Rep. Pat Ryan on War in Iran

0:00Few things are as uplifting as the greatest moments in sports, and nothing brings us together quite like Team USA at the Olympic Winter Games. From NBC Universal's iconic storytelling to the innovative technology across Xfinity and Peacock, Comcast brings the Olympic Games home to America, sharing every moment with millions. When Team USA steps onto the world stage, we're not just watching, we're cheering together. This winter, we're all on the same team. Comcast, proud partner of Team USA. Before you begin your road trip, ask yourself, do you really need five full suitcases? With the 2026 Kia Sportage X Pro's class-leading cargo space, you'll have room for what you need. Find out more at your local Kia dealer today. Keep the adventure going. Kia, movement that inspires. Call 800-333-4 Kia for details. Always drive safely and obey all traffic laws. Compare some space on second-row legroom and cargo space behind second-row seats in the subcompact SUV class-equating Kia segmentation as of October 2025.

1:10Brian Merr on WNYC with us now, New York Congressman Pat Ryan. The Hudson Valley Democrat went to West Point, served two combat tours in Iraq, earning him two bronze stars. He's on the House Armed Services Committee. The district includes Kingston, New Pulse, Bikipsi, and other places around there. Congressman Ryan has been in the news the last few days as critical of President Trump for not answering questions about the Americans killed so far in the war or addressing their families. Congressman, thanks for coming on. Welcome back to WNYC. Thanks for having me, Brian. For you who served in Iraq, what do you think about the comparisons being made between the two wars, especially that like George W. Bush, Trump has deposed the Middle Eastern leader with leader with no plan for what comes next? How much of history repeating itself do you see or not? It's infuriating. Maybe history doesn't repeat, but it certainly rhymes very strongly here. You have a war that is built ultimately on a foundation

2:16of mistrust and lies. You have another generation of patriotic young Americans going to fight in an open-ended regime change war. In this case, even worse than George W. Bush, there wasn't even an attempt, even a token surface effort to have a good faith conversation with the American people, and the Congress has their representatives about what is the cost? What is the cost in our hard-earned tax dollars and what is the cost? God forbid, as we're experiencing now in flag-drape coffins coming back from another regime change war in the Middle East. When you were in Iraq, did you feel like you understood the reasons for that war and does understanding the reasons matter to troops on the ground? I think it matters tremendously. I mean, the idea of giving one's life for something greater than yourself is undergirded by a belief in the values. It's really about a trust that

3:18I'm signing up. I was 18, ultimately, when I chose to go to West Point. I'm signing up because I love this country and I believe that they will only ask me to risk my life and my friends. If it's absolutely necessary for a noble cause, and unfortunately in my service in Iraq, that optimistic view has certainly changed and shaped. To see in the last few days, even after we started combat operations, after we initiated war, to be clear this is a war, to see the administration and even the president himself change the aims four or five times in 24 hours from this is a regime change war, to know it isn't, to where you're going to be there weeks, we're going to be there months, we're going to be there as long as it takes. Hegs said, if yesterday refusing to say we won't put boots on the ground, to start something this serious with clearly no plan past day one, it's infuriating and it's a grave disservice to those over their lives right now.

4:22Those comments you made on CNN about Trump not answering questions about the U.S. Service members killed or addressing their families was on Sunday. Now it's Tuesday and the U.S. death toll has increased to six. Is the president respecting those who made that ultimate sacrifice to your satisfaction yet? No, I mean, he got off the plane, was asked to address the families and instead talked about the new flower garden at the White House or something to that effect. And then he shrugged his shoulders in his second pre-recorded video and said, this is the way it is, meaning losing Americans is the way it is. This is not the way it needed to be. This is not a war that we needed to fight. There was no imminent threat that has been confirmed by every credible, serious, analyst and intelligence operative, including our own Department of Defense now. And so it's very important and this week we're going to have a vote on it too late,

5:27but to get back to what our founders intended and the Constitution says, which is the Congress as the voice of the people has the say in this, not a singular executive in a way that the British King used to do. So that resolution, correct me if I'm wrong, would require congressional approval before continuing the war past a certain point? Correct, but I want to just take a step back briefly to say that this decision to go to war is illegal and very clearly so. After Vietnam and all the lessons we learned in that decade plus debacle, the Congress passed the war powers resolution of 1973, often called the War Powers Act. Congress passed it, then President Nixon vetoed, and Congress overrode it, which is, as you know, quite unusual, to say that these kinds of open ended wars cannot be, you know, laterally started by a president. And so this administration

6:30has now violated both the spirit and the letter of Section 2C of that law. So the vote, which will likely happen Thursday, we're being told in a few days, is to reassert the importance of that resolution, both, you know, going forward, but also to make clear that the decision up to this point was not only, I think, strategically unsound, but also not legal. Well, I know that a similar resolution regarding the Venezuela invasion failed. Do you think there's any more support among the Republican majority for it to pass this time considering the closer similarities to the Iraq war in this case? The Venezuela resolution failed both before that another illegal operation in Venezuela and failed after, but only by one vote. They literally had to fly in a representative from Texas who wasn't there to kill that, which is pathetic on every level.

7:35I am very concerned that this has become another litmus test of mega-fuelty of pressuring Republicans who might dain't actually follow the Constitution and take seriously their oath not to a president but to the Constitution. So unfortunately, I'm not optimistic in the world of today's Republican Party that we'll see any voices of Republican courage. We will continue to push for that, and I'm particularly talking with fellow military veterans, those who served in these two forever wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and trying to appeal to them on that level, and I'll do that up to the very last second. New York Congressman Pat Ryan is our guest, Democrat from the Hudson Valley. I want to play a clip of a caller to the show yesterday from the Hudson Valley like you, a little south of your district, and originally from Iran. It's Peruz in Yorktown. I'm a Democrat by most my voting. However, on this one, I am making an exception because I

8:41thoroughly and deeply understand the ultimate impact and amplification of Islamic radicalism, which is going to be widespread worldwide, and that's the domestic, that's the regional and international and national level ramification of it, but domestically this regime has been extremely radical and repressive to the nationals of Iran and they have been caught between Iraq and a hard place, and so therefore I would give the benefit of the doubt to the Trump administration as we did to Clinton during the Yugoslavia war. So Congressman, what do you say to that caller and other Americans who are Iranian expats who would like to see the repressive theocracy in their country and after 47 years, and that a week around these days with a growing protest movement makes this the best opportunity.

9:45I agree with those goals. I mean, I lost close personal friends to bombs and mortar attacks from Iranian proxy forces when I served. I have no illusions about the regime and their motives and what they have done. The question is how do we best effectuate that? Of course, thinking about the freedom of the Iranian people, but frankly, first and foremost, making sure that the safety of the American people in my constituents are number one, and I fear that having not thought through beyond the immediate tactical, meaning sort of immediate military success of day one, what is the plan to effectuate that regime change in a way that doesn't just repeat what just happened in Venezuela where we replaced one bad guy with now a potentially even worse woman in Delci Rodriguez, and to even hear President Trump in an interview a day or two ago, essentially say that's my playbook here. We want to replicate that. That does not serve

10:47the very noble and correct aspirations of the Iranian people to be free. In fact, it potentially makes it worse. Part of the risk that I think hasn't been thought through here is this Iranian regime clearly planned their succession to the fourth degree has been publicly reported, and it's likely that hardline elements of either the IRGC or others are even more now likely to come to power and potentially be more repressive. It's an excruciating situation for the people of Iran, and I don't skip over that, but I'm worried that we not only don't address, we fail to address that aim, but we've also now initiated what's quickly becoming an escalatory regional war where multiple surrounding countries are now being struck and potentially pulled into this. Meanwhile, while China, who I think is our greatest, both military but also economic adversary, continues

11:49to benefit from us deploying two-carrier strike groups, massively spending down critically short munitions and interceptors and air defense assets, and I think that makes the American people, frankly, unfortunately less safe. Let me ask you a political question. You are generally seen as in a competitive swing district in the Hudson Valley, and obviously this is a midterm elections year. I want to play a clip of Trump that resurfaced recently from 2011 when Barack Obama was president I actually saw this first on Saturday Night Live over the weekend, believe it or not, and I don't know maybe they unearthed it and I've seen it passed around a lot more since then, but listen to this, this is Trump in 2011. This is a great time to negotiate. Unfortunately, we have a president that doesn't know the first thing about negotiation. We have a real problem in the White House, so I believe

12:53that he will attack Iran sometime prior to the election. Well, he predicted and obviously it didn't happen that Obama would attack Iran because it would help Obama get reelected in 2012. Do you think that in Trump's mind with Jeffrey Epstein, with inflation and the tariffs with everything else, that he might think that this is a path toward midterm victory for the Republican party? When I think about our troops that are over there and their love of country and optimism that goes with signing up to serve and risk their life and then you can trust that with what is said that is an incredibly cynical thing that the president said to be kind about it. It absolutely makes my blood boil. I don't even know if he's that thoughtful about this. I actually

13:54think what we've seen over the last year and him taking on more and more of these foreign policy boondoggles moving into Quagmire status is that he's failing at home in the agenda that he ran on and that the people expect him to deliver on particularly on lowering costs for housing, healthcare, groceries, utilities. And so he's like many second term presidents sort of flailing about on the global stage trying to exert his will and strength. And in doing so is a bull in a china shop and creating all kinds of collateral damage for everybody including the American people. I think that's probably the closest to what you're saying as I would interpret it. But we've seen this before. I mean we've seen economic crashing the economy and starting wars has essentially been the theme of every Republican presidency in my lifetime and I'm 43 and it seems to be repeating again. New York Congressman Pat Ryan from the Hudson Valley,

14:56Democrat who served two combat tours in Iraq earning him two bronze stars now on the House Armed Services Committee and obviously from the vantage point of experience with a lot to say about the new war with Iran. Thank you very much for joining us. Thanks Brian. Brian Lara and WNYC more to come. Since WNYC's first broadcast in 1924 we've been dedicated to creating the kind of content we know the world needs. Since then New York Public Radio's rigorous journalism has gone on to win a Peabody Award and a Dupont Columbia Award among others. In addition to this award-winning reporting your sponsorship also supports inspiring storytelling and extraordinary music that is free and accessible to all. To get in touch and find out more visit sponsorship.wnyc.org