Fantasy Football Bargain, Bust & Wild Card for Colts

0:00On March 25th, if the 2026 fantasy football season kicked off today for the Indianapolis Colts, fantasy managers would spot a clear. Bargain, a potential bust, and one intriguing wild card among their players. Tied in Tyler Warren stands out as that undervalued Jim. Last year as a rookie, he averaged 13.1 fantasy points per game across 12 full outings with quarterback Daniel Jones at the helm. Without Jones, that dropped sharply to just 6.3 per game. Meanwhile, running back Jonathan Taylor could be in line for a tough year. His massive 369 touches and 20 touchdowns in 2025 inflated his value, but history shows such workloads often. Lead to regression. Experts point out Taylor's elite talent isn't the issue. It's the sheer volume that raises yellow flags for repeating those numbers. As training camps heat up, savvy owners might load up on Warren early while tempering expectations for Taylor, with their wild car player adding some, late round excitement to watch.