Shadows Amidst Advancement (Updated)

In an era marked by unprecedented technological advancements, medical breakthroughs, global interconnectivity and reported consistent economic growth, one might expect a surge of optimism about the future. Yet, a curious phenomenon persists across the United States: a growing pessimism about the prospects for future generations. This disconnect between measurable progress and perceived decline is what I aim to unravel in a series of essays and in my interviews on “Exploring Prosperity With Host Bob Dewey” on YouTube and podcasts, examining its roots and implications for American society.

As we stand on the shoulders of dozens of decades of innovation and economic growth, why do so many Americans believe that the next generation will be worse off than the last? This essay delves into surveys that highlight this pervasive pessimism, examining the disconnect between objective measures of progress and subjective perceptions of the future.

Exploring Prosperity: Challenging Pessimism in the US is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Thank you to our sponsor Truflation. Learn more at https://truflation.com/

The Prevalence of Pessimism

To understand the extent of this pessimism, let's examine four surveys that paint a sobering picture of American attitudes toward the future:

* Gallop published in October 2022 (HERE) that ‘only 42% of U.S. adults think it is very (13%) or somewhat (29%) likely that today's youth "will have a better living standard, better homes, a better education and so on.’ This marks an 18-percentage-point drop since June 2019 and is statistically tied with the previous low in 2011’ and below the previous low in 1995.

* Pew Research Center Study: A 2019 Pew Research Center study (HERE) revealed a stark generational outlook. The survey found that 60% of Americans believed that today's children would be financially worse off than their parents. This pessimism about economic prospects for the next generation cuts across various demographic groups, indicating a widespread concern about future financial stability.

* NBC News/Poll (Article HERE): More data from an NBC News poll conducted in 2022 shows an even bleaker outlook. The survey found that a staggering 72% of Americans believed the country was headed in the wrong direction. This sentiment reflects not just economic concerns but a broader unease about the overall trajectory of the nation.

* Economic Innovation Group: Even back in 2016, this survey (HERE) found that only 38% of young Americans expected their standard of living to be better than their parents at their age.

* Gallup Annual Satisfaction Survey: Whereas surveys about future generational prospects like those cited above are conducted sporadically, Gallup's annual assessment of satisfaction across 31 aspects of US society provides a running measure of current sentiment and shows similar pessimism. Their February 2025 survey revealed just 38% average satisfaction, down from 48% in January 2020 (pre-pandemic) and from 41% at President Biden's inauguration in January 2021, suggesting this downward trend has continued even after the 2024 presidential transition.

Source: Gallop News article Feb 5, 2025 HERE

These surveys collectively paint a picture of a nation grappling with deep-seated concerns about its future. From long-term economic prospects to the overall direction of the country, Americans across different age groups and demographics express a shared pessimism about what lies ahead.

A Look Back: American Optimism in the 1950s

To fully appreciate the shift in American attitudes, it's illuminating to contrast current pessimism with the pervasive optimism of the 1950s. In the aftermath of World War II, the United States emerged as a global superpower, fostering a period of unprecedented optimism and confidence.

This era of optimism was captured in a 1957 Gallup poll, cited in Jim Cullen's book "The American Dream: A Short History of an Idea that Shaped a Nation," which found that 87% of Americans said they were "very happy" or "fairly happy" with their lives. The stark contrast between this post-war optimism and today's pessimism underscores the significant shift in American attitudes over the past seven decades. This optimism was rooted in tangible achievements:

* Economic Dominance: By 1950, the U.S. produced roughly 40% of the world's goods and services, despite having only 6% of the world's population.

* The Marshall Plan: Between 1948 and 1952, the U.S. spent over $13 billion (equivalent to about $150 billion today) to help rebuild Western Europe, showcasing America's global leadership and economic strength.

* Technological Advancements: The 1950s saw rapid technological progress, with innovations like color television and the polio vaccine fueling optimism about the future.

* Rising Standard of Living: The median American family income grew by 30% in real terms between 1950 and 1959, making the American Dream feel attainable for many.

* Cultural Influence: American music, movies, and products were increasingly popular worldwide, reinforcing a sense of cultural preeminence.

The stark contrast between this post-war optimism and today's pessimism underscores the significant shift in American attitudes over the past seven decades.

Understanding the Optimism-Pessimism Dichotomy

The stark contrast between the optimism of the 1950s and today's pessimism presents a fascinating paradox. One might argue that the very nature of progress has changed, becoming both more rapid and less tangible. In the 1950s, advancements were often visible and immediately impactful - new household appliances, automobiles, and suburban homes were concrete symbols of progress. Today's innovations, while arguably more transformative, are often less visible in daily life, happening in the realms of software, genetics, or nanoscale technologies.

Moreover, the 1950s optimism coexisted with new, unprecedented threats. The dawn of the nuclear age introduced the possibility of global annihilation, shifting from a world where the U.S. mainland felt invulnerable to one where destruction could come at any moment. Ironically, this existential threat may have galvanized American society, fostering a sense of common purpose and technological optimism as a response to looming dangers. In contrast, today's threats - from climate change to cybersecurity risks - are often more abstract and gradual, potentially contributing to a sense of helplessness rather than determination.

This dichotomy suggests that perception of progress and threat is not just about objective reality, but how that reality interacts with societal narratives and individual experiences. The immediate, visible gains and clear adversaries of the 1950s created a narrative of triumph and potential. Today's more complex, interconnected world, with its often-invisible progress and diffuse challenges, may be harder to fit into such an optimistic storyline.

Conclusion: Setting the Stage for a Deeper Dive

The contrast between current pessimism and historical optimism is stark and multifaceted. This shift in national mood isn't merely a fleeting change in sentiment, but a reflection of profound changes in how we perceive progress, threat, and the future itself.

But what exactly are the challenges that fuel this pervasive pessimism? How do they compare to the problems faced by previous generations? In my next essay in this series, I'll examine the specific issues that weigh on the American psyche today and explore whether our list of challenges has indeed grown longer or more intense compared to those in the past.

By comparing today's concerns with those of previous eras, I aim to gain a clearer perspective on whether our challenges are truly more daunting, or if our perception of them has changed. This historical context will be crucial in understanding the roots of our current pessimism and in evaluating whether this outlook is justified or if it perhaps overlooks important areas of progress.

As I move forward, my goal is not just to understand the sources of pessimism, but to critically examine whether this outlook accurately reflects our current reality and potential future. Through my writing and interviews, I'll continue to unravel the interplay between progress, challenges, and societal attitudes. Join me in this exploration as I catalogue and analyze the challenges that shape our collective outlook on the future, and seek out reasons for optimism that we might be overlooking in our focus on challenges.

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit robertdewey3.substack.com/subscribe