill that was the earth, Tetskathipoca, whatever, was a was a sadistic child with a magnifying glass. Oh, great way to put it, mister Smith. Okay. Alright.

Malcolm Collins:Yes. Great.

Simone Collins:Really. Tetskatlilopa was intensely interested in the doings of men, and the Mexica cowered under his gaze and prayed for it to pass him by. Tezcatlipo’s dot wait. Laughter signaled total destruction. And of Tezcatlipoa, whatever, it is said, quote, he only maketh. Of no one can he be a friend. To no one true. End quote. His other names were Moyo Kafo. I’m not even gonna try to do his other names. one of them, he who whose slaves we are and another one which meant the mocker. He was fickless personified. He was utterly unpredictable and implacable. He and he delighted in elevating a man, making him virtuous, rich, and proud, and suddenly and inexplicably destroying him. What the Tezcatlip whatever was the god of kings and earthly rulership. Tez whatever was also the god of slaves who were known as beloved sons of I’m gonna call him tea from now on. Okay? Beloved sons of tea. This was not out of some pseudo Christian lust thou shalt, lust shall be first beatitude because but because their calamitous positions were dramatized, the the pure arbitrariness of individual destiny. The influence of tea pervaded every bit of Mexican society. Good fortune must always be accepted warily because more than likely, it was the setup to a cruel joke by tea. Young mothers were cautioned not to be too pleased with their babies, lest the lord of the here and now notice and destroy the child. Bouquets of flowers were to be sniffed only at the outer edges, the swooning sweetness at the center belonged

Malcolm Collins:not to that. Even allowed to be happier experience any pleasure not even smelling a flower.

Simone Collins:Not even smelling a bouquet of freaking flowers. We are all slaves to tea. He whose slaves we are, victims of the giant unpredictability of the world, the will of tea was also made manifest in the brutal public torture and execution of a warrior or priest who stumbled. Quote, his warrior regalia stripped from him, his scalp locked shorn, his heart excised, his empty body broken into its parts and dispersed to be eaten to eaten. Okay. I didn’t get to them.

Malcolm Collins:The what I this is just like your well, one of your your friends accidentally stumbles in a parade ceremony or something. Mhmm. And it’s not like a, well, he’s in a better place. It’s like, well, of course, we had to tear him apart and eat him.

Simone Collins:He’s in my tummy. That looming reality cast its shadow backed o back over the adult the adulation, the triumphs to reveal the desperate fragility of the seasoned warrior. Endless striving, the endless anxious making of the self and the reversal, the sudden massive physical assault by one’s peers in punishment for some perhaps unintended, possibly involuntary dilict. Dilect. Dilect. Dilect. He uses fancy words. See, they’re the intellectual couple. The merchant, all payments made deprived of his reward. The priest cast out. The great warrior shamed. The threat was always there. Tetskachilopa. The great festival of Tetskachilopa was called Takskatl. It was instructive. A young male slave was chosen for his beauty, then adorned with jewelry and fine clothing, crowned, decked with the flowers, and paraded through the streets. For an entire year, he was addressed as Tezcatiblopa, given pride of place at every banquet, fetid, always preceded through the streets by an entourage of playing flutes and provided any sort of sexual gratification he desired. For the final five days in his role as the god, Tetskatilopa literally ruled the city, the king secluding himself away while the slave danced and celebrated in his place and in the most sacred zones of the temples. On the final day before the next Tocque’s cattle, he took a canoe to a small island to meet the knives of the waiting priests. Quote, as the old Tetskathi Lopa died, his heart cut out, his head skewered on the skull rack. The flutes of the new Tetskathi Lopa were heard in the streets of the city to understand the rights of Tuk’s cattle is to comprehend the nature of Tetskathi Lopa for, quote, the artificially glorious, artificially brief parabola of his ritual life displayed what it was to live in a world ruled by Tetskathi Capulopa.

Malcolm Collins:I wanna be clear here. As somebody who’s really interested in anthropology and cross cultural religions Yeah. There are tropes in religions that you see occasionally, like the trickster god or something like that. I am not familiar with a single real religion outside of, like, horror that has a god like this.

Simone Collins:Yeah.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. This is just a horror movie.

Simone Collins:Yeah. Whose nature is perfectly realized in the destruction of his servitor at the pinnacle of honor and social bliss. Tugscato carried a dark undertext of social prestige as fiction, of the power of men to make this perfect thing and destroy and replicate it at will. It also spoke more deeply of the desperate fragility besetting experience itself, of the evanescence, not only of man made things, but of beauty, pride, and desire, of the impenetrable inexhaustible fickleness of Tetskaki Lopa, the anguish of powerless dependence, the constancy of insecurity, the painful insubstantiality of status and reward in the imperial city of Tenochtitlan, and the casual, inventive, tireless malice of the only sacred force concerned with the fates of men. Mister Smith adds, it tells us something about the Mexico oh, sorry. About Mexico political theory that this wanton, sadistic, fundamentally antisocial god was the patron of kingship and rightful rule. And I’m gonna leave it at that. I think that we we should all visit the mister and missus Smith’s sub stack if you wanna actually get his punchline. I think he’s very articulate. It’s good stuff to read. The he this was almost the end of it, but I don’t wanna steal his thunder. I think

Malcolm Collins:I mean, I’m very glad you shared this. I think that people need to understand this idea, and I think the reason why this is so such a good episode to to to put out there, and you were like, I this will be a weekend episode. This is not a weekend episode. Oh, I don’t know. A great

Simone Collins:like, me being super excited about the extinguishment of a civilization is Well, I’m going to

Malcolm Collins:be censoring those parts, obviously. Okay. Good. Thank you

Simone Collins:for censoring that. Yeah. Y’all y’all can know what I mean, though.

Malcolm Collins:Yeah. But the point being, people need to understand that not all civilizations are equal. Not all civilizations are the same. They don’t carry the same moral weight. They aren’t shades of gray different. Some are really different from others, and some regions of the world really are different from others.

Simone Collins:And the big takeaway from mister Smith’s post too, ideas have consequences, and culture matters. Culture matters. Religion matters. Your gods matter. And if you have toxic, evil, sadistic, soulless gods, you’re gonna have a toxic, evil, soulless, sadistic culture. And, hopefully, it won’t get this bad. But as you pointed out

Malcolm Collins:But doesn’t mean you should be an entire society without any reference to pleasure. A society where everything is about maximizing pain and suffering.

Simone Collins:Yeah. And and, again, minimizing pleasure. Like, to the point about the, like, don’t sniff the bouquet of flowers. Pleasures for this guy. And if you enjoy things too much, you know, he’s gonna cut you down. Like yeah. Truly the opposite of the urban monoculture, which is all about avoidance of pain and and adherence to pleasure, complete inverse, both of them being a sick and dangerous pantomime, but one being unthinkably worse. I mean, I would much rather I would wish upon anyone, you know, death by, you know, pointless pleasure box over the Aztec experience. That is it is it is when I first read this you know, again, I I’m I’m sitting there, like, getting my my miscarriage miscarriage blood work done. Like, I was, you know, going in there being all sad. And then I’m also with the documentary team that’s asking me, like, how do you feel? What happened? So I’m, like, really reflecting on it. Then I read this, and I’m, like, walking away from the clinic with with the the the camerawoman. And I’m just like, oh my god. I’m so glad we’re not the Aztecs. And she’s like, yeah. I mean, yep. Yep. And everything just felt so stupid because I’m still so sad and I’m but I’m also just like, what

Malcolm Collins:the what?

Simone Collins:Oh my god. Yes. It’s just so bad. It’s so bad. I I hate them. I don’t hate them. Like, I that’s what would be

Malcolm Collins:so great? Punish themselves as well.

Simone Collins:No. No. Well, did hate them. And I think the the the the core thing is I I hate deeply their culture because it hurt them. Like, in in that way, you know, like, you get really mad at me when I hurt myself, and I get really mad at you when you hurt yourself. And, like, we get really frustrated with our kids when we’re like, don’t run. And then they run, and then they hurt themselves. And we’re like, why would you do this to yourself? I care about you. I don’t want you to hurt. And hearing about this entire culture, I’m like, I don’t I want your babies to be okay. I want your woman to be okay. I want your men to be okay. I want your boys to not suffer. I want all of this. Why are you doing to the ideas? Ideas have consequences.

Malcolm Collins:We, for example, Simone and I, do not look back to Celtic culture for, like, our No. We don’t. No. You don’t need to. If you are Latin American, you don’t need to look back to this evil. You can do the same thing we do and say, hey. Our people have changed since then. The fundamental thing

Simone Collins:that makes humans human is the presence of a prefrontal cortex, which enables us to weigh ideas in our minds without living or dying. We don’t have to die off as entire strains because we have traits that are suboptimal. We can think through things and be like, that’s not a really good idea. I think I’m gonna change. And the whole point is that humans are able to, unlike all other mammals and all other animals, move beyond stuff that kinda sucks, kinda doesn’t work so well, and and rise above. If we turn to the past forever, that is that is to spit in the face of that which makes us human, To to choose to reject bad suboptimal old ideas and to not accept better ways because they’re new and different is is the is almost definitionally inhuman because it is it is a refutation of the prefrontal cortex and its purpose of allowing us

Malcolm Collins:to evolve quickly. You gotta say thank you Catholics for dealing with this situation. You know, I gotta be nice. I gotta prove I’m not big enough. Oh my god. Yes. You’re the proud of

Simone Collins:the Spaniards. I mean, I think it would have kicked the bucket as a civilization anyway. The Maya did that. they they they dispersed. They were unsustainable, and and the Aztec were too. They would have taken care of themselves. But you know what? Anyone who kind of Helped a little

Malcolm Collins:bit with that. Yeah. Just Anyway, love you, Simone. I’m glad we did this, and it’s 05:00. 05:01. Bye. Bye. There’s suggested dish for these?

Simone Collins:A suggest oh, is it sprinkled on top of mac and cheese?

Malcolm Collins:No. It’s disgusting looking. It’s like hot dog bits and a little bit of cheese.

Simone Collins:Well, so you have your camera on reflect. So I’ll go. You’re you’re giving me a Leonardo da Vinci clear language. No. I’m saying your camera reverses it.

Malcolm Collins:Oh, yes. Well, this it doesn’t matter what the ingredients are. Look at the picture.

Simone Collins:She’s oh, why would you do that? Why would you do that?

Malcolm Collins:That does not look good.

Simone Collins:They’re taking out the crunch. Why would you take out the crunch? The flavor’s so good, though. I don’t know why they didn’t make them always this flavor. I hope they don’t get rid of it.

Malcolm Collins:Oh.

Simone Collins:What? Oh, you’re just looking at the picture again.

Malcolm Collins:You’re just at the ingredients. Two hot dogs.

Simone Collins:Oh, of the recipe, not the chips. I thought somehow you developed an impromptu aversion to highly processed foods, which was

Malcolm Collins:No. Don’t you don’t you worry. I’m still Malcolm.

Simone Collins:Well, you know, I try to make you whole foods. I mean, last night, you know, I foisted my homemade chips upon you. Poor thing.

Malcolm Collins:They were pretty good. Your homemade chips are really good. They’re, like, three times as salty as Fritos.

Simone Collins:That’s because I use MSG. That’s that’s just the secret.

Malcolm Collins:I’m pretty sure Frito uses MSG too, Simone. I’m gonna tell you what. I don’t think you discovered the idea of putting MSG

Simone Collins:in there. I actually think that most tortilla chips do not. I think they just use salt, And that’s their problem, you see. That’s where they made a mistake. Alright. You ready for this?

Malcolm Collins:I’m ready.

Simone Collins:Okay.

Speaker 13:So our AI chatbot site, rfab, that’s rfab.ai. I did some major updates to the sort of brainstorming features for brainstorming chatbot scenarios, and they’re just so much better now. They now focus more on, like, the intent of what you’re looking for. So, like, if you’re looking for, like, a fail girl or something like that, it means you want to be, like, appreciated and needed and have somebody who relies on you. And then that’s worked into the way the story works. And what’s even cooler is I got even the not safe for work story brainstormers working with Fable in the auto generation. So try that out if you haven’t. It does really amazing work, which I was surprised about.

Speaker 14:Are you keeping Dex happy? Yeah. the feeding. He he. You don’t eat a stuffy. Yeah. Yeah. What would that even taste like? Yeah. Didn’t do that. You didn’t know. What does stuffy taste like?

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit basedcamppodcast.substack.com/subscribe