
About this episode
Today, the guys revisit one of the most interesting, and debated, drafts in recent history, the 2017 NHL Draft, and reflect on how it has panned out nine years later. The class featured some of the best players currently in the league including Cale Makar, Nico Hischier, Nick Suzuki, Miro Heiskanen, and Jason Robertson, as well as some picks that just didn’t pan out like Nolan Patrick and Lias Andersson. Plus, to close things out, the guys break down Scott’s latest NHL Draft rankings.
Hosts: Max Bultman, Corey Pronman, and Scott Wheeler
With: FloHockey’s Chris Peters
Executive Producer: Chris Flannery
Producer: Chris Flannery
Watch full episodes on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@theathletichockeyshow
Join our Discord Server: https://discord.gg/VTm9VjkF
Subscribe to The Athletic: https://theathletic.com/hockeyshow
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Interactive timestamps
Jump to segmentGet every episode summarized
Each time The Athletic Hockey Show publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.
Email me new episodesFree for 3 shows. No card needed.
Hosts & guests
Transcript ready
613 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.
Full transcript
The Athletic Hockey Show — Revisiting the 2017 NHL Draft. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.
0:00Hi, this is Farnoosh Trabi from So Money with Farnoosh Trabi and today I want to talk to you about Boost Mobile. Quick money tip, stop paying a carrier tax. If your phone bill feels trapped in a pricey plan, this is your sign to Unlock Savings. Boost Mobile helps you reset your spending with the $25 unlimited forever plan. You can bring your own phone, pay $25 and get unlimited wireless forever and that simple switch can unlock up to $600 in savings a year. That's money you could put towards paying down debt, investing or something that actually brings you joy. Though savings are based on average annual single line payment of AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile customers compared to 12 months on the Boost Mobile Unlimited plan as of January 2026. For full offer details, visit boostmobile.com. My dad taught me a lot, including how easy it is to forget to cancel things, so I downloaded experience, my BFF, big financial friend. Experience could help me cancel my unused subscriptions and lower my bills, saving me hundreds a year. Get started with the
1:04experience app today, your big financial friends here to help you save smarter. Results will vary, not all bills are subscription eligible, savings not guaranteed, $631 a year, average savings with one-plus negotiations and one-plus cancellations paid membership with connected payment account required to experience that comfort details. Hi, this is Matt from P1 with Matt and Tommy and this episode is sponsored by eBay. The cars you'll find on eBay are just different. They come with a story that you can't wait to share. Like this 1973 Dodge Charger on eBay that has been tucked away in an Arizona barn for over 40 years, only 55,000 miles and somehow in great running order, even has a rare sunroof. Suddenly a car that was hidden for decades is being delivered in just a few clicks with eBay's secure purchase. All the paperwork handled. There are thousands of cars on eBay from unique finds like the Pontiac Grand Prix SJ to daily drivers and now with a new way to buy them. eBay, things, people, love.
2:16This is the Athletic Hockey Show Prospect Series. Hey, everybody, Max Bolben here alongside the Athletics, Corey Promet and Scott Wheeler and Flowhockey's Chris Peters for another episode of the Athletic Hockey Show Prospect Series. We got a fun show on tap today. Scott's got a new 2026 draft list out. We're going to talk about that a little bit later on. But first, we're going to turn back the clock a little bit. It's been nine years since the 2017 NHL draft. It was one of the more interesting NHL drafts in recent memory Corey because there wasn't a slam dunk number one overall pick. That makes it a really fun one to revisit for a couple of reasons. One, to see how that's all played out. But two is just a little bit of a case study and how these things are always snapshots in time. You guys always talk about that. This one in particular, the way it's evolved. I think the way that we look at the 2017 class, particularly at the top of it, is different now than it was two years ago, let alone four
3:18years ago, let alone nine years ago. And so I think that makes it a very interesting sample. At the time, the whole discussion was Nico versus Nolan. That one's not really the conversation anymore. No, and it's been interesting. I think you've seen over the last decade, a lot of leaks from teams to reporters about how they perceived the draft and how they loved Miro Haskin and they loved Kale McCarr and a couple of years ago, how much they loved Julius Patterson. You never hear from the teams that had Nico, he shared one of which of which there were plenty or the ones who had Nolan Patrick and one of which I at least I know there was like, there was a couple. But yeah, that draft has evolved in a couple of ways. But back then, it was definitely Nico versus Nolan. That was a legitimate debate. I think there were definitely people. Nestle and Patterson, I know, I mean, I know there were scouts and teams that had haste getting up there and had McCarr up there. But those were minority opinions. It was definitely
4:22between those two centers. They were prolific CHL centers with with with a rich history of success. He sure was tremendous that year's world juniors. He was tremendous in the queue that year. Nolan Patrick had had three great years in the Western league, although he was injured at times. And there were some questions on his game too still. I mean, it was a legitimate debate. But obviously, that's not how things have played out since then. It's interesting too, because I completely understand why that was the debate at the time, right? Everyone's looking for the franchise center. You had two guys who kind of looked like what we envisioned that as this has turned out to be an unbelievable center class in hindsight. When you look at the names in it, he sure has panned out to be a very good center. Maybe more of like a high end number two low end number one, Alias Patterson. He's been a hundred point player. You could say what you want about where he's been the last couple of years. He's still at all day at top six forward. He's been a one hundred point center in the NHL Robert Thomas number one center in the NHL and Nick Suzuki Scott might be the best of the bunch at this point.
5:26Yeah, the defense been kind of defined that class in hindsight. But if you were to rank the four words from that class, I think Nick Suzuki on March 18th, 2026, as we record this, has as compelling a case as any of those guys, Martin H.S., who you didn't mention in that group. More of a winger, more of a winger, but has had a heck of a couple of years. And I think N H.S. probably has a case to be right there with Suzuki with the way that he's played in Colorado. But it's still probably Suzuki with the two way impact with the position with what he means to the Montreal Canadiens who are now a playoff team again. He's probably the like you're taking him over he sure, I think. And and probably over N H.S. too, those those feel like the the three big boys have forward in that group. Although Patterson still leading the draft of scoring right now. Yep. He has not this season, but in the overall like total points, I think it's 497 is what
6:27Patterson's at at the time of this recording. And right behind him is McCartle. We will get to the defenseman here, but just sticking on the center on the center and the forwards here, Corey. It was an interesting class because some of these names that we talked about, Suzuki, Thomas, those guys were not picked in the top 10. And even N H.S. was a little bit later. And over time, Robert Thomas. Yeah, exactly. Thomas Suzuki. We were talking more about names like Gabe Vellardi at the top about Michael Rasmussen at the top. And that's shifted. There's a complicated assessment to be done, Corey, about what to take away from this. And that'll kind of lead in when we get to the 2026 draft segments, some of these takeaways. But when you kind of reflect back on that, do you have a, I know every year you do the what I got wrong list. Is there an overriding lesson here? Well, Vellardi is his own unique case because he's actually become quite a good NHL player, not a great NHL player, but he's become a very, you know, useful piece in the National Hockey League. It took a very long time though. I mean, his injury situation was so complicated
7:29back then. And, you know, he was the name that kept coming up when people were talking about Katie Lindstrom in that 2024 draft and then Roger McQueen in 2025 draft. That the way you have these complicated back and hip injuries, that those are things that can really drag out for years. I know when back then, the assessment of Vellardi, when he went to live in the overall of the Kings was that this is a problematic injury. But I remember at the time, because I've been doing this for a long time, getting a little bit older. I've never talked into scouts back then. The assessment was from a lot of other doctors was this is going to be one, maybe two rough years here, but we can get him back. He's going to be fine. He's going to be playing hockey regularly in two years. That was not the case. It was a lot of ups and downs and stops and starts and is his career over, you know, hypothesizing and obviously he comes back in and is good, but
8:29not for the team that drafted him. There's still something that he's dealing with too. My understanding is Vellardi in terms of stretching and preparing his back and it's a career long thing that he's just managing now. If you look, at least in the top 15, the names that probably didn't pen out of CalFoot, although obviously complicated other issues with CalFoot. Leeus Anderson at 7, Cody Glass at 6, and to a degree, Middlestad at 8, although he's still playing. He's a good player. A lot of guys there are heavy feet. A lot of guys there who really struggled with the pace of the NHL, but you can't use that as a definitive rule because I don't think Suzuki is the fastest player in the world, but he's got tremendous stick and brain and competitiveness. But that'd be probably one of the most common traits there. Max, you've probably covered Rasmussen's career a lot, and I know there was a lot of debate at nine of, yeah, he's big,
9:33he skates okay, but he was a point of game player in the Western league. Was this the biggest upside swing? Yada, yada, and it's fair because obviously net just goes ahead of him. Suzuki even, you could have a conversation him versus Tippit, I think you still might, you could take Rasmussen over Tippit though, but I mean, there's a lot of guys in those 10, 12 picks that went right after Rasmussen that outside of those couple that became prolific players that he probably ends up being better than though, right? Yeah, it's always interesting one for me to discuss with fans because it's a pick that I think to this day frustrates Red Wing's fans. They see the success of Suzuki of Thomas of natures. I think there was a lot of love for natures and a lot of love for Gabe Velardi who played in Windsor, and so was very close to Detroit and a lot of interest in him. So he's always kind of had kind of carried the burden of having been the ninth pick who went ahead of those guys. But I'm interested in it because you look at him and we sort these by points, right? And I wouldn't say scoring has been a defining feature of Michael Rasmussen's game in his NHL career. He's still top 20 in this class and scoring, and that's while being,
10:36you know, a defensive center, a penalty killer. I don't know where he goes in a redraft here, but it's probably somewhere around there 20 to 25. There's some goalie, some defenseman who you take out of him that are lower on the scoring list. But, you know, it's funny. Like I was looking at he's same, same number of points is a to lose to Ryan and I think the way we talk about a to lose to Ryan and is is much more glowing. And there's a reason for that lose to Ryan and it's been on winning team. I think he skates better than Rasmussen. I'd take him over him. But it is interesting every time I go back to this class to look at like, you know, Red Wing's fans frustration on one hand and the reality of it that this is kind of what that, you know, he probably should have gone 10 to 15 picks later, but it's not like he was a, you know, at least Anderson that situation here. The rest of Ryan is one of the more interesting players from that draft because he was a draft plus one that year that this was the second draft eligible year. If you look back at his stats, it wasn't glowing numbers he put up in Liga, even in that second draft season. But he kind of like took off right towards the end of the year. He was the definition of a late riser. I remember
11:40like talking to head scouts who like in the month of March and April. So, you know, peak CHL playoff season, you waitings. There's a lot going on and they were popping over to Europe to go watch this kid. So he was a really fascinating case of just pure athleticism and that a guy who's often kind of developed late. Totally. And you talked about the heavy feet. I think that's kind of a theme too when I look at some of the wingers here and some of them started out as centers. And the reason that they are not wingers is because of the feet. That's geeky and velardy. But Jason Robertson, not the fastest guy, but he's going to end up as one of the highest scoring players in this class. It has a chance by the end of it all to be the highest scoring player in this class. He's only about 20 points. Jake Baviston, another great example there, right? So, I don't know if there's a takeaway here, but it is interesting to contrast that versus some of the more like shifty wingers that were in this class. Your Kyler Yamamoto's, your Ely Tolvenins and see kind of who rose to the top of this Chris. Yeah, I mean, Robert's in was one of those guys. And I think there's other, it wasn't just the
12:42feet that put them outside of the first round here. But in the end, I think that was a defining factor. But I think Robert's in in particular is one of the great lessons in the equalizing factor of hockey sense and the ability to understand how to create offense and how to use time and space to your advantage and other things like that. But yeah, I mean, I think for a lot of these guys, you know, some of them also, it wasn't necessarily the straightest, their quickest path to the NHL in order for them to, you know, to be a factor needed, you know, all of their junior eligibility, maybe sometime in the NHL, different things like that. And then you have guys like Geeky, who have just, it's been a much later kind of explosion towards the end. And so they're, you know, with players that have the skill level, you know, as one of their defining traits, in addition to being a little bit on the bigger side, I think there are a lot of things that you can look at to, you know, put a put together a picture of what an NHL player looks like. And I think the 2017 class
13:44in particular is a great lesson in the, you know, the varying ways that you can reach and reach the league and have an impact in the league. It's a really compelling class in that way. Lots of guys that were first round picks that are, you know, kind of bottom of the lineup guys or, or, or tweeners. And then you have some of these mid-round guys like Batherson and, and, and Robertson. But again, I think sometimes in cases like Batherson and Robertson in particular, sometimes you just have to allow yourself to believe that what they're doing at the level they're at is impressive. You know, like, it's like, oh, yeah, he's got all these points, but will that translate in certain, you know, in not all cases it is. But when you look at the size profile, the, you know, the mitigating factors, whether it be their hockey sense or their, you know, their physicality or something of that nature, you know, the, the players with some size and some skill have a great, a pretty long runway and it might not be right away. But, you know, those are guys
14:48that I think are great examples of the paid power of patients and also, you know, hockey sense can get, take you a long way. Robertson and Batherson are, I think, are a little different for me too. Like Robertson was a prolific junior score. Yes. Like the entire time he was in the OHL. He was, what do you have like 80, 90 points in his draft year? He had a strong underage profile too. Like there was always, there was no doubt on his skills, his brain. It's just, is the brain instinct lead to enough given his problematic skating stride? He kind of, like, is gangly on an athletic skating stride to make it. Obviously, the answer was yes. And with an emphatic, yes, actually, given how good he's been in the NHL. Batherson on the other hand was like Lewis Renn in a late bloomer. Scott might know this detail better than me, but I believe he had a significant growth spurt right around the time, but that's his draft plus one year. Like, this was not, I think he was like 510 or 511 when he came into the, what he came into the queue. And obviously, now he's like close to 6-3. So that one was just like identifying some traits, some intriguing skill, developing body
15:52by Ottawa in the mid rounds. And then, obviously, Batherson became that year after his draft. He was one of the more dominant queue players I could remember. He, yeah, he, I think he was like 511, 6 feet and is listed in his draft here by NHL Central Scouting. I'd have to go back and, and check. And he was still very productive in his draft here in the queue. But that, that step he took post draft was, was something else. Like, that was, okay, we've got a different, different cat here now. You're never going to like solve how to draft based on just looking back at one class, but it's interesting because we're talking about some of this profile. And you might think, okay, so always draft, like the skilled, highly productive score, like, even if they're a little slow-footed. But then you have Liam Greentree, Colby Barlow, Arthur Calliev. Like, there's other counter examples to kind of this similar profile of the prolific scores here. And I wonder, like, is there a trait that jumps out that's like, yeah, but those, those guys had elite scents or more compete or something like that, Corey? Well, well, Tauvannin is one from that year, who everyone loved. Like, he was a world junior
16:56player at 17. He had a tremendous international track record. Didn't have a great year in the USH L that year, but he had been very good as an underage. Like, that was the skill guy that everybody loved. And then even in his draft plus one year, he goes with the KHL. He rips it up. And it's obviously he's in the NHL now. He is an NHL player, but his size skating profile was very problematic. And he was never really good. I think when you have that issue, you want to have the high compete because that's what Suzuki is like. He's not the biggest of the fastest, but he's a warrior. Like, I was watching just a game of his the other night and the way he could win battles for a guy his size is just so impressive. Like, that was probably Tauvannin's issue. It's always a balancing act, right? Like, you go back to that draft and a small guy with prolific feet would have been branched from, like, holy, health and air branched from skate. But he still couldn't defend at the pro at the pro level. Like, he wasn't hard enough. He wasn't competitive enough. So like, when you're that size
17:59or you're big and you're slow, you got to have some other trait that really hang your head on. Yeah. You didn't even mention all of our Wallstrum key for bellows there. Max off the top. Like, absolutely. It's a very long. Not this draft, but no, he's saying like, police and guys who were prolific scorers and maybe you would, you would go, okay, you got to trust the trust. What's there? Like, those guys busted too. The toolsy is guy in this draft who I believe why he didn't make it. But god damn, I thought he was going to make it was Vesalainen. I'm not sure if you guys remember watching Vesalainen when he was a teenager. Like, that guy was so talented. Like, six, four, he could fly, he had good skill, he could rip a puck. Like, he was just like, just lazy, like, average hockey sense. But like, so like, it makes you kind of think of rubric a little bit like from guys this year, like a Lyndon Lackavik, like that profile a little bit. But like, he was so, so talented,
18:59so much fun to watch at the junior level. He played pro all year between Sweden and Finland and his draft year. But he, at the junior level, he looked like a, like, like, not a, can't miss guy, but a guy who had a really good chance to make it. Yeah. And he could, yeah, he couldn't even do it at the, at the AHL level when he got over here. Oh, and tip it too. Like, I know a few people around Owen and watched him a lot in, in Mississauga back then. Like, just the athleticism, the ability to shoot it, the skating, and yet for a long time, Owen had no clue how to play hockey. And it, it just took him, took him a long, long, long time to figure it out between the ears and tip it. So now signed what's almost $8 million player with the flyers. But he's figured it out. You know, he was a top 10 pick. It took a while to come around. I still know if it's top 10, what you're looking for. But he's 40 to 50 point guy. Like, that's a, that's a useful top half of the first round. He was, he was in the, they, they gave him a, the, the early tryout too in the NHL right after his draft. Like with, like, and then, and then he didn't get that for a couple of years. It's like, oh, what happened
20:02there? You know, so, yeah, it was interesting. Yeah. Clim Kostin's another one who really toolsy. He struggled in his draft year, you know, played 11 to 10 minutes in the KHL. But 64, heavy, skilled Russian winger. It's tough with guys like that. Because like, there was, there was a lot of like, talk at the time about, like, you see, fits too over the physically developed, the usual tropes about Russians, about how old is he really, etc, etc. But in which also you could never verify any troops to it. But I remember watching him when he was a junior player, especially as an underage player. And like, he thought, like, this guy has all the tools. And I remember even like, St. Louis was like, at the draft table, they were bragging about him. Like, they couldn't believe they got him at 31. Yada, yada. Not the only thing time you've seen teams do that. But that was one that I couldn't believe he couldn't add a little bit more often. Same thing with, there's a lot in ribbon with the American league. It was a struggle right away. Like, he couldn't score in North America. At the level that I thought he was going to
21:05miss the score, that is. Which was at least like an unreasonable middle six winger. I'll never forget Kostin on the, at the draft that year, they had the top six or seven guys from NHL Central, for both of NHL Central Scouting's list in a room sort of backstage at the draft. And Kostin was one of those 12 or 13 players that they sat there. And then they got to walk on stage as their names were picked. And then suddenly everybody in the room is gone because they've already been selected. And Kostin's just sitting there until pick 31. And in hindsight, probably sitting for a good reason. Which at the time was the last pick of the first round. Yep. Hi, this is Farnoosh Tarabi from So Money with Farnoosh Tarabi. And today I want to talk to you about Boost Mobile. Quick money tip, stop paying a carrier tax. If your phone bill feels trapped in a pricey plan, this is your sign to unlock savings. Boost Mobile helps you reset your spending with
22:07the $25 unlimited forever plan. You can bring your own phone, pay $25 and get unlimited wireless forever. And that simple switch can unlock up to $600 in savings a year. That's money you could put towards paying down debt investing or something that actually brings you joy. Though savings are based on average annual single line payment of AT&T Verizon and T-Mobile customers compared to 12 months on the Boost Mobile Unlimited plan as of January 2026 for full offer details visit boostmobile.com. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free range, self-directed investing or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place.
23:09Visit Schwab.com to learn more. When you manage procurement for multiple facilities, every order matters. But when it's for a hospital system, they matter even more. Granger gets it and knows there's no time for managing multiple suppliers and no room for shipping delays. That's why Granger offers millions of products and fast, dependable delivery. So you can keep your facilities stocked, safe, and running smoothly. Call 1-800-GRanger.com or just stop by. Granger. For the ones who get it done. Corey, a little bit ago, you mentioned Eric Brandstrom and that's a good... that's where I want to start. Kind of as we pivot to the D here because from 14 to 18 in this class, there was a run of five straight defensemen. And I think I'm clear to say that none of them hit. Cal foot at 14, Eric Brandstrom 15, Yusso Valamaki 16, Timothy Lilligrin at 17, and Erhovak 9 and at 18. To go 0 for 5 like that in a run of defensemen, normally would mean
24:13this D-class bombed. But it is saved by Cal McCarr and Miro Hayeskin and going four and three respectively. And I think there's a very real case they would go one and two in a redraft of this Corey. Yes, and I think there's a lot of people, especially with McCarr, there's always kind of been the debate since then is why Jay and he go one because he's so good and he's become such a dominant force in the NHL. Obviously Hayeskin and has two, but McCarr is Stanley Cup winner, elite offense, kind of the anchor there for Team Canada there at the Olympics. You know, he's just a very special player. And you go back to that draft, like we've mentioned at the top, that you had these two really good centers, you know, very toolsy, great CHL careers. Do you realize the balls it would have taken to take a late birth date, 5-11 defenseman in the AJHL ahead of those guys? And I know teams were thinking that I know New Jersey was thinking about it.
25:14They didn't end up doing it, but they did a lot of research on McCarr that you get with the first overall pick. That was a serious debate in that room. But to pass on a guy who you felt really confident was going to be a top six center in the NHL, a really good top six center. You know, like McCarr, there was questions and how it was going to translate. There was questions how it was going to translate even in the year after his draft. He wasn't even the top scoring defenseman at UMass from his draft in that draft plus one year. It was Mario Ferraro outscored him that first year. That obviously the second year he goes, goes off, ridiculous college year goes the NHL, you know, the rest is history. But there was some significant risks in that projection. Despite the great feat, the great skill, the great hockey sense, you know, the AJHL is very far removed from the CHL, never mind from NHL. So those were the risks there. I think he was kind of viewed more as like a defense version of he sheer just really well
26:16rounded, probably a better skater. But I think the chance to get a guy you thought had a chance to be a first line center one the day there. But I think that was more of a conversation of these terms of risks. I don't know. You guys think I'm just remembering anything there because I feel like I think everyone's everybody, I think Central had McCarr what like seventh in North America or something like that. Yeah, it was all over the map with Kale. Yeah, I mean, it's easy to say now and easy to say, oh, yeah, I loved him. I remember watching with the World Junior Rage Challenge, he was incredible. And he was like, he was dominant at that junior event and dominant in the in Brooks. Um, I mean, can you imagine like in this draft, I'm talking about McKenna and Stenberg. And if I told you though, there's this guy in the BCHL who I adore, he's so talented. Let's take him over McKenna. Like you guys would like laugh at me. Like, you know, it would. Yeah. And even then like, then it was like the AJHL was still like, you know, they have, they would have players, they would have, they would have guys that you would draft, but very rarely
27:19where they in the first round. And I, you know, I think we kind of saw some of that this year where like time and Lawrence was like, I probably need to go to be you if I'm going to have any chance of being the number one pick because people are, you know, whatever they may not take a USAJL player first overall. And you know, that's the thing is like, if McCarr was in a different league, maybe we are having a different discussion, but that was a big part of it. And, and Cory, I remember even like talking to you before, because this was actually the year that I did not cover the 2017 draft that was out of hockey at this point for my one year out of it. And I remember the conversation we had, I was like, I, because you mocked him there at the end, didn't you? At number one. Yeah. Or that's not, that's not where I had him rated. But I, I, I, I, you know, New Jersey was doing homework there. And I was wrong ultimately on that front. But I thought he was going, I thought he was going to go first overall. Yes. Yeah. I mean, and that was still like, yeah. So like, and that was a legitimate thing. And that was certainly something that I was hearing too is like, all of a sudden, like, you know, there, there's,
28:21there's a lot of teams and the debate came back to league strength differently. Like, how do you project that out? And, you know, ultimately, you know, if they would have done it, they would, you know, would have a generational defenseman. But, you know, it's, it's really like, you're thinking back to that. And to Cory's point, the jump from the AJ to NCAA for KL McCarr was not managed very well in the first year. He was, I, I was going back and looking at some of my other things. And, and it really wasn't until his sophomore season where it looked like, oh my God, this is a different human here. You know, and, and, and, and think about how little he was utilized at the world juniors that year, too, where he touched the set. He was a power play guy, like a specialist. The set was, he was a second power play guy. He had to sit behind Kale Kleg, who was running for a car. And, and, and he ended up still, I think what, he had a point per game in the tournament as well. And so like, good. Yeah. It's just like, you know, there, there are some people that are just different. And it's really like, I, I feel like it's hard to allow yourself
29:21to believe it in certain settings. And I feel like that's really what ended up happening with KL McCarr was that the fact that he went forth from the AJ is still a really impressive thing. And then, you know, yeah, that one will, that, that is always going to be one of the most fascinating things. And in the current landscape, it'll never happen again. So we don't have to worry about that, I guess. With Hayeskin. And it's interesting because I feel like he's having one of the best seasons of his career this year. And yet I've never heard less about Miro Hayeskin. And then I am right now. I think that problem with that is that on top of what Kale and Quinn have become in the league, you've also now got Werenzki and Lane Hudson and these other guys who've just really, really elevated. And it almost feels like what Miro is has become, he's been way better, there was even talk last year of maybe he's being replaced as the number one defenseman on his team. Like he has been way better than Thomas Harley this year. So I think part of it is just time. And there's new shiny toys like with what Lane's doing with what Zach,
30:26with what Werenzki's done the last couple of years, with what Siders doing this year. There have just been other players that have risen to that, that sort of level. And lo and behold, the Dallas stars are one of the best teams in the league and Miro Hayeskin and still one of the best defensemen in the league. You know, a couple months ago, I pitched to Dom and Shayna. I was like, this is the year of the two, the true two-way defenseman between Siders, Sanderson and Hayeskin. And I was like, all three of those guys are going to end up I think in the top five. And just as the years gone on, Quinn got out of Vancouver and recaptured the magic in Minnesota. Werenzki is somehow at or outshining the level that he did last year, which was outstanding. And then Lane Watson is right there as well to your point that Evan Tushard has like 200 points. That's right. Exactly. So somehow these two-way D get lost every year. And it drives me a little bit crazy because I do think that that that player type is so coveted in the NHL and it just gets lost over and over again. Well, some of those two-way guys are better than some of those other guys. That's just a reality. I agree. I'm just saying that they get lost in the conversation.
31:29You mean that the voters just sort by points? You will not get me to say that on the record. That's okay. All right. Any other thoughts on this class before we get to 2026? I mean, the Goldie class here, Jake Ottinger is kind of the shining star in that regard. Ukepeca-Lukin and Shoutout last night or Tuesday night in Vegas. Anyone else here that stands out that you want to talk about? I mean, there's so many things you can go all the way. I didn't even mention like a little looker in like that. There was such a hype training for that guy going into his draft. And ultimately he runs into issues, average hockey sense, I think, like really doomed him there towards the end, but like that was one. You know, we didn't even mention the guy at the top. He had to play it all. He had to play it all year too. And like Leah's Anderson. Yeah. Like, yeah, that's God. That's just, you know, probably, you know, probably the most disastrous pick from that draft was Anderson. And like, they thought he was going to be a captain. Yeah, I know. And I remember, go back to that time. He was a world junior player that year,
32:34probably played better than Patterson did at the world junior. That year Patterson didn't play well at all at that tournament. And I think he even got invited that he played world championships. I think he got invited to like pre-termine games with the world championship team. I think and like he got like, but there was always like, yeah, he's 5-11. Yeah, he's not that fast. Like, yeah, he's not super skill, but everyone who loves it, like he's a warrior. He's Mike Richards. Like, this is, this is what this guy is going to be. And then, but like, yeah, like, well, you're picking top 10. Like, this competitive as a guy is like, it's, you've got to like have at least some sort of, like, high end traits to hang, you know, to, to, to be hopeful about. Like, he's got to be able to skate. He's got to be able to score. He's got to at least have some sort of athletic projection there. Like, that's, I always struggled with that one. Like, I got a lot wrong that year. That was one I just never fully understood the hype for. Yeah. Now in, now in Switzerland, now playing professionally in Switzerland after two of his
33:39most successful AHL seasons after not painting out as an NHL player. So just it, yeah, that, that one is, and, you know, he was such a central part of Sweden's, you know, they, they went on that run the following year in 2018, where he was the captain, you know, all those, all those different things. And man, it just, it never, I mean, like, he was in the other thing too. So he, he started the season, didn't he start the season with for London and then he moved to the AHL and then the, the Rangers like, oh, we got to get him in. Like, he played, he played games that following year. Um, you know, in the NHL. So it's just, it's, it's very strange. He had two of his 17 points that year, by the way, 17 points at 110 NHL games for the seventh world pick. This was the Vegas expansion draft. And it is amazing to me how badly this should have gone by, by what happened with their, with their three picks, uh, in the top 15, they, they take Cody Glass at six Suzuki at 13, but then trade him for Max patch already. And then they trade Eric
34:43Brandstrom to recover from having that been your first draft. You, you have this amazing opportunity with three top 15 picks to start your franchise on. You nail one of them, but trade the one you nail, uh, and, and to somehow recover from that, you know, like Willy Wonka Ask Fashion is magic. Well, I, I do remember when they traded Brandstrom. That was the Mark Stone trade. Yep. Good, good, good player to get back kind of been important for them the last, you know, last little while. I remember, like, Pierre Dorian, then the Senator Chino Manager, like, talking about just the glowing review of Eric Brandstrom. He's like, well, we traded Mark Stone, but we, the reason we did, we got, because we got, can't believe I just got Eric Brandstrom. That was, it was, it was, like, he was effusive in his praise of that player and obviously just complete disaster after that. Um, he was finished and was the start of the, the 5-11 puck moving demon in the first round that doesn't work out trend that followed for eight or nine years, basically. Oh, Chris, the next year. Unlike, unlike some of those guys,
35:44like Vaseline and Lola Grin and Kostin, Ranshan came over. He was really good right away. Like, that first year in Chicago, he was excellent in the American League. I think he was, we came over at 19, I think, but he, like, he was really, really good. You're like, oh, it's going to work. It's going to translate. And then he gets the NHL and there's, you know, not really a novel tape, the NHL is a little bit better than the American League. And he just, just couldn't defend in the offense was just never really truly lead enough to compensate. Yeah. And you know what? I do think going looking back at the Vegas thing real quick. Like, how good of a lesson was that for them to just be like draft picks or commodities. They are not true in the future. Like, like, it's like, hey, if we, and the thing is is that, you know, teams constantly overvalue their prospects. They constantly do it. And we'll hold onto them for too long. And, you know, basically, you know, Vegas will have no qualms about it because it
36:44did eventually lead to a Stanley Cup, you know, and with, especially with Mark Stone being a central figure and all those different things like that's that works, you know, but yeah, that could have been, that could have been a complete disaster. You also wonder, what is, what do they look like with Nick Suzuki at the center of everything? But then you probably don't have Jack Ikel at that point, you know, all these different things. There's, there's lots of what ifs that you could play in there. But in the end, you know, this is a team that has basically made their every single year. You could pretty much guarantee if like, you know, hey, Trevor Connelly, I think has lasted longer than any first round draft pick that they've had. So kudos to him. Ironically enough, they also ended up with Nick Hague from this draft class who they didn't pick. There you go. Yeah. At some point, you feel like the, you know, it's going to come due for them, right? Like, like, yeah, this is a pretty old team and like, I was about Pittsburgh last year, but obviously Cindy Crosby and Eric Carlson seem to have, you know,
37:46truly special players seem to extend the window there a little bit, but I think with Vegas when when it comes due for them, it's going to hurt. The thing is though, like Vegas is going to, their ability to recruit as both at no tax state, the destination and a place with this reputation. Eventually, yes, they're going to need some young players. I do still think as many players as become available on the trade deadline, Vegas is going to be in the top two or three on their list. So yes, you probably won't have the assets to chase after them in trades forever. But to the extent that there even is free agency going forward, they're always going to be a player in that too. Can we do a quick like, I want to see how you guys would draft the top 10? If we can, are we unanimous Cory? Do you want to, do you want to just go in a square here? You want to pick number one and we'll just see how this would shake out in the top 10? All right, first overall pick. I will, I will fall in that grenade and take kill McCart. Scott. I think it's Miro 2. Chris. Why is this shouldn't be? I don't like it. You'll need to go third. I can go third. No, yeah, okay.
38:50Yeah, you go third. I think it's, I think Nick Suzuki has a very real case to go three. Yeah, yeah, I think right. I think you're right. Nick Suzuki. Because I didn't want to take him three. I'll take him four. Jason Robertson. Okay, Cory. This is where things get tough here. Because I think he sure now in the conversation, pettersons in the conversation, Thomas is in the conversation here. Netches is the better talent, but I'll take he sure, I think. Okay, Scott. I'll go, I'll go netches over Rob Thomas. And I would say Thomas at seven then. Yeah, by process of elimination. Chris has the only two hard picks here, I think. Did petterson get picked yet? He just did at number eight. He just did petterson. Okay. All right, so nine, Cory. Audenture. Yeah. And then a 10, Scott, if you want to round
39:59it out, I don't know, man. Is it, is it batherson? Good. I don't really love Swamon, but I guess he could be considered in the argument. Yeah, yeah, it's probably. I would take, I would probably, I don't know. I think if any of those goalies that have gone in that 10 to 15 range in recent years became Swamon, their teams would be very happy. Swamon's, Swamon's one of his nights. It's, it's probably Swamon. On a current game basis, it's probably Josh Norris, but obviously there's a major asterix there. I think, I think Buffalo would love to trade Josh Norris for Jeremy Swamon if they could do it, right? So, yeah, like I said, I think Josh Norris, when he's healthy, is an outstanding hockey player, but it's, yeah, it's been a rough go, if that late, the last two big of a pretty much, pretty much his whole career. Not bad for a class that that had all that chaos at the top back in 2017 turned out they had no, no, no, no number one overall pick to maybe like three or four. Number one overall pick
41:02worthy players in that class. Let's take a quick break right there. We'll circle back and we'll talk about the 2026 class. And maybe if there's anything we can take from 2017 as we analyze it. Hi, this is Farnoosh Tarabi from So Money with Farnoosh Tarabi. And today, I want to talk to you about Boost Mobile. Quick money tip. Stop paying a carrier tax. If your phone bill feels trapped in a pricey plan, this is your sign to unlock savings. Boost Mobile helps you reset your spending with the $25 unlimited forever plan. You can bring your own phone, pay $25 and get unlimited wireless forever. And that simple switch can unlock up to $600 in savings a year. That's money you could put towards paying down debt, investing or something that actually brings you joy. Though savings are based on average annual single line payment of AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile customers compared to 12 months on the Boost Mobile Unlimited plan as of January 2026. For full offer details, visit BoostMobile.com. When it comes to managing money, forget the hype
42:07and look at the results. Bill has a trillion dollars of secure payments powering our bill pay tools. Instead of just moving money, Bill is powering the financial operations of nearly half a million customers. So stop the guesswork and start scaling with the proven choice. Ready to talk with an expert? Visit bill.com slash proven to get started. And grab a $250 gift card as a thank you. Terms and conditions apply. See offer page for details. The youth mental health crisis is growing and social media is a major driver. Kids are spending up to nine hours a day on screens, often unsupervised, and studies show a direct link to anxiety, depression, and even suicidal thoughts. That's where Gab comes in. Gab offers safer phones and watches for kids with no social media, tailored to every age, offering the right tech at the right time, or tech in steps. From GPS tracking enabled watches for younger kids to phones with parent enabled apps for teens, each device allows kids to more safely grow their independence.
43:09Visit gab.com slash get gab and use code get gab for an exclusive offer. That's g-a-b-b.com forward slash get gab gab tech in steps independence for them peace of mind for parents. All right we are back and Scott you had a 2026 draft list come out this week and I wonder with everything we just talked about kind of looking back at the 17 class. Is there anything that you think really applies in how you're analyzing or expect to be analyzing this year's draft class? There's always certain debates that are kind of universal here. Yeah I think the two universal debates that come to mind in the conversation we just had is the smaller group of D where we've talked a lot about last year no sub six foot D, Cam reads the only six foot D taken in the first round. This group has a number of those guys all of a sudden and frankly next year's draft I just started sort of putting the finishing touches on my first list for next year's draft which will be out next week and it's it looks similar like
44:14the top D and next year's class led by landed Dupont are kind of fit into that that sort of size category and then Corey and I have had some interesting conversations about the sort of late first second round 80 90 point CHL wing types that are in that 511 range and where they fit in this class we almost we couldn't quite settle on a number but we almost settled on a number for whether one of Mathis Preston Igor Shilov Thomas Charenko and Nikita Klepov what whether one of those guys sort of goes in the first round or where those guys fit once the big names once the true premium guys are off the board I think that's going to be a conversation that we're having on draft day and coming out of draft day and into next year some of those guys are going to put up big numbers in junior hockey next year there's a chance that Klepov goes to Michigan State next year and has a good year on a good team and so that conversation is always interesting for me because you
45:16get through the the 6261 centers with skill you get through the premium D and then what happens with that sort of second tier and we had Yamamoto in 2017 and 12 and in 2017 that we just talked about and then Brantstrom on the D side in 2017 that we chatted about that for me is an interesting sort of second layer to the draft conversation this year because those players are like we've had some highs with Nikita Klepov he's one of the leading so he might actually lead the OHL depending on how this weekend goes he might lead the OHL and scoring this year Preston's been banged up but Preston's had some real highs with hockey Canada that that conversation around those kids I think is an interesting layer once you get through the chase reads and and the true sort of big boys I believe the exact words wasn't a conversation I believe we you had a wager which I offered and you declined I think it was top 32 it was Corey insisted on top 30 and I offered top 32 that one of those guys goes top 32 and Corey I think now well I think Klepov's probably going top 32 so I
46:23think that that this wager was back in November so I should have taken the bet is what you're saying yeah yeah yeah I think yeah I think it was a mistake I don't know if she loves maybe I think Preston's a big baby where do you have him on your list right now I have Preston right at the back end like 30 29 30 27 I got I'm looking I I have him like way later than that like I think he was just he's not going in the first year yeah I think he was he was really bad this year I he's been compared to what I thought he's been good in Vancouver and Spokane was tough like Spokane was a tough situation for him I think he's really talented the feet the skill are tremendous but he's just there's there's a lot of he'll be in his game I think he'll be at U18s and have a nice U18s as well yeah on the small defense point Scott a guy that you've loved this whole draft cycle is Ryan Lynn and I wonder like as we talk about some of the guys of that profile who didn't pan out what do you see in Lynn that makes you confident enough that he is different from those guys
47:25to rank him as highly as you do I just think the combination of the smarts and the competitiveness some of those guys had the smarts none of them really had the competitiveness he's got the offense he's got the statistical track record the pedigree all of that but it's it's how hard he plays how hard he competes how smart he is on both sides of it the way that he defends we've talked about that a lot already on the show but that for me is what sort of distinguishes him from your your late first or early second round do you at that size like I just think he's one of the very best players in this age group right now now that doesn't mean he will be one of the very best NHL players but I think because of how intelligent he is on both sides of it and because of how hard he plays I have more confidence that he will remain sort of as one of the better players in this class and I think he's also another he's like he's going to go to U18s and they're going to play him 25 minutes a night on that blue line for Canada and I think that will also help his case after playing
48:30on a pretty poor Vancouver team this year a couple players on your list that we haven't spent a ton of time on yet this draft cycle and I'm sure we will as it gets closer but that was as good a time as any is you know with so much focus on Evar Stenberg and on Vigo Bjork out of Sweden but Marcus Nordmark and Elton Hermenson are also lottery pick range guys for you and I don't think we've talked about it maybe more than a minute or two so far. Yeah Corey talked last week on the show about his sort of top eight group I've got a top 12 group and then right behind that top 12 group is Nordmark and Hermenson Nordmark is as talented a winger as there is in this class after the big two like extremely extremely talented has had some real highs at five or six different events now with with the Swedish national team five nations go back all the way back to U17s in Sarnia a year ago has the numbers haven't quite popped domestically like they have internationally with Nordmark but just very very high end skill package and then Hermenson's got the pro track
49:36record also a very skilled player a little bit bigger a little bit stronger than Nordmark maybe not quite as dynamic with the puck but can score and Hermenson has the track record of having done it at a pro level in hockey alspenskin this year and been a really strong contributor for them I think he scored almost 15 goals for them at that level this year 13 or 14 goals if I'm not mistaken those two guys I'll be interested to see where they go on draft day I had a conversation with an amateur scout last week when I was doing a poll for a McKenna piece and I got talking with him about some of the other wingers and he posed that same question to me of like where do you think Nordmark and Hermenson go because I like them a lot and they're very very talented but if those guys are tricky to sort of slot and I think they're probably going to both end up sort of in the middle of the first round somewhere maybe one of them in the early 20s but they're they're like once you get past the premium guys they're among the only players that you can look at and say okay this kid has top six potential power play potential that those kind of tools well then the one last
50:38thing I want to get you with Scott is there is a name on this list that first of all I hope I get correctly Seamus Ignatavicious and he's from Lithuania and I know that our listeners really love when guys pop up from unexpected places here so tell me a little bit about Seamus Ignatavicious please talk about an unexpected place right like this isn't even a kid from Bell like this isn't already left Shunov this isn't some of the Latvians that have come through in recent years this is a kid from Lithuania they just they aren't just like a second or third tier hockey playing country they're a fourth or fifth tier hockey playing country has played a lot of hockey in Switzerland obviously is now playing pro in the NL with Genevse Served over there and has been a good player like a regular contributing player for them he's big he's strong he skates well he's very very competitive he's heavy I don't think there's like he I've seen make some skill places here when I've watched him on the Insta I don't think he's like a skill guy but he's got quick hands and he's got a
51:43decent release and another guy who scored some goals at a good very good pro level in in the NL this year but yeah just where he comes from makes it as interesting as anything because he's he's a unicorn in a lot of ways and maybe we had that a little bit with Brandt's Ignigard and Solberg but even Norway seems to be producing kids maybe not for the NHL draft but there are a lot of top scorers in the J20 level for example who are from Norway now and they're feeding players into this Swedish junior ranks at a decent clip and Lithuania obviously is not that and they're a world championship too like I know they're not like a top 10 country but they you know top 15 hockey country Norway is like as Lithuania even in the B pool for the men's world championship I don't I think I think they are I think they are I think they are I couldn't sell you on top of my head it kind of reminds of of Liam like god bless him but Liam Kirk yeah he was interesting but I think like Ignatavicious was a guy that is a good pro scouts
52:51yes scouts were definitely going yes making special trips to see they are in the B pool just so the art of Lithuania and listeners aren't aren't yeah but the B pool like that's that's a pretty it's still they're they haven't been up in the senior division for for some time and yeah I mean like it's it's it's a really interesting I I personally always find it interesting to see where players are kind of coming from and different you know guys that kind of beat the odds and and and and our special but yeah I mean like scouts were definitely taking special trips to go see him in Switzerland I'm sure you had to twist their arm to go over to Switzerland but you know either way like it's really you know when you see players like this and especially in a year like this where we're we're you know we're really scraping around for prospects I feel like when we get in outside of this this first round I think when you start looking at depth there's always going to be guys that pop but you know when you have this a player with this athletic profile that's playing aggressively as he is in pro and and with some maturity in his game I think that that's that's always going to resonate so you know hey yeah I I dare definitely you know I had talked to
53:58the teams a while back that that we're talking about him as a potential you know late first early second round draft pick which is probably where he ends up and so yeah if you're if you're a Lithuanian hockey player by way of Texas by birth I believe but you know those are it's a pretty special thing so he's definitely one of those players I'm I'm gonna be intrigued to see ultimately what happens with him yeah a name and a story to learn as we start getting closer to the 2026 NHL draft that is going to do it for us today thanks for listening to this episode of the athletic hockey show prospect series you're going to of course catch more of Chris over at Flowhockey on his podcast called up and more of Scott and Corey's stuff on this draft class and many more on the athletic calm we'll talk to you soon still listing your home address on business documents stable gives you a permanent business address one you can use for the IRS banks vendors you name it so you can keep things professional and keep your personal address private stable also digitizes all the mail that comes to that
55:01address accessible from our secure online dashboard which makes it easy to manage your mail from wherever you are no PO boxes no miss mail just one less thing to think about as you scale sign up for a virtual address today at use stable dot com slash pod and get 50% off your first three months of a grow or scale plan that's use stable dot com slash pod your business moves fast your mail should too investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmers market you can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything maybe you go for some free range self-directed investing or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse you can even get help from a dedicated advisor that's full service wealth management mix match and change your mind whenever you want because at Schwab you can invest your way no matter your goals or appetite for investing Schwab has everything you need all in one place visit Schwab dot com to learn more a password manager should be the first security purchase you make for your team why because compromise passwords are
56:05the number one way bad actors attack companies and small businesses are their favorite targets but unlike a lot of security challenges passwords actually have a pretty simple solution one password lets you manage all your businesses credentials so you can feel confident that your data stays secure as your company grows find out more at one password dot com slash special offer and start securing every login
More episodes
More from The Athletic Hockey Show

How To Fix: Detroit Red Wings
The Athletic Hockey Show

How to Fix: Winnipeg Jets
The Athletic Hockey Show

NHL Draft 2022: What did we get wrong?
The Athletic Hockey Show

NHL Redrafts: 2025, 2024, 2023
The Athletic Hockey Show