Skip to content
TrackPodcasts
newsMar 8, 20261:44

Unsolved Murders: Brother, Sister Killed in Family Feud

About this episode

In the 1970s and 80s, a bitter family feud in Alaska escalated to murder. Muriel Pfeils car explosion and her brother Roberts shooting were linked to a custody battle over her son Scotty. Neil Mackay, Scottys father, was suspected of hiring hitmen, with underworld figure Gilbert Pauole as a key player. Despite convictions of several triggermen, Mackay was acquitted due to doubts about Pauoles credibility. True crime author Leland Hales book, Kill Brother, Kill Sister, presents a strong case for Mackays involvement, leaving both murders officially unsolved.

Support the show:
Get a discount at https://solipillow.com/discount/dnn.

Advertise on DNN:
[email protected]

This is an automated, high-level news summary based on public reporting.
Report issues to [email protected].

View sources & latest updates:
https://sources.thednn.ai/e5c84edd0f9d0551

Get every episode summarized

Each time Anchorage News Today | 2 Min News | The Daily News Now! publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.

Email me new episodes

Free for 3 shows. No card needed.

Hosts & guests

Transcript ready

27 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.

Unsolved Murders: Brother, Sister Killed in Family Feud

Anchorage News Today | 2 Min News | The Daily News Now!

0:00
1:44

Full transcript

Anchorage News Today | 2 Min News | The Daily News Now!Unsolved Murders: Brother, Sister Killed in Family Feud. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.

On March 8th, here's the latest out of Anchorage. In 1976, Muriel Fale, a successful Anchorage travel agent, died instantly when her car exploded in a parking lot. Almost a decade later, on October 12th, 1985, her brother Robert and Alaska Airlines pilot was shot multiple times while driving home. He died a month later from his injuries, including a bullet in his spine. The violence stemmed from a bitter family feud. Muriel had divorced attorney and real estate mogul Neil McCuy, and their young son Scotty inherited her estate. Robert sought custody, sparking a long core battle with McCuy, who suddenly wanted the boy too. After years of legal fights and temporary guardians for Scotty, McCuy won full custody. The custody war fueled deep hatred between McCuy and Robert. Investigators suspected McCuy hired Hitman for both attacks. It's pointed to Underworld figure Gilbert Powell, who ran a strip club and knew McCuy.

Powell allegedly arranged the shooting through petty criminals. Police squeezed suspects, and Powell flipped, wearing wires and testifying that McCuy paid him. Several triggermen were convicted quickly. McCuy's trial moved to Fairbanks due to publicity, but jurors doubted Powell's credibility and acquitted him. Today, both murders remain officially unsolved. Who crime author Leland Hale unravels the tangle probe in his book, Kill Brother, Kill Sister, making a strong case for McCuy's involvement despite the courtroom outcome? This story is made possible by our sponsor. A pillow that plays your sound quietly, comfortably, effortlessly, bill for nighttime listening, S-O-L-I, solelypillow.com.

More episodes

More from Anchorage News Today | 2 Min News | The Daily News Now!

View all episodes →