Who is Peeing in the Podcast Pool?

Hey, it's Dave! In this episode (which uses chapters FYI), I take you through a year-end wrap-up, sharing stories, rants, insights, and predictions about the world of podcasting. Here are the main points I covered:

1. A Christmas Story with a Lesson for Podcasters

I kicked things off with a humorous Christmas tale about the Cridland Boys Choir, and what happens when you keep loosening your standards just to hit a target—a not-so-subtle lesson for the podcasting world.

2. Pushing Back on Changing Definitions in Podcasting

I strongly disagreed with Steve Goldstein and Jay Nachlis' take that YouTube should be considered podcasts. (also TikTok, and Newsletters).

I emphasized that a podcast, by definition, is audio, video, or PDF delivered via RSS—without that, it's not a podcast.

3. Why "Everything Is a Podcast" is Dangerous

I called out the industry for letting YouTube (and now TikTok) hijack the term "podcast," muddling data and damaging clarity around the medium.

4. The Hazards of Exclusive Distribution Deals

I discussed how exclusive distribution (like those seen with Netflix and Spotify) leads to loss of control and audiences for podcasters.

5. Warning Signs of Big Companies Manipulating Podcasting

Shared concerns about major corporations and what happens when their decisions are driven mainly by shareholder profits and not creators or audiences.

6. AI Content Flooding the Podcast Space

I highlighted the dangers of companies like Inception Point AI mass-producing low-value podcasts, cluttering directories, harming discoverability, and devaluing advertising rates.

7.Common Missteps Hurting Podcast Discovery

I warned about creating duplicate listings in Apple Podcasts and elsewhere, usually when moving hosts, and the importance of understanding how to migrate your show correctly.

8. Show Name Collisions

I noted the confusion caused by multiple shows using the same title (like "Thinking Outside the Box") and urged creators to do their research before naming their show.

9. Monetization Predictions for the Coming Year

I predicted a shift toward premium/patron-supported models as podcasters get frustrated with low ad rates.

10. The Fight Against "AI Slop"

I advocated for collectively pushing back against low-quality, AI-generated spam content in our medium.

11. Upcoming Industry Mergers

I think we'll see podcast-related companies merging or being acquired in the near future.

12. The Reality of YouTube for Podcasters

I expect many podcasters to try YouTube, realize it's not for them, and return to audio-first approaches—while some will succeed by mastering the video platform.

13. A Desire for More Creativity in Podcasting

I called for a resurgence of risk-taking and creative experimentation, rather than everyone following the same tired formats.

Podcasts/Shows Noted:

Pod News Weekly Review

No Agenda Show

Good Hang with Amy Poehler

Things We Learn in a Bar

Work for the Wind by Aliyah Langley

Steve's Blog That Drives Me Nuts

Captivate

Transistor

Buzzsprout

Supercast

For more details, behind-the-scenes commentary, and my thoughts on where the industry is headed, give this episode a listen. And as always, if you need help planning, launching, growing, or monetizing your podcast, check out schoolofpodcasting.com (coupon code: listener).

Mentioned in this episode:

Question of the Month: The Smallest Amount of Downloads

We all want a bigger audience. We all put a lot of work into our shows. With this in mind, what is the smallest amount of downloads you would do the show for? If it drops below a number would you stop, or put effort into finding out why? Does the size of your audience matter? Go to schoolofpodcasting.com/question by August 28th (and don't forget to say a little bit about your show and your website address so I can link to it in the notes)

School of Podcasting

Check Out Dave's Newsletter With Behind the Scenes Content

In each issue of Podcasting Observations, I share my thoughts on what is happening in the podcasting space, my latest content, and things that have caught my eye. I also may ask for your opinion. Join the free community

Podcasting Observations

Where Will I Be?

I love meeting you when I'm out at events. Here are some of my next events: Podcast Movement September 17-18 Podindy November 7th (use the coupon pacer at podindy.com)

Where Will I Be?

Get Your Podcast Up and Going in Six Weeks

Dreaming of starting your own podcast but not sure where to begin? Podcasting in Six Weeks gives you a clear, step-by-step path to go from idea to launch with confidence. This practical course is designed to help you create, record, edit, publish, and promote your podcast in just six weeks. Whether you're starting from scratch or feeling overwhelmed by the technical side, you'll get the guidance, structure, and tools you need to launch a podcast that sounds professional and reaches the right audience. Ready to stop overthinking and start podcasting? Join Podcasting in Six Weeks today and turn your voice, ideas, and expertise into a show people want to hear. The best part? It's only $1 Classes Start June 3rd

Podcasting in Six Weeks