Sixteen Thousand Casualties for Two Festubert Miles

0:00Bettering your business takes working with the best. With the James Hardy Alliance, you gain access to leads, training, networking, and support from the number one brand of Siding in North America. Achieve new levels of success by joining the James Hardy Alliance today. Welcome to today's Deep Dive. Today we're looking at a battle that, well, it often gets completely lost in the overwhelming tragedy of 1915 on the Western Front. It really does. There's just so much ground to cover in that year alone. Right. We're talking about the Battle of Festibere. And I know it's incredibly easy to just gloss over these early engagements, but Festibere represents a massive fundamental tactical pivot. A completely, completely transformative moment for how the war was fought. Exactly. So our mission for you today is to cut right through the dry dates and the endless casualty lists. If you look closely at the Mud of Festibere, you find the exact moment when military mines were forced to change how modern wars are fought. And alongside that, you find deeply personal, culturally devastating stories

1:02of the people who are actually there. So to really grasp the gravity of this, we need to look at the landscape. Give us the overview. Well, it's the spring of 1915, and we are looking at a geopolitical landscape defined by a massive, deadly deadlock. We're in the Artuah region of France. Just south of Nouvechipel, right? Yeah, right. Exactly. And the British First Army, which is under General Sir Douglas Hague, along with the French 10th Army, are desperately trying to find a way to break through these deeply entrenched German lines. And the pressure is just immense. Oh, it's unbelievable. The learning curve for fighting a modern industrialized war was incredibly steep. And the cost of every single lesson they were learning was being paid in human lives. And the broader context for you to keep in mind here is the second battle of Artuah. This was a massive offensive stretching from early May, all the way to mid-June. It involved coordinated efforts between the French and the British against the German Empire. But the British military leaders weren't just flawlessly executing some grand master plan.

2:05They were scrambling. They were absolutely scrambling to adapt, just throwing everything at the wall to see what would break the stalemate. I really were. And to understand the specific decisions made at Festivere. Right, May 9th. Yes. On May 9th, the British Army suffered a catastrophic failure at a place called Aubur's Ridge. The tactics they had relied on up to that point completely fell apart. Okay, let's unpack this. Because that direct background is crucial for what happens next. At Aubur's Ridge, the British command used what they called Hurricane Bombardments. Right, Hurricane Bombardments. Which meant an intense, relatively short burst of artillery fire. The goal was rapid shock and awe. And then the infantry would advance with what they called unlimited objectives. Unlimited objectives is such a telling phrase, isn't it? It really highlights the mindset. I mean, it meant they were aiming for a massive sweeping breakthrough. They were hoping to push the line forward by an astonishing 3,000 yards. It's about 1.7 miles. Right, 1.7 miles deep into enemy territory and basically a single sprint.

3:11But it failed miserably. The Hurricane Bombardment just didn't do the job. It didn't sufficiently cut the barbed wire. It didn't destroy the machine gun nests. The German defenses held completely and the British infantry were just cut to pieces. So within a matter of days, the British command had to completely rethink their entire approach. Which brings us to the major tactical pivot we mentioned. The British look at their own failure at Aubur's Ridge and then they look over at their allies. The French. Yeah, the French, who were seeing slightly more success with a completely different method. So the British command decides to scrap the Hurricane Bombardment idea entirely. Instead, they adopt the French tactic, which is slow, deliberate artillery fire. It is a fundamental shift in military psychology. They went from trying to sprint through a brick wall to trying to slowly dismantle it brick by brick, methodically preparing the way for the infantry. Exactly. Slowly, continuously cutting through the barbed wire, and systematically demolishing German strong points over a period of days, not minutes. And they dramatically lowered their

4:15expectations for the infantry, right? They abandoned that deeply ambitious 3,000 yard breakthrough. Yes. For Festubert, the goal was narrowed down to capturing a trench line just 1,000 yards forward. A third of the distance. A third of the distance. It was designed as a continuous attack plan. It involved one division pushing from a spot known as Rudu Bois to Shakala Manier Corner, and another division attacking about 600 yards further north. If we connect this to the bigger picture. And this is vital. The Battle of Festubert officially goes down as the very first British attempt at a strategy of attrition in the first world war. Attrition. It's a grim, deeply cynical concept. It meant the generals were officially acknowledging that a glorious rapid breakthrough to win the war quickly was no longer the reality. Warfare had permanently changed. It was now about the slow agonizing grinding down of the opponent's resources and manpower. You accept that you will take heavy losses, strictly in order to inflict heavy losses on the enemy. It's the horrific realization

5:18that you aren't going to win by outmaneuvering the enemy. You're going to win by out surviving them. But what makes this specific shift to attrition at Festubert even more complex is the overarching strategic goal behind it. Because you might think an attack of this scale was about capturing a vital town or a major supply railway. But it wasn't. This entire offensive was actually designed as a massive distraction. The primary motivation for the British First Army, resuming the offensive here, was to act as a decoy. What the French 10th Army was simultaneously launching a massive attack against Vimey Ridge. Right, which is further south near RS. The British attack at Festubert was explicitly intended to attract German divisions away from the French front. The British command one of the Germans to send their reinforcements north to face them, rather than reinforcing the defenders holding off the French at Vimey. So the soldiers on the ground are being sent into a meat grinder, testing out this grueling new attrition warfare, entirely to serve as a magnet for enemy artillery and reinforcements. It's sex a terrifying tone for the execution of the battle. Now the assault

6:24targeted a salient, a piece of land jutting out into enemy territory in the German lines between new Chappelle and the village of Festubert. It was a three mile front, and they prepared to hit it with an unprecedented level of firepower. To execute this deliberate, methodical French style of bombardment, they masked 433 artillery pieces. And instead of a short hurricane barrage, they bombarded the German lines continuously for 60 hours. 60 hours. There's two and a half days of non-stop deafening explosions. They fired roughly 100,000 shells into that three mile stretch. The sheer noise and the constant vibration of the earth must have been minebending. Oh absolutely paralyzing. The intention was to completely obliterate the wire and level the strong points of the German Sixth Army. And after all that build up, the way they actually launched the infantry assault was a historic first. Here's where it gets really interesting. The attack officially began at 11.30 pm on the night of May 15th, 1915.

7:24This was the very first British night attack of the entire war. Visualizing a night attack in 1915 is chilling. The darkness would have added an unimaginable layer of chaos. You have thousands of men trying to navigate through a landscape that has just been completely pulverized by artillery. It's littered with craters and debris in pitch black. Trying to maintain formation and coordination without any modern communications equipment. Knowing the enemy is out there in the dark. So if you're an infantryman going over the top at 11.30 pm, you're probably expecting to walk into a shattered landscape where the enemy has been annihilated by those 100,000 shells. You would hope so, yeah. But what actually happened when they crossed no man's land? What's fascinating here is despite that unimaginable volume of explosive power, the 60-hour bombardment fundamentally failed. It failed completely. It did not significantly damage the frontline defenses of the German Sixth Army. How does that even happen? You drop 100,000 shells on a three mile front and the enemy's front

8:27door is still locked. It comes down to a few critical factors of early trench warfare. First, the Germans were already learning to dig deep. They were creating reinforced dugouts that could withstand a lot of the standard field artillery of the time. Second, a massive portion of the British shells were shrapnel shells, which are designed to burst in the air. Exactly. They boost in the air and rain down metal to kill troops in the open. They are practically useless for destroying earthworks or cutting thick belts of barbed wire. You need high explosive shells for that. And the British simply didn't have enough of them. And finally, the train itself in Artois was incredibly marshy. A lot of those shells simply plunged deep into the soft mud and exploded underground. Muffling the blast. Muffling the blast and leaving the defenses above ground relatively intact. So the infantry steps out into the pitch black expecting ruined trenches. And instead, they hit a solid wall of German machine gunfire. From there, the timeline of the battle becomes a horrific grinding slog. During that initial night attack, only the sixth brigade

9:33made any real progress. And that was mainly because the weather conditions were relatively good that first night. But that minor success was incredibly fleeting. The initial night attack on the 15th achieves almost nothing strategically. So the command decides to try again the very next afternoon. Right. At 3.15 pm on May 16th, they push forward again in broad daylight. The original brigades attack and they are joined by the 7th division, which opens up a completely new front further to the south. But they are running into the exact unbroken defenses. The casualties mount at an astronomical rate. By the next day, May 17th, the situation is so dire that the fourth guard's brigade of the second division has to be sent in just to relieve elements of the battered 7th division. And even with fresh elite troops, they only manage to secure minor, agonizingly slow advances. It just keeps grinding on. This is the reality of the new attrition strategy. By May 19th, just four days after the initial night attack, the fighting capacity of the units involved is simply gone.

10:35The casualties are so devastating that both the second division and the seventh division have to be withdrawn from the battle entirely. And the main objectives they set out to capture on May 15th still firmly in German hands. And as those original divisions were shattered and pulled off the line, the British command had to feed new forces into the meat grinder to keep the distraction going. The troops fighting this battle weren't just from the United Kingdom. This offensive relied on the incredible diversity of a global empire. Right there in the initial assaults, you had Indian troops from the Garwal Brigade and the seventh Meirut division. And then on May 18th, the first Canadian division is ordered into the freight. Assisted by the 51st Highland division. But by the time the Canadians and the Highlanders enter the battle, the environmental conditions have completely deteriorated. The relatively clear weather of the initial assault is gone. They are ordered to attack in heavy rain. The battlefield, which was already marshy and created by artillery, turns into an absolute quagmire of deep, thick mud. Charging a fortified machine gun position is terrifying enough.

11:38Now imagine doing it in a torrential downpour slipping and sinking into the mud with artillery shells, geysering water and earth all around you. The Canadians and the Highlanders threw themselves at the German lines, but made very little progress in the face of intense artillery fire. The British forces eventually had to just stop the forward momentum and violently dig in to hold their new, slightly advanced front line right there in the heavy rain. And while the British Empire forces were bogging down in the mud, the Germans were using the time efficiently. They brought up reinforcements and strengthened their secondary defensive positions even further. The British attempted to resume the attack from May 20th all the way to May 25th, but it was completely futile. They made virtually no further progress. The Battle of Festubert finally sputtered to an exhausted halt. So what does this all mean when the guns finally stopped on May 25th? What did this grand shift to attrition actually achieve? We have to look at the numbers. Let's break down the sobering math of this 10-day battle. For all that planning, the 60-hour bombardment, the night attacks,

12:42the endless waves of global troops, the offensive resulted in a total advance of just 1.9 miles. That is about three kilometers. You could comfortably walk that distance in your neighborhood in less than 40 minutes. The cost of that 1.9 miles of muddy French territory is staggering. The British Empire suffered 16,648 casualties. To break that down, the second division alone suffered over 5,400 casualties. The seventh division lost over 4,100. The 47th division lost over 2,300. The first Canadian division suffered over 2,200 casualties, and the seventh me route division suffered over 2,500. Over 16,000 men killed, wounded, or missing for a 40-minute walk. And what about the German side, the defenders who were supposed to be ground down by this new strategy of attrition? How many losses did they take? The German sixth army suffered around 5,000 casualties, which includes about 800 men who were taken prisoner. So the strategy of attrition in this very first British iteration resulted in the attackers taking more than three times the

13:43casualties of the defenders they were trying to grind down. Taking three times the losses of your enemies a horrifying way to wage a war. And to really understand the scale of the violence happening across the western front in the spring of 1915, we have to look at those numbers in the context of the broader second battle of our twa. Right, because Festubert didn't happen in a vacuum. While the British were fighting and dying at Festubert, the French were fighting their own grueling battles to the south. French casualties during the wider our twa offensive reached over 102,000 men. Wow. Total German casualties across the entire sector were over 73,000. 16,000 casualties at Festubert. A hundred thousand French casualties. Those numbers are so vast they can easily become abstract. They lose their human scale. Exactly. But what if we look at exactly who made up those numbers? Because of how the British army recruited at the time, those casualties weren't spread evenly across the country. They were hyper concentrated. The military used what they called the PALS battalion system or localized territorial forces. Men from the same villages,

14:47the same factories were the same sports teams were actively encouraged to enlist together and serve shoulder to shoulder. Which meant that a single bad afternoon on the front line could literally wipe out a generation of men from one specific town. Which brings us to a deeply specific cultural impact that shows how a battle in France rippled out and devastated communities far away. We have to look at the Scottish Highlands and a traditional stick-in-ball game called Shinti. Shinti has incredibly deep cultural roots in the Scottish Highlands. These Shinti teams weren't just random guys playing a weekend game. They were the absolute anchors of their communities. And because of those localized recruitment strategies, these tight-knit Shinti playing communities were disproportionately devastated by the losses at the Battle of Festubert. Whole teams enlisted together, fought together, and fell together in the mud of our twa. The impact on these small Highland towns was so profound in lasting that a full century later, the 100th anniversary of the battle in 2015 wasn't just marked by politicians laying

15:49wreaths in London. It was marked intimately by the sports teams themselves. Shinti clubs representing areas that lost a massive portion of their young men organized their own centennial commemorations. Records of the 2015 commemorations show specific teams coming together to mourn. Sky Caminocht and KINGUSI Caminocht, two areas that lost a great many men at Festubert, joined up with the British forces' own Shinti team, known as Scott's Caminocht. They held an entire weekend of commemorations, lectures, memorial services, and Shinti matches on the Isle of Sky, strictly to remember the players who never came back from that 1.9 mile advance. A week after that event on the Isle of Sky, another club, the Buley Shinti club, held their own memorial. They specifically chose to rename their local sports pavilion to honor two brothers who died in the battle. Donald and Alistair Patterson. You hear those names and suddenly it's not 16,000 anonymous casualties on a ledger anymore. It's Donald and Alistair. Just two years before the battle in 1913,

16:49the Patterson brothers were part of the Buley team that won the Caminocht Cup, which is essentially the holy grail of the sport. They were local champions, athletic, young, the pride of their entire town. And by May of 1915, they were both killed at Festubert. The loss of men like the Patterson brothers ripped a hole in the social fabric of these highland towns that took generations to heal. But there is one final haunting detail regarding Donald Patterson that really bridges the gap between the pulverized battlefield in France and the community left behind in Scotland. Donald played the bagpipes. Yes. And decades after he was killed in the battle in the early 1980s, his personal bagpipes were somehow recovered along with his other effects. It's incredible to think of a wooden instrument surviving the destruction of that battlefield and making its way back home decades later. And what's truly chilling is that during those deeply emotional 100th anniversary commemorations in 2015, those exact same bagpipes, Donald Patterson's bagpipes were played. A century after the artillery

17:49of Festubert silenced him, his music was heard again by the communities still mourning him. That really just encapsulates how a 1.9 mile stretch of muddy French territory represented this massive shift in world history. The dawn of attrition warfare, the first British night attack, and the tragic intersection of a global war with local communities. This raises an important question. One that really lingers when you look at the totality of what happened over those 10 days, we have to remember the strategic reality we discussed at the very beginning. This entire battle, the 60-hour bombardment, the terrifying night attacks, the desperate charges in the rain by troops from across the globe was fundamentally designed as a decoy. It was a strategic move by high command to draw a German attention away from the French fighting at Vimey Ridge. It forces you to ponder the deeply chilling mathematics of modern warfare. You have to consider the minds of the military planners who sat in relatively safe rooms, looking at broad maps, and weighed the deliberate sacrifice of 16,000 of their own men.

18:52They accepted the devastation of entire cultural communities, erasing local champions like the Scottish Shinti players, all to act as a distraction for an ally miles away. It requires a level of calculated ruthlessness that is incredibly difficult to fully comprehend today. It's a heavy thought, and it's exactly the kind of perspective we hope you take away from these deep dives. We want to thank you so much for joining us. The history we think we know is always infinitely more complex and often far more heartbreaking when we actually take the time to unpack the tactical realities and the human cost. Keep asking questions, keep looking past the casualty lists, and keep questioning the history you thought you knew. We'll see you next time. You're listening to a podcast right now, driving, working out, walking the dog. If you're in a podcast, chances are you have something to say too. With RSS.com, starting your own podcast is free and easy. Upload an episode and we distribute it to Apple podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and more. Track your listeners, see where they're from, and start earning from ads just like this.

19:55If you've been thinking about starting a podcast, this is your sign. Start your new podcast for free today at rss.com. You're listening to a podcast right now, driving, working out, walking the dog. If you're into podcasts, chances are you have something to say too. With RSS.com, starting your own is free and easy. Upload an episode and we distribute it to Apple podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and hundreds more. Track your listeners, see where they're from, and start earning from ads like this. Even with just 10 listeners a month. If you've been thinking about starting a podcast, this is your sign. Start free at rss.com.