Skip to content
TrackPodcasts
religionMar 7, 202633:18

What Is Faith, Really? Why the Greek Word Pistis Changes Everything

About this episode

A deep dive into the gospel, allegiance, and why understanding one Greek word resolves some of the New Testament’s most perplexing tensions.

Most of us think we know what faith is. You believe something. Maybe you trust it. It happens in your head, it’s invisible, and according to a lot of modern Christianity, that’s basically the whole thing — have the right belief in the right moment, and you’re in. But what if the word we translate as “faith” in the New Testament carries a far richer, more demanding, and ultimately more liberating meaning than that?

This post is inspired by two scholars who have done substantial work on this question: Matthew Bates, author of Salvation by Allegiance Alone and Gospel Allegiance, and Scot McKnight, author of The King Jesus Gospel. Their thesis — and I think it’s compelling — is that we’ve fundamentally misunderstood both what the gospel is and what faith means. And getting both of those things wrong has enormous consequences for how we live as Christians.

First Things First: What Is the Gospel?

Before we can talk about faith as a response to the gospel, we have to be clear on what the gospel actually is. Because there’s a good chance your picture of it is incomplete.

Both Bates and McKnight argue — and I think the early church would agree — that the gospel is the objective facts concerning the entire career of Jesus as Messiah. That includes:

* His pre-existence (he was with God in the beginning)

* His incarnation

* His death for sins

* His burial

* His resurrection

* His post-resurrection appearances

* His enthronement at the right hand of the Father

* The sending of the Holy Spirit

* His future return

This is why the four books are called Gospels — Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John — the whole story matters. Paul lays this out explicitly in 1 Corinthians 15:3-8:

“For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received, that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures, and that He appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. After that He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time, most of whom remain until now, but some have fallen asleep; then He appeared to James, then to all the apostles; and last of all, as to one untimely born, He appeared to me also.”

And in Romans 1:1-4:

“Paul, a bond-servant of Christ Jesus, called as an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God, which He promised beforehand through His prophets in the holy Scriptures, concerning His Son, who was born of a descendant of David according to the flesh, who was declared the Son of God with power by the resurrection from the dead, according to the Spirit of holiness, Jesus Christ our Lord.”

The gospel, in this framing, is the story of how Jesus became the Christ — the Anointed One, the Messiah, the King. If you think about it from the perspective of a first-century Jew, the whole point was convincing them that this man, Jesus, is the promised King. That’s why Matthew’s Gospel opens with a genealogy tracing Jesus back to David. It’s legal evidence for the throne. You’re not just announcing a theology — you’re announcing a coronation.

Yes, “he died for our sins” is in there. But notice what Paul does and doesn’t say in 1 Corinthians 15. He says Jesus died for our sins. He does not explain the mechanism of how that death accomplishes forgiveness — no atonement theory is named. What he does do is spend considerable time establishing the resurrection, the appearances, and the reality of the risen Christ. The death is one part of a larger royal story. You could say it’s roughly one-tenth of the total picture.

The gospel, then, is everything that convinces you that Jesus is the rightful King of the Universe — the King of Kings and Lord of Lords to whom all power and authority in heaven and earth have been given.

So What Does It Mean to Have “Faith” in That King?

Here’s where things get really interesting — and where a single Greek word becomes a kind of Rosetta Stone for the entire New Testament.

The Greek word translated as “faith” or “believe” throughout the New Testament is πίστις (pistis). Its verbal form is πιστεύω (pisteuo). In modern English, we typically render these as “believe” or “trust” — mental states, things that happen inside your head. You assent to a proposition. You trust that something is true. That’s it.

But Matthew Bates argues — with considerable historical and linguistic evidence — that in its first-century context, especially when used in relation to kings and kingdoms, pistis carried a much richer meaning: faithfulness, fidelity, loyalty, allegiance. Not a one-time mental event, but an active, ongoing state of being a faithful subject.

Bates puts it this way: pistis is better understood not as “faith” in the passive, intellectual sense, but as allegiance — the kind of sworn loyalty a subject owes to a king.

The Evidence: Josephus and the Language of Kings

One of the most illuminating pieces of evidence Bates presents comes from the Jewish historian Josephus, who wrote in Greek roughly contemporaneously with the New Testament authors. In his autobiography, Josephus recounts a moment where he commands a rebel leader to “repent and believe in me” — using the very same Greek root (pistis).

The context makes clear that Josephus is not asking for a religious conversion or a change of mental propositions. He is commanding the rebel to turn away from his current course of action and become a loyal, obedient subject of Josephus as his military commander. The “belief” in question was a public declaration of loyalty expressed through obedience. That is what pistis meant in the real-world context of rulers and subjects.

When a king announced his reign, the required pistis from his subjects wasn’t merely believing that he was king. It was pledging allegiance to him and demonstrating that allegiance through obedience.

Bates also points to passages like Romans 1:5 and Romans 16:26, which use the phrase “the obedience of faith” (hypakoē pisteōs). This isn’t faith plus obedience as two separate things. It’s the obedience that flows from allegiance — the obedience that is inherent to what faithfulness means.

How This Resolves the New Testament’s “Contradictions”

This is the part I find most exciting, because it resolves what looks like a hopeless tangle of competing salvation requirements in the New Testament. Let me walk through it.

The “free grace” camp points to John 3:16:

“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life.”

And they say: all you have to do is believe. One mental act. Done.

But then the Church of Christ tradition points to Acts 2:38:

“Peter said to them, ‘Repent, and each of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins; and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.’”

And they say: you must be baptized. It’s right there.

And then there’s Luke 13:3, where Jesus says:

“I tell you, no, but unless you repent, you will all likewise perish.”

So now we need repentance.

And Romans 10:9:

“that if you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord, and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.”

So now we need public confession too.

And Matthew 24:13:

“But the one who endures to the end, he will be saved.”

Endurance to the end.

And James 2:24:

“You see that a man is justified by works and not by faith alone.”

Works. Explicitly not faith alone.

And Romans 2:13:

“for it is not the hearers of the Law who are just before God, but the doers of the Law will be justified.”

Doers, not hearers.

So which is it? Believe? Repent? Be baptized? Confess publicly? Endure to the end? Do works?

The answer is: all of them, and they’re all the same thing.

When you understand pistis as allegiance, all of these passages snap into a unified picture. Bending the knee to Jesus as King — genuinely, not just intellectually — necessarily implies:

* Repentance (metanoia — literally “a change of mind/direction”): You turn 180 degrees away from your previous lord (yourself, sin, the world) and toward Jesus as your Lord. Repentance toward God simply means you’ve decided that He is now your King.

* Baptism: If you’ve just declared Jesus your Lord and he says “get baptized,” you get baptized. That’s what allegiance means. You do what the king says.

* Public confession: Pledging allegiance to a king was always a public act. You don’t whisper it privately. You declare it.

* Endurance: Allegiance is not a one-time event. A knight who pledged fealty to a king and then switched sides two years later wasn’t a faithful subject — he was a traitor. Enduring to the end is what faithfulness looks like over a lifetime.

* Works: If you call someone your Lord but never do anything he says, you don’t actually think he’s your Lord. Jesus makes this point with devastating clarity in Luke 6:46:

“Why do you call Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ and do not do what I say?”

James is making the exact same point: works aren’t an addition to faith; they’re the evidence of it. Faith without works is dead because faithfulness without action isn’t faithfulness at all.

The Luther Problem

At this point, you might be wondering: why haven’t we always understood it this way? The answer involves one towering historical figure: Martin Luther.

Luther’s great contribution to Western Christianity — the doctrine of justification by faith alone (sola fide) — was forged in polemical reaction to a corrupt Catholic system of indulgences and purchased merit. And in many ways, he was right to push back on that system. But in doing so, he overcorrected in a way that has shaped Protestant Christianity to this day.

Luther essentially taught that when Jesus gave his commands — love your enemies, sell what you have, keep my commandments — he was using them to show us how impossible obedience is, so that we’d give up on works altogether and rest in grace alone. It’s as if Jesus was winking at us when he said “do this” — what he really meant was “you can’t do this, so stop trying.”

Luther went so far as to say that even teaching that Jesus’s commandments need to be obeyed is itself a sin. His theology systematically disarmed the church from taking Jesus’s own words seriously as instructions for living.

This is not a small thing. If the King issues commands, and you tell people the King was winking when he gave them, you’ve fundamentally undermined the entire concept of allegiance. You’ve made the kingdom a fiction.

The deeper issue is free will. Luther followed Augustine (as an Augustinian monk), and Augustine taught that human beings don’t have genuine free will — a position that led directly to the doctrines of total depravity and unconditional election as systematized later by Calvin. If you don’t have free will, you can’t bend the knee on your own. God has to save you first, and then you can have faith. Salvation precedes faith, rather than faith being the moment of allegiance that initiates salvation.

This is why Calvinist and Reformed traditions tend to react so strongly against the allegiance framework: it requires free will. It requires that you can actually hear the gospel, decide that Jesus is Lord, and give your allegiance to him. The Reformed tradition says that’s structurally impossible without prior regeneration.

It’s also why “once saved, always saved” (or perseverance of the saints in its more technical form) feels necessary in that framework. If your salvation was entirely God’s unilateral act, it can’t be undone. But if salvation is covenantal allegiance — if it’s a real relationship involving real loyalty — then the possibility of breaking that covenant, of ceasing to be faithful, is built in.

And the New Testament is absolutely full of that possibility. You can be cut off (Romans 11:22). You can be spit out (Revelation 3:16). You can begin to grow and then wither (the parable of the soils in Matthew 13). You can be a branch that fails to abide and is gathered and burned (John 15:6). Jesus says in John 15:1-6:

“I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser. Every branch in Me that does not bear fruit, He takes away; and every branch that bears fruit, He prunes it so that it may bear more fruit... If anyone does not abide in Me, he is thrown away as a branch and dries up; and they gather them, and cast them into the fire and they are burned.”

A Personal Note: Scales Falling from Eyes

This framework didn’t come to me through intellectual argument. It came through a crisis.

I had what I genuinely believe was a real salvation experience years ago. Then I learned about “once saved, always saved,” and — I won’t sugarcoat this — I went back to my sins for about ten years. I believed I was safe because I believed I had been saved, and I believed that couldn’t be undone. I had a theological permission slip for continuing in the very thing I needed to be freed from.

What broke the cycle wasn’t a Bible study or a debate about OSAS. It was an overwhelming conviction — I believe from the Holy Spirit — that I needed to stop drinking alcohol or I was going to hell. Not “it might not be ideal.” Not “consider whether this aligns with your values.” I was going to hell. And I couldn’t shake it. So I quit. For good.

And the morning after I did, I had the same experience I remembered from my original conversion — that same freedom, that same supernatural change of heart. It was like waking up.

My wife Connie had the same experience. We’ve talked about it. It was as if we both had scales over our eyes — we knew all the passages about losing salvation, we’d read them dozens of times, but somehow couldn’t see them. And then, suddenly, we could. Not because someone showed them to us for the first time. They were already there. The scales just fell.

I believe that’s what spiritual blindness looks like. Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 4:4:

“in whose case the god of this world has blinded the minds of the unbelieving so that they might not see the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God.”

I think one of the ways we keep ourselves blind is by refusing to repent, because we know — somewhere deep down — that genuine allegiance to Jesus would require giving up the thing we love more than him. And so we find a theology that makes that unnecessary.

What Repentance Actually Does

This connects to one of the most practically important things I want to say: repentance comes before the refreshing.

Acts 3:19 puts it plainly:

“Therefore repent and return, so that your sins may be wiped away, in order that times of refreshing may come from the presence of the Lord.”

The sequence matters. The freedom from sinful desire — the supernatural change of appetite that people call sanctification — does not come and then enable repentance. It comes after repentance. You turn first, and then the power to walk in the new direction is given.

This is crucial because a lot of people are waiting to feel ready to repent before they repent. They want the desire to sin to lessen before they commit to stopping. But it works the other way around. You commit to stopping — you draw the line — and then the burden lifts.

Start with the biggest one. Not the minor sins, not the gray areas. Start with the sin that has its hooks in you so deeply that you’d almost be willing to go to hell for it. That’s the one the allegiance decision actually costs you. And that’s the one that, when you give it up, opens the door.

Jesus says in Luke 9:62:

“No one, after putting his hand to the plow and looking back, is fit for the kingdom of God.”

Don’t start unless you’re willing to go all the way on that one. But when you do — when you make that decision with your whole will — you will find, as I did, that it’s not the burden people think it is.

Assurance Without OSAS

One thing I want to address directly: if this framework is true, does it mean you can never have assurance of salvation? Are you always white-knuckling it, terrified you might fall?

No. And this is important.

Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 13:5:

“Test yourselves to see if you are in the faith; examine yourselves! Or do you not recognize this about yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you — unless indeed you fail the test?”

Assurance comes not from a one-time event in the past — “I said a prayer in 1997” — but from being able to look at your present life and honestly say: yes, I am in the faith. The Holy Spirit is here. I am on the narrow road. I am His subject. I am doing what He says. There is grace for my failures, there is ongoing work to be done, but I am genuinely His.

That kind of assurance is actually more secure, not less. It doesn’t depend on correctly remembering a prayer. It depends on a living relationship with a living King.

David Bercot tells a story that I find helpful. When he was in college, he got a question right on a test but was marked wrong. He went to the professor, who admitted the answer key was wrong — but said he wasn’t going to change the grade because it would require changing everyone else’s too. Bercot protested. The professor looked at him and said: “Don’t sweat it, Bercot. You’re going to pass the class.”

That’s kind of how sanctification works. I’m not going to get every answer right. There are sins I’m still working on, areas where I’m not yet where I need to be. But I can examine myself and know: I’m in the faith. I’m on the road. And there is plenty of grace on this road for those who are genuinely walking it.

The King doesn’t present 50 failing grades all at once. He tends to point to the next big thing when you’re ready for it. That’s what sanctification looks like — not perfection, but progress under a patient King who is actually invested in your growth.

The Bottom Line

The gospel is the announcement that Jesus is the King of the Universe — the Messiah, the risen Lord, to whom all power and authority in heaven and earth have been given, and who is coming to judge the world.

Faith — pistis — is the appropriate response to that announcement: allegiance. Bending the knee. Agreeing that he is your King and that what he says goes. Not just once, not just in your head, but as an ongoing state of faithful obedience.

Repentance is what that looks like at the moment of entry — a 180-degree reorientation of your life toward a new Lord.

Baptism, confession, endurance, and works are all simply what genuine allegiance looks like from different angles.

And the gospel, understood this way, is not a burden. It’s the most liberating announcement in the history of the world: the King of Kings is standing with his arm outstretched, asking if you’ll follow him. Not just acknowledge him. Follow him. And he promises — through his blood, through the gift of his Spirit — to actually change you from the inside out so that you can.

As long as you have breath, that offer is open.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit vineabiders.substack.com

Get every episode summarized

Each time Vine Abiders Podcast publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.

Email me new episodes

Free for 3 shows. No card needed.

Hosts & guests

Transcript ready

347 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.

What Is Faith, Really? Why the Greek Word Pistis Changes Everything

Vine Abiders Podcast

0:00
33:18

Full transcript

Vine Abiders PodcastWhat Is Faith, Really? Why the Greek Word Pistis Changes Everything. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.

Hey, everybody. Welcome to Vine Abiders with me, Chris White. You can search for Vine Abiders on YouTube. You can also find us wherever you get your audio podcast, which is what I hope to be putting out more of these audio podcasts on a fairly regular basis as I have time. I am doing research for a much broader project. And so I hopefully will be learning things along the way and doing podcasts about them. And that's the case in this particular episode, where I'm talking about a pretty important subject, which is faith. What is faith? And it also sort of includes the idea of what is the gospel. Like we all think that we know what faith is and what the gospel is. But there's a pretty good chance that like me, I didn't really have a full understanding of what that meant. So this particular episode is inspired by a couple books from Matthew Bates, who wrote a book called Gospel Allegiance and a book called Salvation by Allegiance alone. I think Salvation by Allegiance alone was his first book. Gospel Allegiance

was his second book, which is one that I read. It's also an audio book form. Also Scott McKnight, who is a person I've interviewed before and read his book in preparation for that interview. He wrote a book called The King Jesus Gospel, which essentially has the same premise that Matthew Bates does in terms of what the gospel is. But Matthew Bates's contribution here is to go a little further in terms of what does faith mean. And you can probably guess based on the title of his book Salvation by Allegiance alone, that he is going to propose that the word pistis in the Greek in the context of salvation means faithfulness or obedience or allegiance, basically like bending the knee. That's what pistis means in the context of salvation when used by the New Testament authors in that way. And so I'll go through some of that. But I think before we do, we need to understand what these guys are proposing that the gospel is. And they would both point out, which I think

the early church would agree with. And they make that point here too, that the gospel is the objective facts concerning the career in total of Jesus as Messiah, his pre-existence, his incarnation, his death for sins, yes, but also his burial, his resurrection, his appearances, and crucially his enthronement, the sending of the spirit and even his future return are all part of the gospel. That's why they're called gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, is that the whole story is important to understand what the gospel is. So they would say is the story of his royal career. They would argue that the New Testament authors specifically Paul in 1 Corinthians 15 and Romans 1, 1 through 4, the crucial gospel passages, define the gospel as the narrated story of how Jesus became the Christ, became the Messiah, the anointed one, the king. I think of it as

you're trying to convince someone that this guy is the king of the universe, like that's the gospel. And part of that, especially in the first century, if you're talking to a Jew, they already know that a king is coming, the Messiah. So convincing them that Jesus was the Messiah is a really important part of that story. You've got to convince them that their king was Jesus. So that's why some of the gospel start off with a genealogy. It's like this guy fulfills the prophecies that he was going to come from the line of David and he did all the fulfills all these other prophecies in the Old Testament. But you could go on to say, his death and resurrection, we could go on, and they do talk about how all those things that are pointed out by Paul, for example, in 1 Corinthians 15, the resurrection, the appearances, all the stuff is important to that story. But it does make sense. And one thing the gospel is not is all the various things that different

sort of groups say that the gospel is. You know, some people just say it's justification by faith, which is the idea that you just need to believe that there's nothing that you can do and that Jesus did at all. And essentially, that's the gospel, like the idea that you can't do anything that faith alone is the gospel. Some, like I used to believe, was a version of that, but really focused in on the atonement theory aspect of it. So atonement theory is kind of the question about, well, how did Jesus die for our sins? Now, it's important that a part of the gospel is that Jesus died for our sins, right? There in 1 Corinthians 15, Jesus died for our sins. That's all it says about it, that he died for a sins. It does not tell you how he died for our sins, much to my chagrin. I really wish it did. But it just goes on and he appeared to the, you know, and rose again and all the other parts that Paul does consider important, well, also important to the gospel. So died for our sins is a part of it, but it's certainly not it's a minor part of it.

You could say it's like one tenth of the gospel, but getting back to the main point, what is the gospel? The gospel is the facts of Jesus's life, specifically those facts that convince you that not only is he the promised Messiah to the Jews, but that he is the king of the universe. He is the son of the God, the rightful God has given him all power and authority. He is it. He is the king of kings and Lord of lords and the facts of his story, including his pre-existence that he was with God in the beginning, his resurrection, his appearances, you know, that his enthronement, his soon return, all this stuff, including his death for sins and burial, all of those things are the gospel. Anything that can convince you that he is your rightful king and that you ought to submit to him is the gospel. Okay, so I hope you've made it this far and this podcast, because now I'm getting to the main point. The reason I wanted to do this podcast is to talk about Matthew Bates's particular emphasis, which is on the word faith, because what is the response

to the gospel? We know what the gospel is now, but what do you do once you hear that? You have faith. So how do you get saved? You have faith. And again, the Greek word is pistis. You got different forms of it, pistio and different things. But we sometimes, you know, translate that as a belief, intellectual belief, something that happens in your head. Some people will try to get, you know, real deep and say, actually, it means trust. But really, that's just the same kind of thing. Trust is another thing that just happens in your head, basically. It's not that much different than belief, but that's how I've heard it preached many times. But what Matthew Bates brings out and is that the word belief has a much broader meaning. And especially with regard to salvation language, it means faithfulness. It means allegiance, as he's chosen his main word to define it as. But what I want to bring out first is what this solves. This is kind of like a rosetta stone,

a key that unlocks a lot of the New Testament, and just makes it all make sense. It certainly resolves a lot of problems that different people have with regard to the question of satireology. How do you get saved? So for example, the free grazers. These are the people that insist that, you know, they take it to, it's just most extreme that they'll point to John 3, 16. It says, whoever believes in him should not perish in that word believes there is like Pistillo, which is a form of Pistus. Whoever believes in him, and they just take that modern English word and say, I believe in Jesus. And then they, they might define what it is that they need to believe in. The fact that he existed, some of them won't go quite that loosey goosey. They'll say, well, you need to believe in his crucifixion or believe that he died for you. And there's nothing that you could do, whatever, they'll come up with a reason what you need to specifically believe in the facts of. They may even go so far as to say, it believes means trust. And you need to trust him that he

died for your sins or something like that. But basically, it's an intellectual event. And they say, all you have to do is do that intellectual exercise. And you're saved. I don't want to hear anything else about it. But the problem is, of course, that you might have the church of Christ people come up and say, well, what about Acts 238? It says, then Peter said to them, repent and be baptized every one of you. I mean, you can't go to a church of Christ without hearing about that because they'll, their big thing is everybody's got to be, you cannot be saved unless you're baptized. And so, you know, how do you deal with that for graces? It says right there, repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remissions of sins. And you shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost or Luke 13 says repentance. I tell you, nay, but accept ye repent. You shall all likewise perish. So now we've got, wait a second, are we believing or re-repenting? And now we've got public confession in on it, Romans 10, 9, that if you shall confess with thy mouth, the Lord Jesus and shall believe in thy heart. So now we've got the believe, the pistis

and confessing with our mouth. So we now, we've got sort of a bunch of responses to the gospel. We could go even further, Matthew 24 says that we have to endure to the end the same shall be saved. So in addition to believing and repenting and baptizing and confessing, we also need to endure to the end in order to be saved. And to just pile on, we have verses like James 2, 24 and Romans 2, 13 that says that you have to have works. You see that how many by thy works a man is justified and not by faith only. So you're justified by your works and specifically not by faith only. So all of this is resolved by understanding that the word pistis or faith, your response to the gospel is, and we'll go into the technical stuff that people like Matthew bates go into. But first, let me just say it for my own words. So faith, pistis means, in at least in the context of salvation,

it means allegiance, bending the knee, agreeing that this guy, you know, he says he's the son of God, he says he is the king of kings. And if I hear this news that we have a king here, I'm going to bend the knee and say, look, that's it. You're my king, you're my Lord. And so what's next, you know, in the same way that if you were in the feudal system in the middle ages or whatever, if you bent your knee to a feudal Lord, a king or whatever, and you said, look, you're the king, what you say goes, that's the same kind of thing. There was no works involved there. You didn't have to get circumcised to do it. You didn't need to do anything. The bending of the knee is essentially in your heart. It's a mental thing that you do, a deciding to do it. It goes in line with other places in the Bible that says what you need to do to be saved is repentance towards God. What does that mean? Repentance, of course, means metanoia or a change of mind. Meta means a change as in

metamorphosis. And noia means mind. You change your mind. You change your mind about God. Repentance towards God means that you've decided that God was not your God before, but you're going to go 180 degrees, change your mind about God. He is now your king. He's now your Lord. The way that you resolve all these different things that says, well, you got to get baptized or, you know, Jesus says, if you love me, you'll keep my commandments. If you, who hears my words and doesn't do them is like a man who built his house on the sand and great is the fall of that house. My point here is this, if you believe that if you hear this and you say, goodness gracious, it sounds like Jesus is the Messiah. You mean he's like the promised king and like he's coming and later and he's got this other kingdom and I can be a part of it and I can, you know, be freed from sin and all this other stuff and you agree to that and say goodness, well, he's my Lord then. Well, that implied not just then, but it should now that you'd be like, well, okay, he's my Lord. What now? Well, I'm going to read the things that he says and he says, get baptized

and he says, do this and don't do that. And so the idea of having faith or faithfulness in Jesus is to do what he says because he's your Lord. If you look at the Gospels and you're reading what Jesus says because you think he's your king and you're Lord and you're like, okay, I got a Lord now. I better go figure out what he wants and you don't do it. Well, you don't have pistis. You don't have faithfulness. You're, that's why all this language in the New Testament about, look, you say you got faith, but you don't have works. Obviously, you're not, you're not, you don't have faith because you're not doing what he said. You call him Lord, Lord, but you're not doing the things that he said. And in that context, Lord means somebody, a master. You know, I often think of it is like if how easily we would follow some yogi or something who said, look, I'm your master. You want to learn how to levitate when you cross your legs and stuff. You got to follow me and be my disciple and do everything that I said. And if you don't do everything that I said, I'm not going to teach you how to levitate or whatever. Well, you go follow that guy and do everything that

he said. And he would be your master. And we don't even give Jesus the King of kings and Lord of lords who's been given all power and authority in heaven who's coming to judge the world. According to their deeds, we don't even give him that the, the, the, the, if we call him Lord, then do the things that he says. And I think that's the big story here is that he's got this whole thing about what he says. And we have structurally as a church, mostly because of Martin Luther disarmed ourselves from doing that because Martin Luther's greatest contribution to Christianity was to say that we don't have to do the things that Jesus said. In other words, Martin Luther taught us that Jesus said all this real hard stuff, but he was really kind of winking at us and saying, look, I'm going to tell you to do this stuff. But what I really am trying to get you to believe is that you don't have to do this stuff. And in fact, I'm just saying all this stuff so that you'll know that it's really too hard for you to do anyway. And so it's kind of like a wink, wink, nod, nod. I'm

going to say this stuff. I'm going to say you need to do them. I'm going to say that you need to teach people to obey my commandments and to, but I really don't want you to. In fact, Luther would go so far as to say to even teach his commandments in a, in the sense that you need to do them is the sin. Alright, let's move on to what Bates would say about this term faith and how essentially faith means allegiance or faith means faithfulness. So again, the Greek word is pistis. It's got a verbal form. Pisteo, probably pronouncing that wrong. But basically it's undergone a very narrowing thing in modern English to the effect that we might just say it means belief, which is a really not very hard thing to do in modern English to believe something, or even to trust something, you know, if we think that that's all it is. But Bates suggests that the New Testament speaks of pistis as constancy, reliability, fidelity. He would also say that

rather than faith being a one-time passive acceptance of a gift, it's an active state of being faithful to have pistis is to be a faithful subject of the king. In other words, faithfulness. He agrees that pistis and pisteo can mean what we think of as belief. So for example, in the New Testament, it does seem to mean belief in certain contexts such as having faith that Jesus can do miracles. A lot of the healing stuff uses faith in that way. So it's not that faith doesn't mean that. It's not that everybody was wrong and that faith never meant or can't mean anything like what we think of as belief or faith. But it's just like pretty much every other word in any language, it can have multiple meanings. But what he does is shows that when it is used in terms of salvation, it's used in this royal sense. When a king announces his reign, the required pistis from his subjects was not merely a belief that he existed or a belief that he was the king, but it was a public

declaration of loyalty expressed through obedience. He gives evidence. One interesting one is from the Jewish historian Josephus. Remember, Josephus existed and wrote in Greek around the same time, not much longer than when Jesus was on the earth. He says, evidence from Jewish historians, Josephus is particularly instructive in his autobiography Josephus recounts commanding a rebel leader to repent and believe in me. And he quotes the Greek basically pistis and whatever. The analysis suggests that Josephus was not asking for a religious conversion or a mental agreement with his propositions, but for the rebel to turn away from his present course of action and become a loyal to Josephus as his leader. He also goes through the Bible, lots of different places, Romans 1, 5, Romans 16, 26, talking about terms like the obedience of faith, which he argues is, you know, a legent obedience, the obedience that comes from allegiance. It's obvious, isn't it? If you declare

that you're going to be a legent to Jesus, that's the one thing you got to do. You've got to go from the kingdom of darkness to the kingdom of light. Now Matthew Bates doesn't do this, but I kept thinking the whole time because I'm also trying to study the atonement here and what exactly a Satan's role in all this. And I'm really starting to understand that we have this free will allegiance to his kingdom and that God's not breaking that rule. Like what we need to do is give our allegiance to another with our own free will. And anyway, I won't go into that right now, but I will say that does bring up a big point here, which is why do people like a Calvinist? Why do they hate this so much? For example, if you get excited about this and you go and tell your pastor, hey, I've heard that faith was like faithfulness and that we need to sort of like, you know, bend the knee to Jesus and then do the things that he said and you're going to get come down on like you believe in heresy. And I want to explain why they would have such a strong reaction to this, especially if they have kind of reformed a tradition. And it really does come

down to the belief in free will. So remember, Luther absolutely did not break both, well, it's Augustine is really the problem. But Luther was an Augustinian monk. He followed Augustine as if he was a saint. And one of the and Augustine taught that we didn't have free will. Augustine is where we get total depravity from, which is a derivative of the free will argument or you can look at it both ways. Maybe the lack of free will is a derivative of total depravity. But nevertheless, you know, Luther said free will is a mere lie. Of course, we all know that Calvinist and Calvin did, you know, expressly did not believe in free will. And if you don't believe that we have the free will to choose God, right? So they would say they don't like to say this. But if you press them, they will say that that salvation comes before repentance or anything else, that God has to independently of anything that you do, certainly not you bending the knee or anything like that. Just out of nowhere, essentially, for reasons that you will never know and have nothing to do with

his foresight of what you will do or anything for, in other words, for random reasons, God saves you out of nowhere. And then you can have obedience and bend the knee and baptize or whatever. So what comes before salvation or salvation comes before faith is another way to say it. You can't have faith on your own because you don't have free will to have that. You have to be saved first, and then you can have faith. So to them, the idea that you're saying that you can hear the gospel and bend the knee, choose to have faith and then be saved is structurally impossible. Now they probably wouldn't think of it that way. Most of them would just be thinking of it as saying something to the effect of you believe in a work salvation. I mean, they're not even thinking about total depravity or whatever. They just hear this as works. Oh, you need to continue to be faithful to Christ in order to be saved. Well, that really comes down to once saved always saved, doesn't it? And so if you believe in one saved always saved, then everything that I'm saying here just can't work

because it implies that you could cease to be saved. You could cease to be faithful that you could really have been saved and then cease to be saved. And of course, really, that comes down also to the free will argument. I could talk about that, but it's basically total depravity. I won't go into all that right now. But what you need to know is that you can be cut off. You can be spit out. You can abide in the vine. You can have seeds and begin to grow and the cares of this world and the deceitfulness of riches. And you can wither on the vine. You can die. You can't, I mean, there's a million ways to say in the New Testament. I was thinking about this the other day. When I actually I had a moment that was like the the prodigal son, I was totally saved. Absolutely. The Holy Spirit, the whole thing. Then I went through once I learned about one saved always saved. I did go back to my sin for about 10 years. I don't know how exactly how long. And during that time, I I was completely, you know, given over back to my sin. But I totally believed I was saved because I

believed that I totally had been saved before. And if one saved always saved was true, that's what I would point to. Am I going to heaven? Yes, because I totally was saved back then. But once I was convicted and the whole point of this story is to say that that initial conviction that got me to the prodigal son moment was not doctrine. In fact, I think if somebody came to me and said, look, once I've always saved isn't true. Here's all these 50 plus verses that say explicitly in the Bible that once I've always saved isn't true, I couldn't believe it. And this is part of my story. I just couldn't. I don't think I could have heard that no matter what anybody did. And it was just this conviction that I had to stop drinking alcohol or I was going to hell. I couldn't shake it. It was so strong that I just did it. I just quit. And I knew that I had to quit forever because like if I didn't, I was going to go to hell. And it was only then when I woke up the next morning, I was like, oh, this is, I have that same freedom, that same power, that same, you know, supernatural change that I remember from the 10 years ago when I initially repented from my sins and was given

that same power. And so it was only after that that in that month or so after that the scales literally fell for my eyes. And I talked to my wife about this the other day because in my head, it was the same thing with her. Like I, it was like, I knew all the passages about that you could lose your salvation. I knew of them all. I mean, you can't read the Bible and not see them. They're on like every page. But I just couldn't see them at the same time. It was like I had scales for my eyes. Like I was literally spiritually blinded. And it was like they just fell for my eyes. It was almost like a day. And I talked to Connie about it. I was like, did that happen to you too? And she's like, yeah, that was exactly what happened to me. It just was like I was spiritually blind. And then just, no, I didn't need somebody to teach me the passages about one. They've always saved it. It's just like they were all there because I read the Bible. And so I do think that spiritual blindness, you know, it says that Satan blinds the minds of the unbelievers. And I think that that's part

in part what's happening because we refuse to repent, because we refuse to give our allegiance. And we know that allegiance would mean obedience. If you believe what Jesus says, then you're going to have to be like, well, I guess I'm going to have to quit drinking or whatever your favorite sin is, is on the chopping block. And that's really what salvation is. That's why repentance is so tied to salvation. Because if you're going to say that Jesus is your Lord, well, you're going to have to give up that thing that you love more than Jesus. And it's not negotiable. It's not like, and it's only then after repentance, it says then the refreshing comes from the Holy Spirit after repentance and acts. So you can't get the refreshing, you know, you're asking for God to give you freedom from the desires of it. Well, you got to repent first. And I feel like repentance is helped by the idea that you're going to go to hell. And hell isn't a good place. It's not something that you can get used to like a hot tub. Go watch hell testimonies on YouTube.

That really, and this again wasn't something I did before. I got to say it was only after. But it has helped me sense to be like, oh, wow. Yeah, you can't, you can't go there. That's that absolute non-negotiable. I will absolutely do whatever is needed. And I think people hear this when they think of it as white nucleine, you know, that they must be really hard to be me to not live, you know, and do all these sins. And first of all, I'm not talking about sinless perfection, but I am talking about those big sins. They're gone. The, the sins that Jesus says you're going to go to hell if you do them. I don't do them anymore. I just don't do them anymore. But that doesn't mean I don't have other sins that I'm worried about and working on. And it's hard. Whatever I'm on right now is what I, it's hard. And eventually, I'm going to get to a place where I repent from that sin altogether too. Now that sin right now for me, I've said it before is kind of like, you know, getting high from eating carbs, like I'm getting there. I'm very, very close. But I call it getting high. It's basically just eating carbs or any kind of refined carbohydrate gives you

boost in dopamine, right? And so I finally realize that's like, that's why I like carbs is because I'm essentially getting high from it. And so I'm there. You know, I'm, you know, working on it. It's not, and I know it's sin now. I mean, it's, it's, it, it, if eating carbs isn't to sin, then smoking isn't to sin because it's just as bad as smoking. You know what I mean? And you'll say, well, smoking isn't sin. Okay, maybe not. But I guess what I'm saying is I'm now in the realm of things that you could argue. I mean, they're not specifically said in the Bible, you know, that you can't eat carbs. Or here's another one that is in the Bible, which is anger and unforgiveness and stuff. So we're going through a hard time right now with, you know, medical stuff. And if you've been in the medical world a lot, people do terrible things. People always talk about you got to be your own advocate and all this stuff. And they're really doing things that are like worthy of me ruminating about them and be like, I can't believe they did that. I mean, that they were, you know, whatever. And it's a battle that I've got to fight every day. But I'm absolutely unrelenting

about it. Like if this thing happens where they do something that's terrible and worthy of being mad at them about, like I'm battling out that because I have a, I have absolutely no unforgiveness policy in my life. I know a no anger policy. I do not let the sun go down in my anger. I am battling it. If something's bad happening, I'm forgiving. I'm praying for that person. I'm getting rid of it. So it's not that I don't have that temptation to sin or even sometimes the sinning within those kinds of things. I'm reminded of a story that David Burso said in one of his recent audios. He was talking about how he views this whole thing, you know, examine yourself to see whether or not you're in the faith. Am I in the faith? Am I going to have an yes? Am I looking at myself saying, if I die right now, I'm going to have an I finally have assurance of salvation not because of I did one thing one time, but because I can do like Paul said, examine myself to see whether or not I'm in the faith. Oh, yeah, I'm definitely in the faith. There's a Holy Spirit. I'm feeling good. I feel like, you know, I know that I'm in the faith. I'm not deceiving myself. You know,

don't deceive yourself. Those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God. I can look at those passages and be like, yeah, that's not me. I'm not doing those things. So, but it's not hard. Again, one of the things I wanted to say was that this is freedom. This is what you want. It's not like I'm burdened by the desire to do all these things. The desire's lesson that what you want is the lesson of the desire. And that only comes once you decide to never do them again and to start battling. Start with the big sin that you love more than anything. If you're not willing to repent from that one, well, you can't start this journey. You got to start with the one that has its hooks in you so deeply that you would literally think about going to hell for it. Like, that's the one that you need to worry about. Don't worry about the small things. First, that's what if you can't, it won't start until you get rid of that one. It won't start. Jesus says, you know, who has the plan heading to the plow and looks back isn't worthy of me. You know, let the dead go bury the dead, et cetera, et cetera. So, don't even try it unless you're willing to give up that one. But as soon as you recognize that you're going to either go to hell or

you're going to keep or you're going to get rid of that thing, well, then you can start this journey of bending the needy Christ. And it's easier and he's gracious and he does give you time to work on the next thing. And you're sitting there and he doesn't give it to you all in one sitting, you know? He doesn't say, okay, you got rid of that. Now, here's 50 other things that you're sitting. He usually just points to another really big one and says, okay, now this one, let's let's work on this. And that's what sanctification looks like in my life anyway. And I hope that's what it looks like in your life as long as you've been the need. I finished with a story from David Burso. He said, when he was in college, he got this test from his professor and he was sort of like, you know, really gung ho, always the guy who raised his hands like you with the right answer. Nobody else was even trying to raise her hand, but he was very serious and wanted to get it done. And he was right in his hand. He got all the right answers. And one test, he actually got the answer right, but he got it marked wrong on the test. And he went to the

professor and said, hey, look, you marked this wrong, but it's actually right. And the professor was like, oh, you know, actually, you're right. I guess my answer key was wrong and you were right. And so, but he didn't change the grade. And David Burso was like, what do you mean you're not going to change the grade? I was I was right and you were wrong. He's like, yeah, but if I change your grade, I have to go back and change everybody else's grade. And we're just not going to do that. You're just going to get the whatever the C or the B that was on the test. And he was like, well, that's not fair at all. I mean, you know, I, you know, whatever, because he's trying to, you know, get this really great grade and stuff like that. And he said, the professor looked at him and said, don't sweat it, Burso. You're going to pass the class. And I think that was helpful, because the idea is, look, I am I might seem to you as if I am like, you know, white knuckle in this situation and completely worried that I'm going to go to hell. And I do think that we do need a healthy fear of God in order to endure the various temptations that we're going to get throughout our

lives. Um, but I'm on the narrow road and I'm safely on it. And I can examine myself. I'm in the faith and I there is grace plenty of grace in this road, but you have to have faithfulness. You need to be a faithful, a legend servant to the gospel. What's the gospel? Jesus is the king of the universe. And he is the only king. Every knee shall bow to him. You can only serve one master. This is a situation you cannot fail. And here he is with his arm outstretched saying, will you follow me? Will you be my disciple? And will you bow the knee to me? And what that means is that you have free will to do that, to make that decision. And what that means is you go find out what he wants. Read the gospels for the first time and understand that you can do that. Not by your own power, but through the Holy Spirit that he gives you once he cleanses you with his blood and gives you

that freedom, that cleansing of your for completely forgiving and forgotten, all those previous sins, all those different failings, even if you once experienced salvation, but you didn't now. I mean, you've obviously been off the road. You're in the pigstie right now. Well, he's got his hand out to you too. As long as you got life in you and breath in your lungs, he's got that hand out and saying, come on, let's try this again. But this time, let's be an actual disciple. Okay, that's it for me. Go to vineabiders.com. That'll take you to the sub stack. Subscribe to the audio podcast. You can also check us out on YouTube, Vineabiders. See you next time.

More episodes

More from Vine Abiders Podcast

View all episodes →