Colton Underwood | Secrets From Hosting Hulu’s “Are You My First?”

#871. Did you know Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn are cohosting a brand-new Hulu dating show, Are You My First? Now that the season is out, they can finally spill all the tea — and this is the convo Colton was most nervous for… because when they sit down together, things get way too comfortable ;)

We cover it all — their totally different journeys with love and sex, how Colton finally lost his virginity, and the guilt, confusion, and shame he carried while trying to convince himself he was straight. He opens up about faith, coming out, and what life looks like now — married, starting a family, and finally living as his best self.

But don’t worry, it’s not all serious! They spill behind-the-scenes tea from filming on a tropical island (think lightning strikes & jellyfish attacks), dish on cast secrets, and even debate who was really a virgin. Plus — reunion plans? A lie detector for season 2? 

Hit play for laughs, honesty, and stories you won’t hear anywhere else.

If you’re LOVING this podcast, please follow and leave a rating and review below! PLUS, FOLLOW OUR PODCAST INSTAGRAM HERE!

EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS: 

• (10:08) – Colton gets real about losing his virginity, the guilt, the shame, and the wild mental gymnastics he did trying to convince himself he was straight.
• (29:07) – Who from Are You My First? could survive Bachelor in Paradise.
• (32:50) – Tropics gone wild: lightning strikes, storms, and a jellyfish coming straight for Kaitlyn.
• (39:30) –Colton shares what it’s like now — married, building a family, and finally living as his authentic self.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.