On Those Nights, Something Was Watching: Red Eyes & Shadows

Some childhood memories never fade, no matter how hard you try to bury them.
In this episode, we hear two chilling true stories told by people who were far too young to understand what they were seeing. The first begins with a single night, a terrifying sound, and glowing red eyes watching from outside a bedroom window, an experience two sisters would not speak about for years. The second unfolds across decades inside a quiet house on the east side of Toledo, Ohio, where a shadowy presence seems tied to one specific room… and one family.
Whether these encounters were warnings, hauntings, or something far darker, both stories share one unsettling truth: some things don’t go away just because you grow up.
Have a story? TrueScaryStory.com
Editing and sound design by Sarah Vorhees Wendel of VW Sound. Additional production by Edwin Covarrubias and the Scary FM team.