
About this episode
Irish Breakdown answers questions about Notre Dame Football, College Football, Irish Recruiting and much more in the latest Notre Dame Football Mailbag! This is part three of the show.
Shop for Irish Breakdown gear at our online store: https://ibstore.irishbreakdown.com/
Join the Irish Breakdown premium message board: https://boards.irishbreakdown.com
Stay locked into Irish Breakdown for all the latest news and analysis about Notre Dame: https://www.irishbreakdown.com
Subscribe to the Irish Breakdown podcast on iTunes: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/irish-breakdown/id1485286986
Like and follow Irish Breakdown on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/irishbreakdown
Sign up for the FREE Irish Breakdown daily newsletter: https://www.subscribepage.com/irish-breakdown-newsletter
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Get every episode summarized
Each time Irish Breakdown publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.
Email me new episodesFree for 3 shows. No card needed.
Hosts & guests
Transcript ready
537 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.
Full transcript
Irish Breakdown — Notre Dame Football Mailbag - Part III. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.
The Maps app that came with your phone, it's fine if you enjoy waiting and guessing and inefficient routes or you could use MapQuest. MapQuest is back with live directions, real-time traffic and faster routes. It moves when you move. Best of all, no prints are needed, no paper, no more misterns, just you and the app. Get there fast with MapQuest. Download the MapQuest app on the app store or visit MapQuest.com. MapQuest, still getting you there. Every team, every topic, everywhere. This is believed. Getting into part three of the Irish breakdown podcast brought to you by our friends over at FanDuel.
We got the Friday free for all mail-back, getting us kicked off here. In part three, we got Jason Rose. He says, hey guys, do you think Notre Dame has the most talented roster in college football this year? I think they might. On real amount of depth and mix of veterans and youngsters. I've been on record to saying this before Jason and I'll gladly say it again. I absolutely think Notre Dame has the best roster coming back, coach football. Is it head and shoulders above everybody else? No, it's not, but I think it's the best. Look, you've got an elite quarterback. No, you don't have a lot of experience at running back, but I don't care about experience at running back. I care about talent. They've got talent. They've got depth of talent. Receiver, sure. There's things to prove at receiver. So is such a true for some of the other teams that are in contention for top rosters. I think Oregon's in the conversation for top roster. They've got questions that receiver two from an experienced standpoint. In the past, Notre Dame had experience and maybe some talent issues compared to top units. I don't think they have a talent issue in 2026. I think they have an experience issue and can they develop it and use it
correctly? Tight end room again. There's other rooms with more experience, but there aren't a whole lot of rooms that I would say have more talent than what Notre Dame has. There's a couple that have really good tight end rooms. I think Notre Dame has gone through a little bit of this over the years of tight end where sometimes it's really good, but sometimes it's not. You think of and how that 2020 tight end room with Michael Mayer and Brock Wright and Tommy Trumble, but there was also years where it was like Tyler Lewatua, Nick Wischer. It was a nice tight end, but like, it's like, yeah, it wasn't a great room in those years. It was a solid room, but it wasn't a great room. I think this year's going to be a bit of a dip compared to the elite level tight ends. I don't know that Cooper Flanagan is that, but I think it's going to send back up very soon when you look at James Flanagan as a red shirt freshman, Ian Primer, as a true freshman and in Preston Frizel, guys like that. I think they're in a great position with like Jackson Dollar and Malik Howard in 27 class, where it's ascending back up and it's
going to become an elite position group. But even right now, it's a without a doubt a top 7-8 tight end room in coach football. I think they've got a big time D-Line room. Yes, there's, as we, as our preview show, there's still questions that have to get answered, but talent is not a problem. I mean, the fact that Chris Burgess right now goes into spring practice, probably is like your six or seventh detackle, says everything you need to know about how deep this defensive tackle room is. Your D-ins don't have the same amount of depth, but you could have arguably the best one to punch in the country at defensive end from a talent standpoint. It's in the conversation. You have the best and deepest linebacker room in coach football, and I would argue you have the deepest and most talented secondary in the nation. On top of having what I would argue is the number one or number two quarterback in the country coming back. So I absolutely think they have the best roster in coach football. And can you debate it? Sure, you can debate it, but I know the rosters of the other top teams and no, I don't think the rosters are better. Yeah, I also think that
Notre Dame has the most talented roster in coach football. I mean, look, it depends on who you talk to. The two guys sitting on this side of the screen thinks it's Notre Dame. Now, some people only view that as just overall star power. And some people like, well, they don't have a Jeremiah Smith. It's like, okay, I'm taking Notre Dame's secondary over Ohio States. I'm taking Notre Dame's lineback in core over Ohio States. I'm taking their defensive line depth and talent over Ohio States. I'm taking their offensive line potential over Ohio States. I'm taking their running back room. That one's a little bit closer. I'm taking their starting quarterback over Ohio States. So it just depends on the school that you want to nitpick. I've also heard, well, they don't have a Collins Simmons. It's like, okay, not yet. They might this year production wise. I think Collins Simmons is the best edge roster returning in college football. Just like I think Jeremiah Smith is the best wider seeber coming back in college football. Notre Dame also has the best quarterback coming back in college football. Right. You don't play this game. Jeremiah Smith player on offense. Right. But they have that guy on defense is a great point, Trev. Yes, agree. Yeah. They have his they have his counter. Yeah,
we might not have the best wider seeber in the country with the best corner. I mean, it's just the conversation go both ways. So yes, I think they do. Yeah. Some interesting responses, Trev, to the rivalry thing, Andrew Gilmore said, I think playing Miami every year would be great. You know, the only thing that turns me off a little bit about Miami is I still hate the fact that home stadium is an NFL stadium that doesn't match the colors of their team. It doesn't feel like you're playing a road game. It's a tough road environment. It's just different. And I don't love that. But the program makes a lot of sense. Raymond Hartons says same thing. I'd take Miami over Michigan. Joe Mark has an interesting comment. Why not just keep BYU. They seem poised to be a top 15. I mentioned this. I wrote an article about this athlete schedule BYU. And I said, I'd have no problem making this a long term rivalry. No problem. If that's the direction I want to go. I don't know that I'd view that as a replacement long term for USC. But look, I think Notre Dame should
would be wise to any time a team wants to sign a long term deal, take it. If you can get some scheduling stability over the next 10 years, you've got the 12 year deal coming up with Clemson. You know, you've got obviously a deal with Navy. If Stanford wanted to sign a 10 year deal, I'd sign it. If Purdue, Michigan State, Miami, BYU wanted to sign 10 year deals, I'd take them, you know, and get four to five guaranteed games a year. Plus you have the four to five ACC games a year. Now you've only got to find a couple games a year. Well, for the next 10 years, most of those games are already scheduled. So I would, I would, I'd have no problem playing BYU. And I wrote an article about that. I just, like, if you're going to say that's the replacement for USC, I'd say, okay, that I don't love that because I would rather replace USC with a rival. But this would be creating a new rivalry, which has some some history to it. And I'd have no problem with. But I, I'd say do that, but still do this is kind of how I'd make that argument. Bill Walsh does Miami
adds flexibility because they're ACC. Black Irish Chris says Indiana. I honestly Trevor have zero desire to schedule any kind of anything long term with Indiana. They're good now, but I just don't see what value that brings to you. And if you want somebody to be an in-state rival, let it be a program that you have history with. And at that point, let it just be Purdue. Chris, I get where you're coming from because Indiana is fresh off of a national title. And I get that completely. But I do think a lot of their success is going to be determined on how long Kurt Signetti stays there. While he's still there, their team that's going to contend for a playoff spot in the championship, I think pretty regularly. But once he leaves, you're going to get another Kurt Signetti type of coach in there. I don't know if there's another Kurt Signetti in college football right now. So who knows what the outlook is going to be? I mean, in 2036, I don't know if he's still going to be the coach there. It's going to be in his 70s. So who knows? But I get where you're coming from though. It's not a crazy thought. From just your ordinary Joe, for both of you,
is there a coach in your personal athletic past whose priority on character formation or life lessons was especially memorable? Any anecdotes about that coach? So I mean, obviously you're always impacted, Joe. And I thank you so much for the question, buddy. There's a lot of different coaches that have had an impact on my life, some directly, some not directly. Biggest impact I had like as a kid are the coaches that like actually showed like they cared. They believed in me. You know, that was a big thing for me. But I unfortunately, I wasn't blessed with a lot of coaches in like high school and college, especially college that I that I looked at as like mentors. Like I really felt like they were really impacted me in that kind of way. The coach who had the biggest impact on my life as somebody I worked for. And that was Mike Donnelly at Mulemberg back in 2002. And I was actually planning on going back in 2003. I got a call from Duquesne about interviewing for the receivers job in the summer. And coach Donnelly gave me his blessing to go interview for the job because it was a it wasn't a ladder. It was a ladder move position-wise
receivers, running backs coaches, receivers coach. But it was going from D3 to one double A. And that's why he kind of gave me the, and it's only reason I considered it me also because I love that at Mulemberg. I really love living in downtown. I loved the kids at Mulemberg. They were awesome kids. They were smart kids. They were hard workers. A lot of Jersey kids, a lot of Philly area kids, just like the blue collar, smart, hardworking kids. I really did love it there. But he was someone who, you know, he talked about like anecdotes. It was it was really just about him teaching that like, look, family can can be a priority for you and you can still win. But if it's if it's winning plus making the most amount of money possible, then it's harder to do that. He was a defensive coordinator in the Ivy League. And it's a guy that had offers to go coach at higher levels. And he was actually, I believe the defensive coordinator for at Columbia when Marcellus Wadi was there, I believe. But he went to the division three level because
he had two young kids and he wanted to be a dad more than he wanted to be a football coach at a higher level. And now that, I mean, there's there's coaches that coach at the higher level. And they're also great dads. Like I'm not saying that can't happen. But I'm saying for him, the lesson for him was was really about like, look, your family's got to come first. And the other thing that he taught me was like, if we're not developing these young men to be successful in life, what are we really accomplishing here? You know, like, like, what are we really doing? If these kids go out and win a bunch of football games and set records, but they're not prepared to go be successful men in life, whether it's his fathers, whether it's his husbands, whether it's his employees or employers, then what do we really do it? And that was very adamant for him. And then the other thing is just kindness. He knew I didn't make a lot of money working for him. He knew that there was limitations there. So he'd do things like this, Trevor. There was this sandwich place in town. And I can't remember the name of it, but I wish I could remember the name of it. But the
sandwiches they had there were called hogs and they were phenomenal. And he'd say, hey, Brian, you know, go get us lunch. All right, cool. I was a, you know, there you're, I wasn't a G.A. I was an assistant coach, but like, I made G.A. money. I made like, I think $3,000. But we also like, there was a house there that the school owned. And so we didn't have to like pay rent and all that other stuff. And we had a, you know, we had a meal plan so we could eat on campus and all that. But he's good and he'd give me like 50 bucks or he'd give me a hundred dollar bill and he'd just like, just keep the change. You know what I mean? Like just, but just decency, you know, just, just being a good person. And that sometimes that meant, hey, Brian, like, you know, we need to scold you a little bit because of this or I need to tell you that, you know, you need to do this better or that better. But, but just when you think about my sense of what truly matters as a coach, it number one comes from my dad. My dad raised me and my mom and dad raised me in a way that that was core to my principles. But Mike Donnelly showed me that how it works in this vocation.
You know what I mean? Like, and that's why he had such an impact on me and not just as a coach, but also as a husband, you know, and how I run my business. You know, like, Trevor, I think most people that work for me would be willing to say this. But like, yeah, I'm demanding. But I also, I think I treat guys with respect and give you a lot of freedom and don't necessarily ask you to do things that I'm not willing to do. But just treat you with respect. And I think doesn't mean that respect doesn't mean I can't ask a lot of you. But it just means like, you matter to me. You know, you're not just someone that I need to do a job, but you matter to me. And I hope that that I'm able to be that. But that I, you know, for my parents, but then also learning that from Mike Donnelly at Mulemberg was a big, a big thing for me, big thing for me. So I, you know, since we're doing Notre Dame stuff, the most trouble I got in for Mike Donnelly,
I didn't mean I didn't get most of it was like, bring them in and like, hey, yeah, I saw you doing this. Let's maybe work on this. Let's maybe try this. We were playing Gettysburg. And I can't remember. I think it was Gettysburg and we were killing them. It was, we ended up winning like 41 nothing. We're killing them. And it was night. It was, it was 2002. And it was the week that Notre Dame was playing Florida State. And so to have flip phone, when that flip phones first started having internet on them, it was like, I had a flip phone and I could check scores. And it was like real slow to update. But in the second half of the game, I kept pulling my flip phone out of my pocket to check the score of the Notre Dame Florida State game. Somebody saw me in the stands and called Mike Donnelly and reported it. And he was like, he scolded me for that. And I was like, I didn't care. I guess I was the day Notre Dame beat Florida State that day. You know, too. So I was excited about it. But yeah, that was pretty funny. Little Notre Dame. That's awesome. That's awesome. Yeah. For me, Joe, my quarterback coach, my first three years of high school Jeff Miller, who actually Vince knows, like they like grew
up together. So Vince knew him and he's now the head coach at Brandywine High School. He taught me a lot of valuable lessons and he taught me what it kind of meant to be a quarterback. Kind of taken some of the lessons that he's taught me and applied it to my daily life and how I treat the people in my life. A lot of what he told me is that quarterbacks get too much of the credit when you win and too much of the blame when you lose. And so it's kind of about living in the gray. That's something that I talk about a lot on this show of expectations for players. But it's also kind of how I conduct myself. I'm sure my wife and some of my friends would tell you I've natural leadership qualities. And I think I learned a lot of those under him. And what it truly means to be a leader, not just vocal. And it's also about putting in the work that nobody sees. Because if you are going to get the credit for something, you got to put in the work to do it. Because naturally, if you're a quarterback, you get a lot of that and it just comes with the territory. You know, you're the one that the newspapers want to interview that people want to do interviews with preseason. But I mean, if you're not the one leading the charge at workouts or anything like that.
So I take that mindset. It's a lot of being in a hot like that's how I feel about, you know, leading a household, being a good friend. And so a lot of those were from him. He left after my sophomore year of high school. That was an emotional day. But that's been a lot of it. He was a coach that took the time to go the extra mile for me because that was his expectation for me. I mean, my family didn't have enough money. I didn't get my first car in high school until like my senior year, all of my friends were driving by like the end of their sophomore years. You know, we would have workouts at 5 a.m. at the school. He'd go out of his way to come pick me up to make sure I could make it to them. So taking the extra mile and doing the extra things for the people that you care about. It's a big lesson that I went from him as well. So yeah, it's him and I don't even know if it's overly close as far as like in my athletic career. The only high school coach I had that really had a big impact in my life was a guy named Adam Chansky, who was my head coach, my junior year of high school. And then he left. He's the guy
that I followed down to Florida. I was going to go play for him. He became a decordinator at University Christian school in Jacksonville, Florida. And I was going to move down there and play for him. But I got rolled in eligible because I wasn't going to live with my parents, even though I was 18. But I did play spring ball down there. So he was a good guy. Yeah, high school coaches have such an important role in developing young men because most won't go play cause football. They won't have that Mike Donnelly figure at college. They are the final impact. And I have great respect for guys who value that. So that's good stuff. Real good stuff. Super chat from Tyler Evans. Appreciate you, man. Is there a team you could see this year in the top 10 end up like Penn State or LSU did last season? I mean, that's so hard to predict because I would not have even dreamed that Penn State was going to be that way. But LSU we did feel was that way. Honestly, we did feel that LSU was a team that could potentially falter.
So there's a little bit different, but I did not see the Penn State. The worst case scenario for Penn State was they were going to go nine and three. That was to me, that was worst case scenario. Who could be that team this year? I'm just going to go through ESPN's kind of top 13 teams on their way to early top 25. I don't see Indiana having that big of a draw like that sort of seven and five or worse drop off. I don't think Texas has that kind of drop off. I don't think Notre Dame has that kind of drop off. I don't think Georgia has that kind of drop off, but Georgia could be LSU. They won't be Penn State. Penn State went six and six, but it was worse than that because they played some really bad teams. They were able to barely beat later in the year. Oregon, I don't think that's an issue for Ohio State. I don't see that happening for Texas tech possibly, but I don't see that big of a drop off. I don't see it with Miami. Ole Miss is a team that I could see taking a big step back. Really big step back. That would probably be my pick.
You look right outside the top 10 Texas A&M, BYU, Oklahoma, USC. USC, I think, have an LSU type of disappointing season because of their schedule and I just don't have a lot of faith in Lincoln Riley, but those would probably be my schools that I think could potentially have that type. I'm not predicting it, but they're the ones that I could see that. In Fight and Mike said, Penn State is only 500 because they're out of conference schedule and he's 100% right because they played nothing but FCS and G5 teams and not even good ones at that. They beat Nevada Florida International in Villanova. It was not good. Their power for four wins in the regular season was Michigan State Nebraska and Rutgers. Yeah, Ole Miss is probably the runaway favorite for me. I'm going to always keep my eye on Texas tech because one team has just one year of being really good. I don't then set the standard of like, well, that's just who they are
now. That's what made Indiana's run so impressive to me in 2025 because I was one of those people until proven differently. I thought 24 was kind of a flash in the pan because people weren't seeing them coming. That's what made that run really impressive for me. So Texas Tech going undefeated in the regular season or did they go, yeah, undefeated in the regular season, I think. Texas Tech? Yeah. No, they lost airs on a state without that. That's right because they had, yeah, no, that's right. But Texas Tech really for the better part of the last decade has been a perennial like 7-8-9 win team. The one time they make the playoffs and have an 11-1-12-1 record going into the playoffs isn't now my, all right. Well, they're just going to be that way every single year. So they'd be at my top class. They got by Oregon Trev. Like they got super outclass by Oregon. They did one like you and I've talked about before. It's any team that's predominantly made up through the portal. Now they do have guys coming back but they had to hit the portal hard again. You just never know how that's going to be. The other team that I'm also thinking about and I
hope that this doesn't happen and I hope that this doesn't happen is Texas A&M solely because of their schedule. I think culturally they're fine. I do think that we've seen the best of Marcel Reed at quarterback. But I mean, man, you know, they get on the road against LSU before September is even over and then they're on the road against Missouri and October. But really from October 24th to the rest of the season, their schedules are pretty nasty. They get on the road against Bama, on the road against South Carolina, home against Tennessee, on the road against Oklahoma, and then home against Texas. That's that's rough. That's an interesting one to Trev because they're where they're, they didn't have a lot of personnel losses everywhere. They had heavy personnel losses at two positions, offensive line and defensive line. That's a big concern that I have about Texas A&M. Very big concern. That's a good one. It's a very good one. Hey, it's Howie Mandel and I am inviting you to witness history as me and my Howie do it gaming
team take on Gilly DeKing and wallow 267's million dollars gaming in an epic global gaming league video game showdown four rounds multiple games one winner plus a halftime performance by multi-platonomartis Traviemagoi. Watch all the action and see who wins and advances to the championship match against Neo right now at globalgaming league dot com that's globalgaming league dot com everybody games. The maps app that came with your phone it's fine if you enjoy waiting and guessing and inefficient routes or you could use map quest. Map quest is back with live directions real-time traffic and faster routes it moves when you move best of all no prints are needed no paper no more misterns just you and the app get there fast with map quest download the map quest app on the app store or visit mapquest.com map quest still getting you there thank you for calling the bombas comfort line bombas make socks slippers tease and underwear made with the highest quality
materials press one for comfort two for style three for donation you chose style bombas of styles for whatever you enjoy you can run in bombas lounge and bombas dress them up dress them down but always give back in bombas because with every item purchased another is donated bombas comfort worth calling for go to bombas dot com such audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase that's b o m b a s dot com and use code audio college basketball is nonstop big games tight spreads momentum swings every night and now fandall is giving you a way to turn that energy into bigger wins with the college basketball parlay profit boost here's how it works build any college hoops parlay you like the early tip the rivalry game the ranked matchup the late night west coast shootout mixed spreads totals props whatever fits your read of the slate then just apply your profit boost and instantly bump up that potential payout go safe go spicy go with the team you've been following all season it's your parlay your style now with more upside behind it
head to fandall.com slash believe to get started fandall play your game must be 21 plus in present in select states for a Kansas in affiliation with a Kansas star casino or 18 plus in present in DC Kentucky or Wyoming opt in required minimum two leg parlay required bonus issued as a nod with drawable boost builder tokens restrictions apply including any token expiration of max wager amounts c terms at sportsbook dot fandall dot com gambling problem call 1-800 gambler or 1-800 my reset call 1-888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org slash chat in Connecticut or visit md gambling help dot org in Maryland hope is here visit gambling helpline ma.org or call 800-327-5050 for 24 seven support in Massachusetts or call 877-8 hope and why or text hope and why in New York for Louisiana call 1-877-770-7867
from chief Brody aka bobo noted aim quarterback with the most drip of all time and noted aim quarterback with the least drip of all time i'm going with jimmy for the most jack cone for the least okay before i answer this question Trevor i need to explain to me what the heck drip is it's like looking cool okay like on the field accessories off like chief that was that would have been my question we talked like on field or off field trip because off field it's like i mean probably Riley Leonard i he seems like somebody that would wear like a hoodie jeans to class every day i mean off the field it'd probably be jimmy because he showed up the campus in a he said style style on field yeah okay all right that helps yeah that definitely else jimmy would be my answer as well um Riley Leonard actually had some of that when you think of like the wristbands and like the the verses and all i mean he had the the towel he had some
i can't even say the word i feel like i'm 15 but he had some of that i'm gonna i'm gonna disagree with you on jack cone i am because like i know jack wasn't super athletic but i thought jack played with some swagger yeah i mean this is a kid that you know you're you're going down the field for a game winning touchdown drive he gets his finger dislocated he runs at the sideline they pop that sucker back and he goes in like two plays later if those touchdowns pass one game you know and jack played with some fire jack look stiley out me had the towel you know me he looked fine i don't think he was like goofy looking i think the guy that the probably the least amount of that would probably be oh you want to say because i think people are going to take it wrong i'd say probably probably Tommy Reese as far as just like not having i mean Tommy wasn't flashy Tommy you know he didn't he wasn't like with a lot of gear you know he just yeah i'd probably say
Tommy it was the least i'd go Jimmy or Riley with the most Brady Quinn i mean to be honest his guns were part of his style and everybody saw those so i'd probably put him a little bit in that one in my lifetime Tony rice had a lot of that too i was just i was just about to say like i from the old games that i've seen like rocking two towels is pretty sick i wouldn't do it but that's definitely you would have if you were a college player in 1988 oh yeah 100 percent i mean i for the most i think Evergolson has to be in that conversation too he had the visor he had the towel he had like the the three-quarter leggings that were big at that point in time um no didn't even has it really had a quarterback that's rock like an arm sleeve that's never like cj wore one against poisey state but who's in his non-throwing arm that was pretty cool least of all time probably Tommy just as far as like on field like drip like as far as
like accessories that you have because i agree with you jack Cohen had like the swagger about him but that was more in his play style yeah i'd i'd probably say Tommy Reese that or i mean if we're counting him as a starter because he did for a little bit no seven Evan sharply was a pretty bland drink yes in so many ways yes i agree with that yeah that's a great one let's go without one Vince will appreciate my response that yes Evan sharply without a without a doubt now we can move on from the drip conversation from Andre Tonsel top ten non-quarterback position players on offense and defense i think this question could be part of his show who show i'm a little confused um top ten players because i don't think it's just the ten starters because that doesn't necessarily in no particular
order because i can't sit there and write it all out and rank it i'll say top ten players combination of talent plus production experience i'll go non non-quarterback i'll go jade and great house jordan phase on Anthony nap gerbielambert ashton craig will go james flanagan and neus williams because i'm trying to also like look at guys with some experience whenever he comes back charles jagasaws in that conversation and then i'll have to put a couple guys who haven't played a bunch in there i'll go i'll go will black because he's immensely talented and i will go um
quincey porter that'll be my ten top i like that yeah and i'll we just go on off of like talent like talent slash production plus production plus experience like you know like there's got to be some level of what you've done and now quincey porter hasn't done a whole lot but he's played more meaningful minutes than like cam Williams has for example who is one of the ten most there's no question that cam Williams is one of the ten most talented players on the team but i think so is grace and mccue and i'm not going to put him on this list either because he's you know the main like so that's kind of why i look at it there's got to be some level of of of that yeah for sure yeah i in no particular order then i'd probably go gerbielambert anthony nap adeus williams jayden great house jordan phazon one of quincey porter or myland gram heck that james flanagan probably has to be in that conversation now for just overall talented
gosh yeah i'm with you i mean like guys like will black interested to see what mica gilbert does he's been a player that's been mentioned in some of the player interviews of somebody that's been pretty difficult to cover so far this offseason but again who's that mica gilbert but again can he translate the offseason kind of hype into the inseason hype we'll see but as far as talent goes yeah caught cj's first touchdown pass so i mean in he's been talked about each of the last two offseason there's a guy to keep an eye on and he just can't stay healthy i know that's the problem there aliza burske probably have an argument in this conversation too but yeah it's good stuff good question here's another good one from chicil oatmeal how would it prime charlie wise do is offensive coordinator on this twenty twenty sixteen that's a great question because man he was really good at Notre Dame as an offensive coordinator but also his Kansas teams weren't
very good and his Florida team was not very good like um and those were obviously both after his time at Notre Dame obviously he went to florida first and then i think he went to Kansas after that right and his offense as a Kansas were really bad and i think that's partly because he doesn't know how to build a team he inherited a bunch of good veteran players at Notre Dame but i i think i think charlie wise's offense is dependent on having an elite quarterback and he had four really good offenses at Notre Dame and one terrible offense in their name what was the difference between the two Brady Quinn Brady Quinn Jimmy Klauson Jimmy Klauson right in the mill Evan Sharpley and freshman injured Jimmy Klauson you know John Brantley I think was this quarterback at that Florida and then a a broken dane chris and some other guys at Kansas charlie wise with cj car would probably be pretty good yeah he is good but he'd be pretty good
oh green i for the twenty six season i think you'd be special i think you'd be very good offense i do think it would be one of those things though where somebody whether it'd be freeman or an assistant coach on a staff might have to have them dial things back a little bit because what made charlie wise is often so great when Brady Quinn was running it was very close to a like an NFL style offense and he had a very experienced veteran quarterback along with a very talented quarterback with the head the ability to run it i think first couple games would have been like okay hey like we kind of have to you know simplify a little bit but i think it would have been i think freeman's conversation would have been hey bra i need you to run a ball a bit more i think that would have been the big beef we need you run a ball a bit more it's a good one i want to try to get to all the ones we haven't got to yet then we'll go back to the top and just work through the the duplicates from j melvin i was looking back at bubacars recruitment why were a lot of the major teams not after him outside of michigan and Notre Dame there wasn't that many elite programs after a four star top
200 to 150 recruit that's fair i think there's a couple reasons why uh number one is injuries he was he was not often healthy in cotton high school uh he's from massachusetts so he's not exactly a big time program i think that factored into it as well and he was wrong i mean that was a that was a big reason why i mean look i i have said this before bubacar did not rank very high in my current so like for those who don't know i do a ranking system i have two grades i give you current grade it's basically kind of where you are now and where you project now on just normal growth and and who you are today and then i have an upside ranking which is if this guy reaches his full potential his his caliber of play is here and i've obviously had to adjust it over the years bubacar was not even in the top six or seven i don't think on the defensive class of the current ranking but he was my number one guy on upside grade and it was like look i don't this
kid may never do a meet play meaningful down at Notre Dame or he may become a first-round traffic that was the range with bubacar when he committed to Notre Dame the the really good coach just kind of could look at the tools and say do it he's really good but remember there was a lot of people thought he was going to grow into a detackle in college he actually lost weight when he went to came to Notre Dame he was a bigger kid he was like 260 260 pounds he streamlined build a lot of muscle got rid of some bad weight and that's why he looks like he does now but there's a lot of people that thought he could be a detackle coming out high school so i think that factored into it as well it's like can he put all that weight on and hold up and you know obviously Notre Dame decided to go a different route with him and it's really paid off yeah i would say so all right we got one from Aaron Valerio predict the Heisman finalist next year and how many will be quarterbacks i think four will be the number so let's go there Trev I think one will be a receiver
the rest will be quarterbacks that's where i'm going next year i think the receiver will be Jeremiah Smith i think the quarterbacks will be cj car dot tay Moore and archmanning if there's a fifth it'll be julienne saying but i'm not ready to go to him yet but i think Jeremiah Smith sure would be one that i would predict although i'm they're going to need some other receivers to step up because early in the season teams like texas are going to be like i dare you to throw to anyone else other than Jeremiah Smith like i i'm going to make branding in this for Chris Henry jr some of the transfer from was it you tep or whatever i'm going to make one of those guys beat me because when they when texas i mean remember texas did that to Ohio state two years ago and in Ohio states offense struggled and they had a mecha ebuka and cardinal tape on that roster and they only scored 21 offensive points one of them was on a screenplay in like with 30 seconds left where they threw a screen to trade on henderson that's the other thing they also had trade
on henderson and quencha junkens taking some of the junkens taking some of the pressure off a chair of my smith i mean honestly they're not they don't lack talent right let's let's not kid ourselves and act like Ohio state's got mediocre talent i'm not saying that but i would argue that they're current talent level cross the board starting lineup and two deep and rotation guys that'll like play it's not as good as it was two years ago i'm close no no no i think bow jacks is a good football player i don't think he's as good as what trade on henderson and quencha junkens were in 2024 i definitely don't think their backups are as good as those guys were germ i smith will be better a better version of himself but i'm sorry there's a big drop off between a mecha ebuka cardinal tape and what they are going to put out or see and i like branding in this but he's he's not a mecha but you know i'm close to mecha ebuka so i i think they're i don't think there's talented as they were i think julian sands probably got more physical tools than will howard but he's young you know and he got a lot of good valuable experience this past year but i don't think their skill talent is what it was two years ago i really don't i really don't
know i'm with you i'm with you completely cj car still the heisman favorite on fandall to win the award so here's the hope and that comes to fruition but i'm with you i think it's going to be a quarterback every year i mean if you go and look over on fandall the the next closest non-quarterback is seven spots down in its jaramisement all above jaramisement you got cj car archmaning trinidad chamblest julian saying josh huber dante more endearingments are all above jaramisement jaramisement tom red tom renger had him and he said him him there too i could see that i just i need to see it first but he could he could put up some similarish numbers to cam ward from two years ago for sure oh yeah well absolutely i it would not shock me if there was four heisman finalist this year and they were all quarterbacks agree uh trev who is there any other non-quarterbacks besides jaramisement on that fandallist i'm very curious about that the next closest one is malachytonia plus three thousand odds and malachytonia's below marcel re jade maiva brennan sores b sam levit
gunner stocked well way better coach will ball play than all those guys but it's that quarterback bias that goes with the heismatrophy yep yep i i don't see the two top running backs karen lacey and umand hardy i don't see them putting up the kind of numbers and being as dominant as jaramis love was but i think of the two i think umand hardy's gonna have the best chance to to have those kind of numbers yeah well i hadn't scrolled i'm pretty far kwan lacey is ahead of umand hardy by or actually excuse me they're both tied at ten thousand odds to win the heisman kwan lacey is currently behind dillin rayola to win the heisman who is a backup quarter oh my goodness so that's funny that's very funny do with that what you win oh my goodness superchat from tyler evans appreciate you man what is your
mount rush more of uniforms one each from the nhl the nba the nfl and the mlb and it could be from any era that's a good one uh nhl i'd probably would part of me once i would go with the rangers because you know me trev i'm a big red white and blue guy you know and i think that they're which one do they do at home in the nhl the colors at home or the white at home which one it's colors right at home isn't it like i have no i you guys in the chat let us know but i think the nhl is kind of like the nfl where the home team normally wears the colors and the road team the other one would be if you're going something iconic i think the red wings of you know back in the day for a long time had the real iconic had real iconic nhl uniforms i can at least evaluate that even though i that's about all that i know about hockey that would be my one for that that one trev the other one would be uh nfl i mean i'm i'm kind of biased i'd have to go with the old school
broncos the orange you know like what they were for most of always career i think when the broncos go with their throwbacks with the baby blue and the the the orange from back in the day those are just it's absolutely gorgeous um i'd have to go there i think that's that would be my favorite i think the most iconic is probably the cowboys would would probably be my pick for most iconic the patriots in the brady years had some really sweet uniforms they they really did mage league baseball again i'm i'm there's my favorite team the 1970s and 80s Cincinnati red uniforms were pretty sweet in my opinion uh with the sea on it but if we're talking about iconic mount rush more you got to go either Yankees or Dodgers i'd actually probably go i'd probably go Yankees the pinstripes the home pinstripes are pretty sweet but the Dodgers are also iconic i mean the Dodgers go back to the i mean they pretty much still have the same uniforms they had when they were in
Brooklyn i mean just Dodgers and i mean it hasn't really changed a whole lot it's been modernized but it hasn't changed a whole lot pick one of those two and then NBA there's no other answer other than the boss and Celtics home home whites there's no other answer than that it's my favorite team and they're the most iconic team with all due respect to the lakers that the lakers would be number two and i'd go old school lakers with the curse of you know from the 80s and yeah it's probably the right style of go can i speaking of uniforms can i say this i saw a tweet yesterday where the Tennessee Titans showed that they're new uniforms for next year those are flipping amazing i love it's basically it's the old oilers uniforms but Titans they put a video out yesterday trip you got to check them out those those would be mine those would be mine fight Mike says black hawks that that's the black hawks have a pretty sweet uniform too so do the penguins i will uh no uh Bruins i think the Bruins the Boston Bruins i think have a pretty good one he says Dodgers Celtics Packers Packers i never
really thought of that's that's it's a pretty iconic one as well that's a good one as well what say you trip yeah i'll be honest here all of my answers are just completely biased like i understand the most iconic and that you know you could show a non sports fan of those they would know what those are i'm not putting them on my mount rush more all of mine are just the aesthetics and like what they look like so NHL by default i'm gonna go with the black hawks because i literally could not tell you what any other forms like like and i can't really even tell you what the black hawks uniform look like i just i had a buddy grown up one of my best friends who was a black hawks fan and he would wear their jersey sometimes so i know what those look like the home reds are pretty sweet looking i i agree yeah agreed uh the NBA i'm biased i also live down here in Indianapolis but i think the Reggie Miller pinstripe whitepacers uniforms are pretty sick big fan of those i like pinstripes basketball jerseys this is the best coach that uh reggie what reggie Miller ever had i have no idea slay bird come on man i'll set you up for that one on run here comes a hanging curve
trap oh man it took him to the finals sorry buddy sorry man oh i was in diapers when that happened i don't want to hear that man i don't want to hear that come on you're from india now you got to learn that stuff but no larry bird was actually took them to the finals and then also took them to the eastern conference finals and loss of the bulls i think it's seven when he was coach also a great one coach of the year i think bit layer bird is one uh coach of the year and executive of the year i believe and then also obviously leave it league mbp during his career so actually let me check that out uh i believe that's the case let me see uh yeah NBA coach of the year in to the 1998 and then NBA executive of the year in 2012 nice on top being an NBA three three straight years as mvp pretty awesome but anyway please continue treff yeah i then i had a NBA with you the rest yeah in college i had a pinstripe white reggie Miller jersey the NFL i'm with you the most iconic is probably the Dallas Cowboys my favorite one that's came out
i am i guess recently a Cincinnati bangles fan and i'm also a sucker for all white so they're all white like white bangle tiger uniforms are nasty so the red skins home white the red skins are one of the cowboys both war white at home the red skins back in the 90s and 80s and 90s their home uniforms i think are in this conversations well from an aesthetic standpoint yeah they probably have my favorite helmets of all time those helmets were sweet their uniforms back in the day were sweet but yes i think the red skins aesthetically are in that conversation as well and then what's the last one the mlb yes for you majorly baseball yep that gosh like i mean most iconic i it's it's it's probably hard not to just go with Yankees or Dodgers the advantage that Dodgers have are the Yankees is they have red white and blue in their in their uniform i think that i mean you're midwestern guy cubs i think home uniforms back in the day that their pinch reps are pretty sweet yeah yeah i like the the cubs recently
came out with like a carolina blue like a powder blue jersey that is also sick there was a time when like everybody had some sort of powder blue uniform it seemed like the expose had it the cubs would wear it at times the the fillies had that you know powder blue in the maroon uh the royals had it i mean it looks it seemed like the cardinals home uniform or road uniforms were that kind of powder blue with their red there was a lot of teams have had that yeah i'd probably also throw the san francisco 49ers name in the hat for like iconic looking jerseys too like the red and the gold i would put their helmets in that conversation i would they probably have one of my so my fate my five favorite helmets of all time obviously the broncos old the old broncos right the powder blue with the baby blue whatever with the the d in the horse i think the redskins are having iconic helmet i think the cowboys have an iconic helmet and i think the 49ers have one of
my favorite helmets i was never a big fan of the packer helmet i just think that's kind of an ugly color bellow i think the g is school looking by i've never like been in love i'm maybe it's because we were the seahawks and we had the same helmets in high school but i think the seahawks have a pretty sweet helmet as well um but you know there there's been some other good good ones but yeah those those are b ones i think the bangles helmets back in the day were pretty sweet i don't know what they look like now but the with the stripes across oh it's the same like it's the same yeah that's a pretty sweet helmet yeah the bangles helmets are no sweet helmets yeah browns have the only helmet that's worse than pen states by the way the pen states helmets suck dude like they're there it's like they're trying psych if i went to dig sporting goods and just wanted to get my own speed flex to wear around the house like that's what their helmets look like like when they come from like when you're a team and you order them from the company and then you're gonna color paint them and put the logos
on like their helmets look like the store bought pre putting your stuff on them helmets and they just were like yeah we can't afford to put adding to them so we're just gonna put them out like this and they kind of worked it we're just gonna keep it that way people kind of like it so our cult member i mean our fans seem to like it so
so so so The Maps app that came with your phone, it's fine if you enjoy waiting and guessing and inefficient routes or you could use MapQuest. MapQuest is back with live directions, real-time traffic and faster routes, it moves when you move. Best of all, no prints are needed, no paper, no more misterds, just you and the app. Get there fast with MapQuest, download the MapQuest app on the app store or visit MapQuest.com. MapQuest, still getting you there.
Studies show that 100% of everybody in the world wants to curl up indoors and do nothing because it's so darn cold out there. That's why many people are turning to Bombas, whose pillowy plush slippers and warm arena will socks have been said to be the most comfortable in the history of feed. Bombas products have been found to boost co-siness by up to 1 million percent. Okay, enough fake statistics, but could Bombas socks and slippers really be the cure? Go to bombas.com slash audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase. It's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com and use code audio.
More episodes
More from Irish Breakdown

Marcus Freeman Talks Brauntae Johnson/Jason Onye Injuries, Sullivan Absher/Style...
Irish Breakdown

Chris Zorich Talks Notre Dame Win Over Wisconsin, Defensive Line, James Flanigan
Irish Breakdown

Rapid Fire: CJ Carr Passing, Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa Injury Update, More Notre Dam...
Irish Breakdown

Notre Dame Daily Mailbag - Part II
Irish Breakdown