
The 401k Deal Nobody Would Take | Average vs Actual Returns (Ep. 271)
About this episode
Your 401k says 25% average return — but your actual return could be zero. Here's the math.
👉 Find more Without the Bank here: https://www.youtube.com/@MaryJoIrmen?sub_confirmation=1
👉 Get the book: https://www.withoutthebank.com/book
Part 4 of the 401k Half-Truths series breaks down the biggest illusion in retirement planning: average vs actual returns. You've probably heard your 401k grows "5-10% on average" — but that number hides a painful truth. Tarisa walks through a real math example that shows how a 25% average return can equal a 0% actual return, shares her own mom's experience of having less in her 401k than she contributed, and poses a simple question: would you take a deal where someone tells you how much to give them, charges you fees even when they lose your money, locks your money away, and penalizes you for needing it early? That's essentially what a 401k is. If you're contributing the max to your 401k, you need to understand the difference between inputs and outputs — how much you've actually put in versus what you can actually access. There are alternatives that aren't subject to market risk. This episode is about empowering you with information to make better decisions for your future.
⏱️ Chapters
0:00 - The Problem with 401k "Average Returns"
0:42 - 401k Half-Truths Part 4: Average vs Actual
1:30 - The 25% Average, 0% Actual Math Example
3:47 - My Mom's 401k Story
5:15 - How Losses Destroy Growth
6:30 - Global Economy Risk: Tariffs & Inflation
7:47 - Why Actual Return Matters More Than Average
8:50 - The 401k Deal Nobody Would Take
10:14 - Inputs vs Outputs: Audit Your 401k
11:35 - Seed vs Harvest: The Tax Trap
12:03 - Simulate Your Portfolio's Past Performance
12:34 - Guaranteed Alternatives & Final Thoughts
#personalfinance #retirementplanning #retirement #compoundinterest #401k
📘 Books Mentioned:
→ Life Without the Bank
→ Becoming Your Own Banker by Nelson Nash
👉 Get them here: https://www.withoutthebank.com/book
📧 Questions? Reach us at [email protected] or [email protected]
🌐 Learn more at http://www.withoutthebank.com
Get every episode summarized
Each time Without the Bank Podcast publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.
Email me new episodesFree for 3 shows. No card needed.
Hosts & guests
No transcript yet
This episode has not been transcribed. Request it and it moves to the front of the queue.
More episodes
More from Without the Bank Podcast

How to Build a Brand That Actually Lasts (Ep. 286)
Without the Bank Podcast

Is Airbnb Dead? 20-Year Investor Exposes the Truth About Short-Term Rentals (Ep....
Without the Bank Podcast

Why Infinite Banking 'Didn't Click' (And How to Fix It) (Ep. 284)
Without the Bank Podcast

The Real Numbers Behind Infinite Banking (It's Not What You Think) (Ep. 283)
Without the Bank Podcast