The young conservative movement post-Charlie Kirk

0:00This week on Here and Now Anytime, 25 years after 9-11, we asked you how your life changed. I did not appreciate that day how much September 11th would come to shape my adult life. We also talk about the long shadow of Islamophobia still hanging over the country. Listen to Here and Now anytime on the NPR app or anywhere you listen to podcasts. One year ago today, conservative activist Charlie Kirk was gunned down in Utah. Today, we're going to check in with conservative youth movement. How they're coping and where they go from here. It's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Miles Parks. I cover voting. I'm Alina Mora, cover politics. And I'm Mara Liason, senior national political correspondent. And before we do dive into our main topic here, Mara, during this first ever Republican midterm convention last night, President Trump made a pretty notable new pitch. Seems like a novel way to get voters.

1:00If the Republicans win the House of Representatives and the United States Senate, both of them, because of our economic, tremendous economic success, like in history, we've never had anything like what's happening. But because of our tremendous strength and success economically, I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $5,000. I feel like the first question that comes to my mind when I saw this this morning was, like the same one that comes up a lot with Trump is like, can he do this, Mara? Sure, you mean can he promise to give everybody $5,000? I mean, is it literally legal? I don't know. Mara, make it make sense. It's legal to make a campaign promise. That's all he's doing. He's saying, if my party wins both houses of Congress, I will issue $5,000 checks to everyone. Now $5,000 checks to every adult in America would be $1.3 trillion. That's a lot of money.

2:01Whether he could actually do this without congressional approval is a whole other question. But this is very similar to someone saying, if I am elected, I will issue everyone a COVID check or a tax cut. It's no different from any campaign promise. And what's interesting about it is that Donald Trump's approval rating has dropped dramatically because he hasn't fulfilled his campaign promises. And now he's making another one. We'll see how credible it is to voters. That's what I was going to ask. It's like, does this move the political needle? Do you think, Elena? I mean, is any thoughts on whether this is going to matter this year? I mean, the first thing I thought about is, yeah, exactly what Mara said, this is a big campaign promise. But Trump is not on the ballot again, which is also something to keep in mind. This midterm election, obviously, he's not on the ballot, but symbolically he is. The midterms are often a referendum of the sitting president, so you can argue he is on the ballot. But after this midterms, he really isn't. And so I'm curious. I mean, what the White House even sees as the repercussions here on really making sure this pans out?

3:05Well, one of the things this does tell us is that as many times as Trump disparages affordability as an issue, they understand that it is the top issue of voters. And this promise of $5,000 checks to everyone is a way that they can show they recognize that affordability is an issue. They don't want to address it directly because he said it's a myth. But they know that this is what voters care about. It's also once again, just like a very tangible promise, which we know that that really resonates with voters on both sides of the aisle. I mean, the amount of voters who would tell me on the campaign trail for former president Biden, oh, he's going to forgive my student loans or, you know, Trump voters who said no tax on tips. Like these are very tangible promises and that can go a long way for someone. But I guess I mean, president Trump has promised people money a lot of different times in his second term, right? I mean, he promised people some sort of checks after the doge cuts. I remember he promised tariff refunds at one point. I guess I'm just wondering and people haven't seen money from either of those two other instances. When the average voter hears about a promise like that, do you think they engage with it like, oh, like this

4:08is actually going to happen? Or is it kind of a thing that they shrug off? Well, I can guarantee that there are posters in the field right now asking people that question. Do you think you're actually going to get $5,000 if they take both houses of Congress? What do you think? I mean, we're now at the end of a very, very long line of broken campaign promises from Donald Trump. I don't know if anybody's ever counted them up and compared them to the broken campaign promises of other presidents. But he has quite a record of doing this. All right. So this was probably the most notable moment of this midterm convention going on in Texas. It's continuing tonight where they are going to have a moment to commemorate Charlie Kirk and Elena. Other commemorations are going on in Utah where you are right now. Yeah, right. So there's a memorial tonight. It'll actually be on the campus of Utah Valley University, which is the same campus where Charlie Kirk was doing his prove me wrong event last year on September 10th, 2025 when he was shot and killed. I mean, how are young people

5:09feeling now about the Trump presidency, Elena? Because I do remember all of those stories after the 2024 election about the way that Trump was able to win this coalition that has been previously I think of when I think of political wisdom young voters have been traditionally liberal voters. And they Trump was able to make gains a lot of that because of Charlie Kirk. How are those people feeling now two years in? Yeah. And we should say, you know, Kirk is credited with helping. He was definitely a massive cultural player in this. But we can never, you know, fully attribute Trump's electoral gains with Charlie Kirk. Yeah, of course. He'll be linked to that. But, you know, former vice president Kamala Harris still won the under 30 vote. But Charlie Kirk said this to me when I spoke with him the day after the election day two years ago. He was said the goal was to lose by less. And that's exactly what they did. Trump chipped off a key portion of the Democrats needed coalition of under 30 voters. So that's all to say your question on, you know,

6:11how are young people feeling about Trump and the Republican Party now? It's complicated. A lot of young people are not, you know, as excited and resoundingly proud and happy with the state of their politics, their political leadership as they were when Trump came into office. There are massive issue divides among young conservatives on some of the same, you know, divisive issues that are playing out in the larger Republican Party, things like whether the US should have gone to war with Iran, the US's relationship with Israel, rising prices. You know, some people still bring up how the administration has handled the Epstein files. These are issues that have been, you know, somewhat of a big wake-up call for a lot of young conservatives who felt very seen by Trump's 2024 campaign. And, you know, folks have told me they feel like Trump has gone back on some of his promises. One of the great political accomplishments that Donald Trump had was to bring young men into the Republican column. But what we know from polling is that young men have begun to sour on Trump just like other parts of the Republican

7:14coalition haven't broken with him entirely, but they're less enthusiastic. A Reuters poll taken in August showed that men 18 to 29, their support for Trump was down 11 points from February a year ago. Well, when I keep thinking, you always, I feel like hammer down to this point that these younger voters don't identify with political parties the same way that older voters do. And I guess I just wonder if that makes them just generally a more fickle group that they are more willing to sort of, I don't know, take a critical eye to their party leaders or to the policies of the current moment. Yeah, yeah. I mean, here I go back on my soapbox with this generation. Here I go. I'm climbing up. This is a generation that has only known political turmoil and economic uncertainty. This is a generation speaking of the 9-11 anniversary tomorrow that is basically their entire political life has been shaped by 9-11. Most of them have only known politics that is Trump. They are extremely distrustful of institutions. They are extremely, you know, apathetic. I talk to one

8:16Democratic pollster who's been studying young people for decades. His name is John Del Volpe. And, you know, he does regular focus groups with Gen Z. He observes focus groups. He says Charlie Kirk's name still comes up all the time. And to him, it feeds into this growing feeling that so many young people are feeling which is that they have no, you know, political agency. And, you know, I found that so striking because to add to my soapbox, it is another example of this feeling that of a generation, regardless of partisan affiliation, that just has example after example of feeling like the country that they live in, the system they've been born into does not work for their benefit. Okay, let's leave it there for now more in just a moment. At NPR, there's a little something for everyone. If you need advice for that big life change, try listening to LifeKit. If you want to know more about that new TV show, check out Pop Culture Happy Hour. And if you want to dive deeper into your favorite podcasts and enjoy perks like bonus episodes, archive access, and more. Check out NPR Plus. Find out more

9:19and support the shows you love at plus.npr.org. And we're back. So, Elena, sticking with Charlie Kirk and his enduring legacy in our politics, I've been thinking today about free speech and how much that was a main issue for Kirk as he was doing for years and years and years these viral moments where he was just debating people over and over again on college campuses. It feels like an issue that, is it fair to say that that is another part of Charlie Kirk's legacy, just this sort of free speech and moving the Republican Party into winning on that issue? Yeah, I mean, I think it's a good point to bring up. I think so. I mean, Charlie Kirk, like a key part of his like initial entrance into politics was like this core value set he had on like defending free speech, free markets, limited government. Those were like his things. That key part there, free speech was crucial because he was talking about like wanting to be a conservative, proudly in liberal spaces and not be penalized for it.

10:19You know, that was that was kind of the central impetus for starting turning point. And of course supporters will will look at how he died as a clear violation of free speech. And, you know, people can disagree with Charlie Kirk's views. He said a lot of really disparaging comments towards immigrants, trans people, black people, women. He spread conspiracy theories. There was a lot of controversy, but he was still exercising free speech. And I talked to some young people yesterday who were there like watching someone get murdered for beliefs that they have is a really chilling, um, scary thing. Free speech was one of the things that formed the key critique of the left on the part of Charlie Kirk, on the part of other conservatives that there was kind of language police. And you were, it was cancel culture. And you weren't allowed to say what you thought. But after Charlie Kirk's death, there was a kind of free speech for me, but not for the because there were people who got fired from their jobs for criticizing what Charlie Kirk said when he was

11:23alive. Yeah. I mean, this young voting block that Charlie Kirk did so effectively kind of galvanize. It as we mentioned has been traditionally a difficult voting block for Republicans to energize. Where does that go from here? I guess do you, do you both think that Republicans will be able to be successful in 2026, 2028 at being able to keep these voters coming out for Republicans? I think to a certain extent, they will do that with young white men. Uh, I think that, uh, that's a pretty fertile ground for them to plow. I think it'll depend on things that are much bigger than these cultural issues like the economy. Uh, it turns out that young voters are kind of like all voters. And they care about whether they can afford a house, uh, and maybe take a vacation. If they're married with young kids, they want to think about being able to pay for their college. So yeah, I think they can't. The interesting thing is who will pick up the Kirk mantle? Is there another person like JD Vance, another young Republican who can excite them in the way

12:28that Kirk did? I don't know if that's possible, but I do think that the White House has mystified a lot of Republicans with deciding to compete with Kirk's commemorations rather than just let Kirk have his own day, uh, and then have the convention on another night. I also just think there's a really interesting parallel here, Miles, to your question, which is like, this is a generation of voters that is like really craving leaders that excite them. Um, but they've also had a lot of leaders that they take a chance on and that disappoint them. And it reminds me a lot of, you know, I can make when we were covering the 2024 election, so many Democrats and just in general voters who do took a chance on former president Joe Biden in 2020, who got a huge portion of the youth vote. It was a key coalition that put him over the margins and some of these crucial swing states. They felt very let down by Joe Biden, whether it was because of how the United States

13:33approached uh, Israel's war in Gaza or the affordability crisis. And I see some of the similar kind of sentiments forming on the right here with Trump, where young people were excited to vote for Trump and felt that he was seeing their plight. And now they once again do not feel that. And something unique, I think, about this generation or unique at the scale, rather, is this is a generation of voters, regardless of party that is not afraid to criticize their own side. You know, if we're talking about the post Trump world, the big question is, can there be somebody else on the Republican side who will have a cult of personality like he did? Joe Biden never had a cult of personality. Totally. I mean, that that vote that that in 2020 was an anti-Trump vote among young people. But Trump and Charlie Kirk, those are, those are figures that really did excite conservative young people. And the question is, who can pick up that mantle? I don't see JD Vance having a cult of personality. That's what I was going to say. Wasn't it supposed to be JD Vance? I feel like that was a year or two ago. It was supposed to be, but we haven't seen it yet.

14:35Yeah. Well, I mean, in my conversations with young organizers that involve attorney point or who used to be around the country, I end a lot of my interviews asking like, who in the party or the larger movement excites you? And I mean, it's anecdotal, but I didn't hear Vance come up that often. I mean, he did somewhat, but I don't think, at least right now, there is uniting around him. I don't think that's happening. And it kind of gets back to this question, which we're talking about both with, you know, the aftermath of Charlie Kirk's passing for turning point or just what does the Republican party look like without Trump as the leader? But when you make a man the movement, what is the movement without the man? And I think that like that's the question facing. It's the question that has been facing the Democratic Party for much longer. And it is now very much so and has been for a bit facing the larger Republican party as well. We can leave it there for today. Before we go, a quick plug for a virtual event that we're doing for our MPR plus supporters next week. It's on the midterms and the races that could decide the

15:36control of Congress. We're also going to do a live Q&A and give you a chance to ask us some questions. I'll be there. Tomorrow will be there. My co-host Tamar Keet will be there. It's next Thursday at 2 p.m. Eastern 11 a.m. Pacific over Zoom. For our plus supporters, check out our bonus episode from August 30 for details on how to register. And if you have not joined MPR plus yet, now is your chance. You can do it at plus.mpr.org. Again, that's plus.mpr.org. I'm Miles Parks. I cover voting. I'm Elena Moore. I cover politics. And I'm Mara Liason, Senior National Political and thank you for listening to the MPR Politics Podcast.