
Miracles or Myths? Deciphering Fact from Fiction with the Miracle Hunter | Michael O'Neill
About this episode
In this episode, Conor Gallagher is joined by Michael O’Neill, known as The Miracle Hunter, for a captivating conversation about the mysterious world of miracles. Michael shares how he first became fascinated with miracles and why he believes they have a unique power to stir hearts and open the door to faith.
Together, they explore the Church’s rigorous process for investigating miracles, the difference between big “M” and small “m” miracles, and why God often leaves just enough mystery to invite us deeper into faith. They also discuss miracles in other religions, fraudulent claims, and the Vatican’s recent changes to how supernatural claims — especially Marian apparitions — are handled.
This episode is a fascinating look at how miracles aren’t just about the supernatural — they’re about God’s invitation to see His hand at work in every corner of our lives.
GET THE BOOK
Science and the Miraculous: How the Church Investigates the Supernatural
THE MIRACLE HUNTER WEBSITE
https://www.miraclehunter.com/
CHAPTERS
- (1:57) Introduction
- (4:04) How Did You Become ‘The Miracle Hunter’?
- (7:34) Why Miracles Can Crack Open the Door to Faith
- (8:15) Why God Leaves Doubt in Miracles
- (10:38) What Is a Miracle?
- (12:01) Big 'M' Miracles and Little 'm' Miracles
- (14:38) Process of Miracle Investigations
- (20:01) Why “Catholic” Miracles Are Ignored
- (21:04) Other Religions and Miracles
- (23:37) Fraudulent and False Miracles
- (34:40) Change in Vatican’s Standards for Miracles
- (44:15) Medjugorje
- (47:59) Our Lady of Guadalupe and The Tilma
- (1:13:17) The Shroud of Turin
- (1:26:23) The Shoulder Wound of Christ
- (1:31:53) The Stigmatists
- (1:40:39) Is the Stigmata the Marking of a Saint?
- (1:49:08) Marian Apparitions
- (1:52:20) Conyers & The Catholic “Maybe”
- (1:54:51) Vatican Guidelines for Apparitions
- (1:55:36) Garabandal
- (2:02:19) Zeitoun
- (2:05:28) Las Lajas
- (2:10:06) Healing Miracles
- (2:10:41) The Girl Whose Bladder Grew Back
- (2:26:05) Incorruptibles
- (2:31:24) Eucharistic Miracles
- (2:38:18) Saint Januarius
- (2:47:05) Weeping Statues
- (2:53:11) Closing Comments
Be sure to subscribe to The Conor Gallagher Show for more honest conversations about faith, culture, and the Catholic life.
#MiracleHunter #CatholicMiracles #ConorGallagherShow #MichaelONeill #CatholicPodcast #Miracles #FaithAndReason #CatholicChurch #MarianApparitions #Vatican #CatholicFaith
Get every episode summarized
Each time The Conor Gallagher Show publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.
Email me new episodesFree for 3 shows. No card needed.
Hosts & guests
No transcript yet
This episode has not been transcribed. Request it and it moves to the front of the queue.
More episodes
More from The Conor Gallagher Show

Masculinity CRISIS: Why the World NEEDS St. Joseph More Than Ever | Fr. Matthew...
The Conor Gallagher Show

Wild Sinner to Saint of the Ages: The Spiritual Warfare & Conversion of St. Augu...
The Conor Gallagher Show

SSPX Standoff, the Angelic Doctor, and Making a Good Confession | Fr. Gregory Pi...
The Conor Gallagher Show

Miracle or Fraud? The Remarkable Stories of the Stigmatists | John Clark
The Conor Gallagher Show